Agnostic.com

9 1

Any musicians on here?
In addition any thoughts on playing religious music when You aren’t?

Gonzogopher 6 May 8
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

9 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

Recently I was offered a few dollars to fill in on piano for a Sunday morning church service when their regular guy was out of town. I was glad to do it. It helped that this was a rather progressive and casual congregation. I didn’t tell anyone about my lack of belief and doing this as an occasional one-off thing doesn’t strike me as unethical. However, if I were offered a regular job to do this every week for a particular church, I don’t think I could accept that in good conscience. Does that make sense?

0

I'm a violist and cellist in various Baroque, Classical and Romantic period ensembles. It is hard to avoid some linkage with Christianity in that milieu as the church was the main patron/employer of musicians from the Renaissance to modern times. But, a gig's a gig. In fact, that is how many of the greatest composers and musicians looked at things. Mozart was notorious. He was a freemason in a seriously catholic country. The local archbishop hated his guts because of his irreverence, but Mozart was the rock-star of his day so the church couldn't touch him. Similarly, Bach was a Kapellmeister for much of his life, but never stopped looking for a job on civvie street. Both of these men wrote magnificent "religious" music, but music is music and if you don't listen to the goofy lyrics, most of which are in German or Italian anyway, you would never know.

0

I recorded two CDs worth of Gospel, Spirituals and Pop religious music for my aunts. They are all nice Church ladies. I'm not religious at all. But I like Gospel and Spirituals, it's good music. I've also subbed in a church band on occassion. Didn't like the music so much, and it got redundant--the same 4 or 5 songs every weekend. Kinda glad when the gig was over.

1

I've performed countless classical choral works. Most were religious themed.

1

I've never played in a church, but as far as songs, I'll play it if it's a good song. There are plenty of songs about things I've never done, or wouldn't do, and religion isn't really any different. It's playing a part.

0

That’s some great sound, straight out of 1967. Beautiful voice and the rhoades!

0

I’ve never had the opportunity to play any gospel music. I suppose if I was paid to play it I would, but I personally don’t listen to it.

1

I try, I have a resonator in my collection too. Religious shit is not in my repertoire.

JK666 Level 7 May 8, 2018
2

I’m a singer, songwriter, and play primitive percussion. I’ll get some links to my rings up soon. My most recent project was described as “haunted graveyard neo-folk” and “campfire neo-folk” we were called Black Light onnthe Brave Mysteries label.

I missed the religious part - my band did a hymn to Nyarlathotep, “Obsidian Pharoh” it’s a bunch of lines stolen from Nitsche, repurposed for pretend mythos cult singing lol. We also did a song from the POV of a Valkyrie, and one from the POV of a Siren, well it’s like a Siren spell song for a film I made. I also love to sing that Mothra worship song that the people of Infant Islsnd sing in the Mothra movies.

I’m not skilled enough that I have any cause to grapple with good music made for the theocracy, I play an elk hoof shaker and a bodrhan and that kind of crap, my stuff is all campfire music.

We were also lucky to get to play in the Gates if Heaven, a beautiful and historic old Synagogue - now a lovely secular venue, The space does have a beautiful and special atmosphere due to the care and reverence in the design, and the mood imparted by the solemn and lovely history of it being Wisconsin’s oldest Synagogue lovingly preserved.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:76671
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.