Agnostic.com

14 0

Buddhism

Don't know if this should be in a different category, but I don't think it matters.

Several people have Buddha as part of their avatar name.

Do you consider Buddism a religion, a lifestyle, a practice ...? Really interested.

I've been thinking of making it part of the Journey, but don't know where or how to start.

Thanks

By phil217
Actions Follow Post Like

Post a comment Add Source Add Photo

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

14 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

I think the answer is all of the above. I just depends on how you approach the practice. There is some really good stuff there if you strip away all of the rebirth and karma nonsense. I'm a fan of Stephen Batchelor. He spent time as a monk in both the Tibetan and Zen traditions before becoming disenfranchised with all organized forms of the practice. He went on to write a number of books, such as Buddhism without Beliefs and Confessions of an Athiest Buddhist which have been very helpful to me.

0

Imho, Buddhism is totally a religion. Some people practice something like a buddhism-lite, but that doesn't make Buddhism not a religion. They have magic books, myths, dogma, priests, etc.. and once people get deep into it, they talk in jibber jabber just like other religions. I mean karma, reincarnation, the whole bodhi tree incident.. definitely a religion.

0

It all depends on how you define religion and Buddhism. If religion is a set of beliefs, mainly spiritual type of beliefs, then it is.
If you defined religion to be a belief in a higher power, probably not, unless your definition of Buddhism includes such.

LauraUU Level 6 Mar 16, 2018
0

I ran the gamut from Southern Baptist to agnostic to atheist to anti-theist to Buddhist to Vedic sage. What I learned is if you label me then you minimize me. I no longer have any need for supreme beings to give me assurance. The balance of the universe is my security.

It's necessary in this context to offer a warning aout the knee-jerk immediate refusal to acknowledge anything that seems to be a god or deity. Often the being one might call a god or a deity is no more than the personification of a concept. This was a necessity for telling stories to carry the religious ceremonies from northern and western europe to the Indus valley by the aryans. Instead of saying "Jaeed crossed the great river and ate some fruit to quell his hunger" the story-teller would say "Jaeed snuck past the sleeping river and slayed the dragon Ungar - who would still arise the next evening". This is where most of the "gods" of the vedas come from. It was a necessity to embellish stories as memory aids until sanskrit was developed to document the same. Thats not the case in every instance ... but it is for many.

2

Philosophy.

A religion has to have a supernatural being that controls us or the universe. The Buddha never claimed to be a god or in control of us. Further, the supernatural beings of buddhism, the Bodhisattva's, were humans that had achieved their supernatural designation by being the best humans they could be; they are super-natural by being super-human. These Bodhisattva's also don't control humans nor the universe the way religious gods are purported to do; they only affect themselves and through that affect, not control, the universe around them

Further evidence that Buddhism is not a religion is that Buddhism doesn't prohibit the belief in other religions while every religion prohibits the belief in any other religion.

0

It is for sure a religion..

Charlene Level 9 Mar 3, 2018
1

I lived in the Republic of Korea (South Korea) for several years and dabbled in Buddhism with both Koreans and expatriates from some western countries. I did not feel I was worshiping a deity, but learning a way of life. Didn't stick with it, but felt I learned somethings which make my life more pleasant -- as well of those around me.

1

Buddhism is a religion in the east, but it is not necessarilyy considered one in the west. A lot of this has to do with the western mindset. When practitioners first brought it over to the US decades ago, they had to adapt it so that it could be more accessible.

bleurowz Level 8 Mar 3, 2018
0

It depends. I have read where many Buddhists consider their path a philosophical one. Some even say that there is no "god" in Buddhism. However, in Nepal, the "living goddess" is worshipped by both Hindus and Buddhists. This smacks of religion to me. [npr.org]

Like Catholicism/Protestantism/Greek Orthodox sects (for lack of a better word) and Christianity and the Sunnis/Shites in Islam, any philosophy/religion is what the believers make of it.

1

I consider it a philosophy.

1

I was under the impression Buddhism was more of a philosophy and did not require a diety

0

I am an atheist, and I practice Buddhism. I am not very good at it...but I practice every day. Buddism is not a religion as I see it because Buddhists do not worship a god or higher being. I learned a lot about Buddhism on YouTube. Richard Gere has a series of videos about Buddism and if you look it up you will find a generous amount of videos on just about anything you want to know. Here is a good start:

Thanks Lucky.

0

Regardless of what I may think, it is considered a religion by society. If it were mandatory that I have a religion it would be Buddhism or Taoism.

jlynn37 Level 8 Mar 2, 2018
2
  1. nope, not a religion. it's a discipline with no "higher being" except yourself.

  2. seek refuge in the triple gem (darma, sanga, and Buddha)

Where can I find the Triple Gem?

The triple gem is a bit of a misnomer. It means that you seek refuge in the Buddha, the sangha, and the dharma. The Buddha, generally, refers to Shakyamuni Buddha. The sangha means others who have gone through the search you are encountering and taken refuge in Buddhist thought or really just any vedic thought - a community. And the dharma meaning the texts and writing and other teachings of this community. This is seeking refuge in the triple gem.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text 'q:31386'.
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content read full disclaimer.
  • Agnostic.com is a non-profit community for atheists, agnostics, humanists, freethinkers, skeptics and others!