Agnostic.com

4 6

Top Florida health official on leave over support for vaccination

[bbc.com]

xenoview 8 Jan 20
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

4 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

I think it would be great if Democrats win FL this year. I don't really care how it's done.

1

I suspect this won't prevail in likely court challenge(s).

1

Freaking absurd.

And it is irresponsible and pathetic, as he says.

7

Politics interfering in medicine...

So, if getting a vaccination is a "personal choice", according to the Republicans, why isn't abortion?? Or same-sex marriage? Or gender identity? They want to mandate all that shit that affects nobody else, but not something that saves your life and the lives around you.

Please don't expect anybody in the Rethuglican Party to be rational, reasonable or humane. The selfish bastards are in it purely for themselves, and they perceive anybody with different views or different values as being extremely dangerous.

I don't hear much "hue and cry" about government restrictions on 'personal choice' regarding suicide and organ selling.
I would think government should allow for religious liberty exemptions. Deciding where/whether the limit(s) exist, IMO, can be problematic.

"why isn't abortion??"
Regardless of my position, I don't claim/imply/infer that there isn't another (potential/not-yet-born) life involved for which government(s) claim legitimate interest(s).

"gender identity"
Regardless of my position, some other folks have (some, somewhat) legitimate interest(s) (i.e. privacy) when non cis folks behave against their wants/interest/principles. (i.e. locker rooms/bathrooms, sports)

@FearlessFly "Potential" life is a misnomer. Every sperm or egg is a potential life (that's why the Catholic Church says every sperm is sacred)(no, wait, that was Monty Python). There is a line between fetus and human being, which medically speaking is when the forebrain develops. The body itself aborts spontaeously all the time. It's not he government's place to decide whose health is paramount, the woman or the unborn child.

I don't think trans people are going into bathrooms/locker rooms/ wherever to get a gander at their cis counterparts' dangly bits. This is the exact same argument that was made about gay people and it doesn't hold water.

@Paul4747 Without disagreeing with your positions . . .

I contend that, even irrespective of religion, government(s) have legitimate interest(s) for 'rule-making', regardless of those of us who have counter arguments.

Well said. Thanks for saying it.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:646190
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.