Agnostic.com

18 4

Tonight is Chirstmas Eve and this is my first post on this site. How many of you contemplate the relevance of the Holiday Season in relation to a lacking of religious points of view? I reside in an extremely religious town and for them, today is the birthday of Jesus. To me... this is just another day, aside from all the social mores and norms. Do we merely celebrate as a way to appease our loved ones or because the tradition has been ingrained upon our psyche all our lives?

Sadoi 7 Dec 24
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

18 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

I grew up in the Bible belt near Kansas City in the 50's and 60's. There were more churches in our little town you wouldn't believe it. I stopped believing long ago but I do still celebrate Christmas. I believe in the family and children. I go to a local church to hear the Christmas hymns my father loved. It is a way to remember him. I love to see the lights in children's eyes. I love the few moments when we act our best. It doesn't happen for very long or for everyone but it is our hope for the future.

That is a lovely, well thought out comment, sir. And I do agree with you 110%. It has manifested itself into Tradition and Tradition holds much weight. 🙂

1

This particular Holiday can be deep or shallow. It is up to us to create, and maintain, that depth.

It has become a commercial holiday, which is very shallow. That said, I do believe that we can make it a holiday about celebrating our relationships, our imaginations, and our crafts, with one another which can deepen the holiday.

I have no issue with giving a gift to one another and also none with the idea of a store bought gift... but, I LOVE the concept of giving an adventure, or something crafted of your own skills and I think that we should strive to make those gifts, the adventures and the hand crafted ones, the cherished gifts. We should in fact, downplay the store bought gifts, though we still need to acknowledge that it is a gift and must be valued as such.

Not saying it's easy, just saying that we need to find positive ways to move away from it being a commercial holiday and one of family, and home life. Then, I think, we find ourselves in a better place... no matter what you think of the holiday from an aspect of faith.

I tend to only accept gifts that were hand made for me. I do not like people to spend money on me. I hate that. I don't like anything that is over the top expensive. I think it is a waste of money. I don't even like jewelry that is overly fancy. I prefer it simple too, esp during the holidays. I agree! Store bought, its a holiday of commercialism. That is the downfall to it. I AGREE!!

1

I personally think Christmas is a great day, not in a way you think. It's a great day because it rewinds family ties and reunions, it sets the entire global in a happier mood, nothing makes me happy than seeing a happpier society,even if it's for a day. And no other day where people feel relaxed and at ease with themselves than this time of the year...even the poorest of the society---like me, find a reason to be happy.

I actually... agree with you on that one, sir! This is true. I just wish we could find a way to extend this One Day onto a larger calendar of days.

1

For the family. I hate this holiday

Family for me too

2

I participate in the capitalistic form of the holiday. The holiday, on a religious level is BS. So we can choose to have fun on this not so special extra day off. I even put up a small black tree to appease visitors. However, go with your gut. Sometimes we do things even if they're silly because it's nice to have family around.

Boxes Level 3 Dec 30, 2017

Those are also valid facts you mentioned. I try not to invest my cash into it as much as humanly possible. I put limitations on it. I do love that many people I rarely have a chance to see trickle back home for he holidays. Those perks, i cannot deny!

1

I wish I could ignore it, skip it, and let it be any other day. It'd only fun because of kids. It was supposed to be my niece's first, but she died a few months ago...so that's how I reached that conclusion and that's where I am right now. I was going to partake in tradition, not belief -- it's never been about Jesus, even when I was Christian. I've reduced it emotionally to capitalist propaganda.

Cwen Level 4 Dec 27, 2017

Bingo. I think you hit the nail on the head. It was the same for me even when I was a believer. I just sat in the church to appease my grandmother, my family. I was typically bored into a coma whenever we had to "pray in christmas" or "pray in the new year." However, the good side: Potluck!! All those grandmas sure knew how to toss together a decent, god loving spread for the church meal! haha Gotta find those silver linings!! 😉

2

I celebrate given any excuse to because I enjoy it. For me, year end celebrating is special as I usually get time off from work, coinciding with others in my family also being off. I relish getting to be with my favorite people for quality time.

Zster Level 8 Dec 25, 2017

That is certainly true. The holiday has created a time when most human being have time off and are able to be together, in a number of cases, it is the Only time they can all get together. Those are the things I love about the holiday season, too. 🙂

2

I have been a non-believer for 60 years. In my adult life, I have always celebrated Christmas as a time for he warmth of family, as a time for good will to all, and as a time for sharing -- without any religious trappings at all.

That is how I see it myself. Agreed.

3

I'm not a Christian, but I celebrate Christmas because it is about nostalgia and family for me. I like the lights, and festive atmosphere, and of course presents are fun to give and get. Lots of good food and people making time for each other. I do NOT allow it to overextend my bank or energy though.

That is a good balance to have.

1

It seems the value we receive viewing life unfiltered has a price. A certain amount of social alienation is definitely one. I assume, that by residing in one of the most beautiful area’s I’ve found, the cost is living in my small town community is both accepting and avoiding their overflowing basket of beliefs 😉 That likely expands out to our nation's; if by choice or tolerance, we appreciate where we’re at, we’re obliged to tolerate what we can’t change...

Though remaining a tiny element of change, with time, you get better dodging the negative ... and watching so many lives revolve around this ‘one day’ for me has become negative. But I figure, let the children play! I can definitely find other things to do. And alone, it’s one luxury I have ~

Varn Level 8 Dec 25, 2017

Yes. Even as a child I found the hypocracy of One Day a year, one small window in time, where we are Encouraged to be kind. And one day a year when we are basically wallet raped because we are forced to supply gifts, otherwise, we are assholes, right? hah! And yes, this is the price, but I would rather pay this price than to be blind and in the dark. I rejoice in the knowledge because for me, I don't need to Waste my time crediting some... big dude in the sky for my failures or my successes and I am not governed by a set of rules that box my intelligence and my yearning for experiences by keeping my freedoms held hostage. I also believe if there Were a god, there is no way on Earth we could understand how to comprehend his/hers intentions with our mere, human brains. And any god I would believe in would, first and foremost, chastize the behaviours of Most Christians, religious folk in general, the ones that insight violence or shoving of their points of view down the throats of the unwilling. Any god I would believe could exist would be more so benign... not all Fire and Brimstone. Religious texts as so versed in such a way that it was Clearly the mind of a Man who dreamed that fantastical shit up. I mean, thats how I see it anyway. I might as well read Grimm's Fairytales to that of the bible. I would get just as much insight, I am sure. lol

@Sadoi811 Impressive. … ‘wallet raped,’ perfect. You’ve put it together, I feel I have too, so why can’t everyone (present company excluded)? And why should our free thinking be so rare, or feared? Are we that exceptional, god-like? ...or is humanity as screwed up as it appears…

Dog damn - I can’t shake this place! Granted, I’m ‘home alone,’ on X-mess, thousands of miles from former friends and family -- but I’ve fought online for many years supporting Atheist Rights, and would be ‘lucky’ to have 1 or 2 ‘like minded’ folks chime in to help. Here, and relatively new at that - I’m surrounded! And to read a response like yours, then on to another … wow, and thank you ~

@Varn Aww why thank you. I much appreciate kind words based upon the intelligence ratio of the compliment giver. haha! I am also thousands of miles away from my own family. I understand that feeling. I do have my children with me though so that is a something. It would be nice to have elder members of my family around me during the holidays though, but I am still okay, with or without. 🙂 Maybe as we get older, we begin to grow more comfortable within our own skin so alone time isn't a feared thing or a status curse. I enjoy being alone actually. haha! I consider it a compliment from me to me considering I truly enjoy my Own company. lol! Ego aside. I also agree with you about the quality of responses and of people here. Why didn't someone think of this long ago?? Its been a pretty sublime experience for me thus far, too!

@Varn oh yes, and we are feared because we are considered void of morals if we are void of god. Or dare we say We are God to ourselves. That is blasphemy, you know! haha! Only unorthodox types could think such things!! lol! Well, at least the good deeds I Do, I do out of a place that receives no hope or thought of reward. But... I (we), we are the fucked up ones, right? lol. riiiight.

@Sadoi The thing I’m noticing about getting older ..is that I’ve never done it before 🙂 And though you’re right about becoming more comfortable within our ..thinning skin (never knew that was actually a thing!), there is an aspect of being haunted by memories of ..better days … and the realization they’re not likely to be repeated... I’ve a lot of time inside my head, and though I also ‘appreciate’ my observations and humor, it feels wasted.

And yes, this place is amazing, though addictive… But, as much as you feel you have in common with anyone, the more you share, the more differences appear.. I appreciate watching friends navigate that in a relationship, wondering if I’ll ever get that good.

Yes, good ol’ Blasphemy, that victimless crime 😀 I appreciate your wisdom, humanity is lucky to have us, whether they realize it or not ~

2

For me, Christmas is almost completely secularized. It's all trees and lights, Santa and reindeer, candy canes and gifts. There are a few nativity scenes around town, but the secular part has really overshadowed the religious part. I celebrate because it is part of my family tradition and it is part of the culture in which I live. But the Jesus story is just as fictional to me as the Santa story.

Oh yes. Very true. I have only seen the Nativity in the front yards of churches and maybe, maybe, one or two homes. Instead I see dancing reindeer, even dancing candycanes... heck, I even saw a Dancing Pickle Rick at one of the houses I frequently drive past. haha

1

I chose to celebrate my relationship with kids and friends..not religious dogmas..

Agreed. 🙂

1

I got married on xmas day. Divorced I still call that wonderful woman on the day, she is the mother of my children. Somehow she is like an inspector or sheriff that comes and straight me out once a year.

Hahahha! That is a kind gesture, and tradition of sorts, to continue to hold to. I am sure your children appreciate it. 🙂

@Sadoi811 It is a parent responsibility to show your 3 children how you handle a divorce. I have never spoke wrong of their mother... she had not been that kind about me but does not matter I won't smear their DNA. They come from Good Stock, both sides. She need to keep me alive to get half of my military pension anyways. I need her dead to get that other half... is our joke!!!!

2

Properly speaking, if Jesus existed, he was almost certainly born between April and June as that's when the Romans ran the census; the religious significance is purely bureaucratic in any case. Personally I celebrate Christmas because of the traditions (mostly the food) and because I like giving and receiving gifts.

I am envious of Australians, mid-summer Christmas would be a lot more fun!

I grew up on the Coast of Central California and the Hawai'ian Isles so I am not well versed in the snowy nature of this season. I am used to being in a swimsuit, grilling up tri-tip and veggies outside next to the pool, in front of the Pacific Ocean. lol! I now reside on the lakeshore of Lake Michigan and we get so much snow... driving in it is a form of hellish torture for me, ugh! Let me just say, I am Nooo fan of Winter. This is bullshit. And yes, I like to hostess so I am usually the one who makes ALL (yes, All, and I'm not exaggerating) the food and boy, do I make a total spread! I do the turkey, pineapple spiral ham, about 10 sides, tons of veggies, salads, appetizers of all types, pies, cakes, cookies, bar desserts, etc etc. I don't mess around. So yeah, I celebrate. However, there isn't one, single religious icon in my digs. No thank you sir! I quickly change the channel PAST the publically broadcasted church pray-in's and masses. I go for horror instead. haha! I prefer to play The Shinning on Christmas day. On Christmas Eve, I play Twilight Zone (original of course) most of the day and in the night I watch Logan's Run, Fantastic Planet (and anime from the 70's, French) then more horror. Those are my traditions... thus far. hah

2

who knows anymore. I don't care.

hahah! Good answer! Now go scream that into a few religious mass gatherings? I would like to be there too. Let me know where we are meeting. HAHA

1

I like to make what I want out of it. It's definitely ingrained in some ways. I like the feeling of winter as a distinct season because it feels right to get snow around Christmas.

Of course, it has no intrinsic value over any other time of year, but I did enjoy the holiday cheer and music growing up, so some of that carries over. I'm single without a family, so I don't know exactly how I'd feel if I were raising kids.

Some people hate Christmas music with a passion, but I find some of the classics to be legitimately well-written music -- even if they are deeply religious (O Holy Night, for example). A lot of the music is recycled and repetitive trash (little drummer boy, anyone?).

I've discovered that I don't appreciate gifts as an adult. Gift-giving is supposedly one of the "love languages", and I have to say it's not one I'm fluent in. I love to give things to others as long as I know it's exactly what they want or can help them in some way.

Unless it has deep personal meaning (well-written letter, sign of affection, etc), I'd honestly prefer cash to collect and spend as I please. I might just be offended that you assumed to know what I like =P

It's pretty easy for me to forget about the religion and Jesus stuff these days. I don't watch Fox "news" or go to church. As far as I know, hardly any of my close friends are Christian. I guess living in Denver/Boulder again helps. It was harder to avoid religious billboards and the like living in the south.

forgo Level 4 Dec 25, 2017

I agree with you. I think, for me, the tradition rolls on because I have children. They still have a connection to it. I do have fond memories of family get togethers on Christmas too, but for me, it was always void of snow as I grew up in the Central Coast of California and Hawai'i. I now reside on the lake shore of Lake Michigan and, wow, SNOW ANYONE? Jeez I loathe the stuff! haha! Winter is like... the long months of death for me these days. lol! The city I reside in is very religious, upper class, white bread America. I fit in like a dreeam if you can imagine! I was raised by hippies. I am anti-government. Yes. I can't see myself sipping wine at the typical get together as we mix and mingle and pretend to have concern this one time of the year. I prefer to keep it low key, celebrate for the sake of celebration... for the family time. Otherwise, I kind of prefer to check out by way of holiday... things. I am the only one in my family who has traveled to this snowy land as well, so not being near them sort of dulls the desire as well, however, the children... 😉 As for Christmas music, I must admit, I am that asshole that dislikes Christmas music, minus some old few as well. I was actually thinking as I read your first sentence and before I saw your (little drummer boy, anyone?), I thought to myself, "one of the few Christmas tunes I can handle is (about then I saw your notation) Little Drummer Boy..." haha! So it must be a good one!

@Sadoi811 Nooooo! Not little drummer boy!!! How could you? =P

1

The vast majority of Christmas traditions and symbols originated in paganism or were manufactured by modern corporations. God and Jesus have no real meaning to me any more than do Zeus or Odin or Ronald McDonald.

Tomorrow I'll drive over to my parents' home and exchange gifts and eat lunch with them and my sister, niece, and nephew. Jesus doesn't really enter the picture for me and though my family claims to be Christian there is only marginal evidence of this so Jesus won't likely ever be brought up.

I find Christmas to be annoying but I will continue to give gifts to my immediate family and a few friends who are important to me. I'd be fine if Christmas was done away with but I also don't really mind giving gifts to people I care about.

Yes. I spent over a decade searching for "The Truth" as though it is just That simple and That obvious! haha! Oh the ponderings of the young mind. In time, as I researched religion after religion, my faith eventually became crushed under the weight of Logic and Sensibility and all God was choked out of my system. However, during that collection of years, I honestly could have majored in Theology and been granted a phD for all the work i completed. hahah

1

Some of both I think. Even the believers don't really know why they celebrate, for the most part I suspect. We're all just swept along in the stream.

skado Level 9 Dec 25, 2017

I believe you are correct, sir. Yes. I think at this point it is merely habit, cultural norm. I mean, can any of us in Modern America say we have known a time without Christmas? Even if you are Jehovah Witness, you Still know Of the holiday seasons, short of celebrating them. I cannot recall a time I never know of a Christmas. Or an Easter for that matter. I also know of Asian holidays too, though, since I am half Japanese and was raised by my Asian family. It is like going through the motions when I celebrate or do so with my own children. I know they love the tradition. I don't want to make my children feel like freaks so I opt to tell them I Celebrate Christmas because of the Winter Solstice and have changed, in my mind, what it is I am joyous about, however, if They want to believe it is the birthday of Jesus or a time when a Jolly, rosy cheeked man flies around the Entire Earth in One night, dropping gifts down chimneys, then Sure. As for mom, mom looks at holidays in terms of seasonal changes, but not as dates created due to Heavenly, etheral happenings. I just want them to decide for themselves What they believe. I always share my point of view and I always tell them to Decide for Themselves what they believe. If they end up athiest or agnostics too, i hope it was an organic process for them because unlike most Christians, I will never Force feed my child a faith and force them to agree that it is 100% Truth without Ever having given them the chance to Decide for themselves. I never want them to follow my lead simply Because I am their mother. I love my children and in that, I love their rights to choose their own truths.

They are lucky to have such a thoughtful Mother. @Sadoi811

@skado aww thank you. 🙂

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:10400
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.