Agnostic.com
9 6

This is hypocrisy. Québec has made long strides to become secular but this little nagging issue is hypocritical to the path moving forward

[friendlyatheist.patheos.com]

François Legault won Quebec’s provincial elections last week and will soon become the next premier. He has already vowed to stop government workers — including cops and teachers — from wearing religious symbols like hijabs and yarmulkes and turbans “in order to protect Quebec’s secular society.” It’s a move that trounces on religious freedom in the name of religious neutrality and creates far more problems than it solves.

But if religious symbols have to go, then what about the large crucifix that hangs in Quebec’s National Assembly…?

Lukian 8 Oct 12
Share
You must be a member of this group before commenting. Join Group

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

9 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

and a crucifix necklace? or ring? how does that work?

AmmaRE007 Level 7 Nov 7, 2018

if the said person works for the government (civil servant) then they would not be allowed to wear that during while working.

2

Not sure why that surprises you but the Pure Laine element is still alive and well in much of Quebec society

Pure Laine culture does not equate to practicing Catholicism.

1

The crucifix was put in place in the National Assembly in 1936 by Prime Minister Maurice Duplessis, very right-wing and very close to the Catholic Church. The era he was in power is now known here as the "Grande Noirceur", the Great Darkness.
I didn't vote for Legault's party, I agree with his policy on secularism, but I think the crucifix at the National Assembly should be removed.

0

I think all we have to do is look to literal insanity happening in the states an the fact they are going through the second uncivil war this time its a war of words mostly political.I think that same war of words is happening in Quebec.Going back to the states secular groups challenged the hypocracy to symbols by errecting a statue of the satin right next to the 10 commandments i forget what bible belt town that was there wasa video on youtube about that.

1

How about the mummified heart of that priest in the Oratory in Montreal, creepy as fuck.

Surfpirate Level 9 Oct 12, 2018

creepy but not illegal since it's a place of worship. (you meant the St-Joseph Oratory right?)

@Lukian That's the one, the place where idiots climb up stone stairs on their hands and knees so they can be cured of their arthritis. If they want to keep their creepy heart on display then they should pay business taxes like every other going concern.

@Surfpirate agree

"Hey kiddo! Put that back in the jar!"
(local stand-up joke about that heart)

3

His reasoning for letting it remain is that the crucifix is a part of Quebec heritage. If that is the case.. it should be put in a museum where such icons and relics of history can be observed and studied within the larger context of Quebec's colorful back story.

Davekp Level 8 Oct 12, 2018
1

They all have to go then.

2

They must have an answer? None yet?

The crucifix should never have been there in the first place though.

Umbral Level 8 Oct 12, 2018

true but it is and it should be removed.

6

Yes, there is clearly a double standard.

Write Comment

Recent Visitors 29

Photos 323 More

Posted by bookofmoronsAlways love to share this at Thanksgiving (Although Fiona stripped our fall foliage off so colours are few and far between this year . . sigh)

Posted by QuidamOutrepontQuebec elections: I'm in!!! On October 3rd, Quebecers will elect the members of their provincial legislative assembly.

Posted by godfree2Canadian beaver From the archives

Posted by bookofmoronsIts true when you think about it

Posted by Heather2367Message from Rogers

Posted by QuidamOutrepontSome major change

Posted by bookofmoronsheard that nonsense from the local and Ottawa tantrum convoy at least a dozen times. If you're gonna "overthrow the government", you should at least know which country you're in.

Posted by SnowyOwlJust for Laughs. :D

Posted by QuidamOutrepont"Don't be sad. We could be in Ottawa, living in tyranny."

Posted by SnowyOwlSoon the occupiers who feel privileged will realize that privileges are not rights and hopefully leave and go home.

Posted by SnowyOwlIt's easy to believe that you are in the majority when you live in an echo chamber.

Posted by actofdogNinety percent of Canadian truckers are vaccinated so the ''freedom convoy'' is useless and has no end game, plus it is illegal now they only had a two day permit.

Posted by actofdogNinety percent of Canadian truckers are vaccinated so the ''freedom convoy'' is useless and has no end game, plus it is illegal now they only had a two day permit.

Posted by bookofmoronsSeems history does repeat itself

Posted by bookofmoronsand there you have it

Posted by MsHolidayAn immunocompromised man who ran across Canada as an act to unite and to raise funds for medical research. 💔

  • Top tags#Canada #video #world #friends #DonaldTrump #government #god #religion #hope #religious #money #laws #reason #children #book #hell #hello #freedom #vote #wife #Song #earth #atheism #belief #liberal #church #fear #minister #federal #media #community #rights #Bible #death #Humanist #Police #weather #dogs #USA #oil #conservative #military #truth #Atheist #guns #mother #politics #animals #voters #secular ...

    Members 437Top

    Moderator