Agnostic.com

13 2

Does anyone else get strong religious 'feelings' when entering churches/mosques? Avowed atheist here, after rejecting christian upbringing, but it seems like a primeval part of my brain still holds onto religiosity in some way - secretly hoping some kind of revelation will come along one day and sweep away the doubt, confusion and anxiety of a nogod existence.

Jamienogod 3 June 28
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

13 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

Thank you for all the feedback. A double blind(fold) test for religious experiences in various types of building could be the solution. Can understand how medieval peasants got so overawed in such places.

1

Never having actually belonged to a religion churches don‘t hold any memories for me. I do like visiting churches and cathedrals when on my travels in foreign countries but would’t go visiting any when I’m at home unless it’s a wedding or a funeral. When I visited Malaysia I tried to go inside a pretty impressive mosque with my husband but they wanted me to go in through a separate door so we didn’t bother. Women are second class citizens in Muslim eyes. I’m sure you will get over your strong religious feeling if you just say to yourself, this is just a building which was man made just like the religion it represents.

We've experienced the same when visiting some (not all) mosques. The reason given was that separating the sexes helps both to concentrate on their prayers, instead of checking each other out..

1

Have a friend lead you into a church, or whatever, with your eyes closed. And see if you have the same reaction.

xyz123 Level 7 June 29, 2018

Good idea, will try a double blind trial sometime.

1

It used to happen in the starting year of my atheism but have got over that feeling since a long time. And it was only specific to my ex-religion Hinduism. But not at all now, in fact I don't like to stay at religious places for long periods of time.

1

Religious buildings were purposely designed and built to inspire and invoke awe like commercials to make you buy a product or believe in a political candidate.

Lukian Level 8 June 29, 2018
1

I think a lot of old buildings have an aura including churches but there are plenty that leave me cold

ipdg77 Level 8 June 28, 2018
2

For the art , architecture and maybe some of the history yes. The religious baloney going on inside no. That produces revulsion.

1

For me this is complicated as I appreciate art and architecture I acknowledge that some Churches can be a Marvel to look at. I can appreciate at the church helps people and that the people can be kind the music can be inspiring structure of a church the building is beautiful. But the foundation that this was all built on somehow spoils it all. This was all built on lies and Miss guidance.

I think a lot of it was myths rather than cold lies: the misty realm of spirit worlds mixing with the visible one, which most of humanity has believed in for so long.

1

I can appreciate the beauty of many churches, synagogues, temples, cathedrals, etc. But the 1st thought that comes to mind -- wouldn't the money for this be better spent on building renewable infrastructures and helping feed the poor?

xyz123 Level 7 June 28, 2018

True, although same could be said for huge secular expenditures on sport, marketing, military etc. At least churches provided some sort of social safety net before the modern welfare state.

@Jamienogod True -- but these other organizations do not put forth helping others as part of their mission statement.

2

No, I don't. Sometimes the art, architecture, even the music is awe-inspiring, but that's just me emotions giving me pleasure. Nothing religious in it. And if you're expecting a revelation to show you there is no god, you've got more latent religious problems than you think!

That wasn't what I meant, a 'revelation' would reveal there is a divine realm after all..

@Jamienogod I think you're on the wrong site. X

1

I feel in awe of the length people will go through to create beauty. How they manipulate materials, make plans, and construct these buildings, down to the last detail is astounding. I don't feel god, I feel humbled by us.

Humans are amazing.

0

No, I refuse to enter, bc I'm revolted. The buildings are safe spaces for men who shove their dicks in little boys rectum while they scream and bleed. Everything else in the building is theater

1

sometimes I found myself praying .. LOL I did it for so long that it is almost unconscious, like everything, i thing it is a process...

vmedel Level 6 June 28, 2018
Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:117566
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.