Agnostic.com
  1. Agnostic
  2. Posts
  3. Philosophy & Meaning

11 2

Which one is atheist?

You run into two guys. The first one says: "I don't believe that God exists." And the second one says: "I believe that God does not exists". Which one would you say is more accurately atheist?

  • 13 votes
  • 4 votes
#Atheist #First #god
Ammar1992 4 Dec 29
Share
Submit

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

11 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

Level 8

Both meet the criteria. Atheism is the lack of belief in a God or gods or the belief that no God or gods exist. That's the dictionary definition. The latter is a subset of the former, as one who believes no deities exist necessarily lacks belief in such deities. The American Atheists specify "lack of belief" on their website.

1

Level 4

They both lack a belief in a god so they are both equally atheist.

1

Level 8

I would say the 1st is closer to though not an agnostic, I feel the 2nd comment more emphatic yet the first must be more accurate and the existence of god cannot be proven.

0

Level 9

I lean ever so slightly towards the first, but not enough to actually vote. I don't think there is enough difference in what they are saying to justify spending time to debate it.

1

Level 7

The latter is anti-theist not atheist.

Atheism is a response to the theist's claim that a god(s) exists. It is not a claim that gods don't exist. The burden of proof remains with the person making the claim.

If you state that god does not exist, you have a burden of proof to back up your assertion.

Gtear 👍
2

Level 7

I voted for guy #1 because his statement is grammatically correct, and therefore he is more rational.

I knew that some "smart" guy would make this "brilliant" comment, that's why I tried to edit it but it seems that there is an issue with editing.

@Ammar1992 I thought you put it in there to get picked up...
0

Level 6

"I don't believe", to me, is more accurate, but depends on the way a person speaks. Plus I have never, ever heard and one say "I believe that god does not exist"

0

Level 7

I think the key is "I don't believe" which underscores the notion that atheism is not a belief, but rather the lack of belief.

godef Level 7 Dec 29, 2017
Reply

First and foremost, when I am asked that question I must define what they mean by god. Someone will ask if I believe and perhaps I say yes I love ALLAH , then they say oh not that god. perhaps I say Jesus and they say oh yes he is the only one
My idea is god is not necessarily a religion , rather a concept for discussion

@Diarmaede The difference between the two phrases is nuanced, and it really comes down to rhetoric. Too many people want to twist the notion that "I believe there is no God" and make out atheism just to be another belief system, aka a religion, which is of course nonsense. I resist that notion by declaring a lack of belief; I don't go to any temples and pray to non-gods.

@EMC2 - Do/did you work for EMC? In contracted in Hopkinton for a few years.

@godef
Actually the difference is huge, because the second one is actively expressing that God doesn't exist, thus he should proved evidence for it
While the first one simply does not believe that God exist, maybe because he didn't see enough evidence, but he is not required defend his belief because he doesn't have belief in the first place.
0

Level 9

Is second one right or wrong?

The second one slightly assumes that person has evidence. It makes it sound like a faith based claim because there isn't evidence available that negates every possible god. However, that doesn't really make it wrong just not easy to defend in debate. Personally, believing he doesn't exist seems reasonable because few people take a disbelief position on anything else. Like bigfoot. You can't proof he doesn't exist so why would we take a position of believe he doesn't vs I don't believe. Just semantics but one sounds close minded to other people.
2

Level 7

What about I know God does not exist.

How can you know that?

@Ammar1992 from the knowledge shared on human evolution, from the knowledge shared on evolution of concepts like religion, God's. I wonder now will you ask me how do I know superman does not exist.

@Srijith This is actually a very good question, because it's impossible to prove that something doesn't exist,
So,
how do you know superman does not exist?

@Srijith - I think it's time to drop the capital thing for god.

@GoldenDoll yes. It's the auto correct. I generally do correct it. Forgot this time
1

Level 6

Atheism is disbelief not another belief.

Write Comment

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

Share this post

Copy Link

Related Groups More

Christopher Hitchens Fans
80 members

Categories

You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:11271
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.