Agnostic.com

16 4

Pick one and tell me how you would solve it: National Debt, Child hunger in USA, Homeless Veterans.

#USA
antman 7 July 18
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

16 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

National Debt: It takes money to make money... put average social security lifetime payout into a diversified index fund upon birth when children are born. Each child would earn interest like the wealthy do over time, be less dependent on government assistance, and we would be proactively addressing needs vs reactively.

0

Frankly, for hunger in America simply make it illegal for companies to produce a certain quantity of food waste. Otherwise facing a hefty fine.
This could possibly solve multiple flood related problems, such as food waste and obesity. Give companies incentive to donate food to shelters and other places that could use food.

0

Return to the tax rates we had from world war two until Regan. Re-Regulate banking and tax all stock trades at 1%. Universal Health care for all citizens. Living wage laws and force banks to allow any homeless veteran to live in any foreclosed property with a route to owning it with low interest VA guaranteed loans.

1

Put those closed bases and smaller closed facilities to use as veteran communities. Aim to make it as self-sufficient as feasible, thus giving those vets purpose and something to do. This would include having a VA clinic on site. Certainly include an agricultural component, with both food crops and livestock.

bingst Level 8 July 20, 2018
1

You know the story.
There was an old women
Who lived in a shoe.
She had so many children
She did not know what do?
Answer- So she kicked the old man out.

To solve those three Nations problems.
We need to kick the bankers and politicans out, like the women did in Iceland.

Good idea really!

1

Institute a progressive tax like most other 'civilized' countries. Those with the means need to provide more.

1

All three lots of nuclear bombs

Simon1 Level 7 July 19, 2018
2

Homelessness is very easy to cure without our government doing anything.
If you know of any veteran that wants a house have him contact me.

The problem of homeless vets is quite often about a lack of services to provide for the specific mental illnesses that afflict veterans. Putting a roof over their heads only helps if we provide mental health care, also.

@GinaMaria
With respect I've got to say you may be misinformed about all of that. There is no lack of services. I am one of those 100% disabled vets that has also been homeless. Any vet with a dd214 can walk into any VA facility anywhere in the country and be taken care of. What is missing from that equation is a purpose and opportunity to have their own house. I offer that.

@Anonbene You are right at some level but for many vets, with substance abuse and mental health issues, working the maze is beyond their capacity. And there is a lack of resources to help them do so.

@Mitch07102

Mitch, when was the last time you walked into a VA facility seeking help?

@Anonbene And I'm happy for you that you've been served adequately, but I have friends and acquaintances who have not been treated so well. Many are veterans who were dishonorably discharged due to the behavioral issues brought on by PTSD. There is no assistance for them. Just consider the broader picture.

@GinaMaria Word

@GinaMaria yes I hear that is a new development the Pentagon has been trying but I also hear that any vet that challenges it gets their benefits back except for non citizens that have been getting deported but also that they have commited another crime too.

@Anonbene What exactly do you mean by "a purpose and opportunity to have their own house?" You make it sound so easy, so I'm curious as to what exactly you're offering that the VA is not.

0

My initial humorous response is an adaptation of A Modest Proposal to somehow include all three (because I'm a jackass sometimes)

My serious response...homeless veterans.

Scenario 1: the government buys up many of the derelict houses left on the market for years after the real estate bubble burst. Those homes are then repurposed into rent-controlled housing for veterans and their families. I like this scenario but it seems unrealistic, largely because it requires a lot of capital and/or imminent domain issues on the front-end and...well the National Debt is one of your other topics.

Scenario 2: the government purchases land and either develops it similar to the way they did after WWII or engages in a 'habitat for humanity' style process whereby returning veterans collectively build a community. This seems unrealistic both for capital reasons as well as...it's kind of messed up to ask men and women who are returning from combat zones to subject themselves to construction sites to build their own homes basically, but the self-sufficiency aspect may appeal to some.

Scenario 3: okay this assumes I adequately understand the principles that govern federal spending. If I don't this falls apart pretty quick as a result. Okay, the government allocates a certain amount or percentage of the annual budget to (in this case) the military. A bill will have to be passed as part of the budget process to make this happen. These bills include earmarks for contracts with companies, and taking money from a pool of spending (education) and allocating it to another pool (agriculture) is not allowed, without another cycle of voting on spending bills, if at all. And if your department does not use its entire budget, it will have a smaller budget next year.

So the military includes, as part of its spending bill, an increase in the line item or bill which handles budgetary spending for military housing, puts the psyops people to work crafting kickstarters and fundraisers and benefits and other charitable events to help raise money to house veterans. Where that money needs to come from within the defense spending budget as a whole is beyond me, but I'm sure someone somewhere has been padding inventory to pad the budget. I don't mean criminally, necessarily, but someone has kept an eye on making sure the budget stays healthy, so some of this can come from the padding (is this cutting pork barrel spending by diverting it to a relevant and valuable expenditure? I'm honestly asking that's one of those terms that always twitched me out.) Contracts with contracting companies can be engaged as part of spending to do the building. This seems like the winner for me, but something in my mind is telling me I'm overlooking something.

2

I wouldn't know how to 'fix' any of those.
But I do try to help the homeless. I volunteer at a homeless shelter.
It's called Pinellas Hope. there around 500 people here, most are vets.

This place is really great because it's not just a place to stay, we have GED classes, a computer room so people can apply for benifits, food stamps, jobs etc.
There are personal councelors, Therapists, AA meetings.
There is a mobile med that comes every wednesday as well.
The goal here is go help people get back on their feet, and it works very well.

The place is very well known so we get donations all the time. things like blankets, clothes, food etc.
There a lot of organizations that come here and bring lunch, or dinner for every one.

I wish there were a lot more places like this.

Good for you. Sounds like a great place.

@Mitch07102 It is. Through my time being here I've see many peoples lives change around, and I am very fortunate to have the time to be there and help out as much as I can.
All of the staff and volunteers are very friendly and helpful. We really need to have more places like this.

Is this it? [pinellashope.org]

@bingst Yep, that the place. I didn't actually know they had a website, but I'm glad they do.

3

Take half of the current funds slated for Defense and put it towards all Veterans. Build city gardens to feed the homeless, the children, and reduce the food waste. Stop our elected officials from exacerbating the national debt. Only use the money obtained by taxation and refrain from over taxation. Make all taxation fair for all, including the rich. Reduce the pay for the representatives in D.C. Impose term limitations for Senate and House seats. Make Marijuana federally legal and tax it and use that money locally to improve infrastructure and schools.

Gohan Level 7 July 19, 2018

Sounds like a good plan to me!

3

Stop giving billions in aid to Israel., concentrate on your own people.

2

Stop going into other countries and making war there that will save billions.

1

National debt ? Have a massive trial trying all corporate and war criminals , when they are found guilty of acquiring money and assets through criminal activity , confiscate those and assess huge , beyond total fines to be used to pay the legitimate debts ! Child hunger , Homeless vets ? Tax the rich to death or at least enough to solve these problems and most others.
Then EAT THE RICH ! Or feed them to the hungry critters at the animal shelter , ha .

2

For national debt, I'd make hemp a main crop that was federally grown and have the government use the profit from the sale of raw hemp only. All other steps below raw harvest, the refining and processing and products created, would be citizens. Use the profit to pay off the debt and once it is paid off, the profits would go to the things our taxes pay for.. and any profit beyond that would be divided among the people. I'd make it a 20 year plan with complete transparency and if it proves to pay off our debt and work for the people, they could vote to keep it going or have the business of producing raw hemp returned to the people and have taxes reinstated.

For the other two, Thunderdome?

2

Oh my gosh, this would be too long a post. However, one could actually start with one and end up fixing all three.

For starters, no matter the choice, I would start by cutting the military budget by 35% and taking a portion of that money greatly increase funding to the VA. I would then take what was left and add it to the amount we spend on health care and institute a universal health care system to greatly lower the cost of health care to the people. I would increase corporate taxes to 80% and increase the tax on the estate tax to 90%. Most would go to pay down the debt while the rest would go towards school programs, better funding of the education system, research in overhauling the curriculum to be more efficient and better effective. I would implement tuition free post secondary education. I would wipe away all outstanding student loans. I would implement programs that would mirror European labor union laws and make it a law that labor must have a representation on company boards. People would bring in more take home pay allowing families to be able to spend more money of food and groceries. I would actively research ways to lead in education, health care, overall happiness, and work on ways to reduce stress of the people. I think it could be done if everyone worked for the greater good of the many.

80% corporate taxes????? Wow. No incentive to be in business. Surely most would get passed on to the consumer anyway. I think estate tax should be abolished...I can’t leave what I’ve earned to my kids with out having to pay tax?

@antman You need to understand that this is tax on profits. Other countries pay a lot in taxes and look after their own and people still open up new businesses.

@antman The corporate tax was 90% in the 1950s when we were the most prosperous and managed to build the Interstate Highway System. I don't think 80% would cripple anyone. Also, do you have an estate worth 12 million dollars? If not, then you have nothing to worry about since the estate tax would not apply to you.

@antman It's still a progressive tax, and companies hire employees, raise wages and make capital investments in order to decrease their tax liability. That's how we grew a middle class. That's how companies grow in net worth for real, instead of on paper. And that's how you increase tax revenue - by employing more citizens at higher incomes.

@GinaMaria I am not sure that they rise wage that much.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:134315
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.