Agnostic.com

13 5

You can be patriotic and not have to pump your chest, yelling about how patriotic you are...right?

Rideauxb 7 July 19
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

13 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

I whole heartedly concur. I hate people who wrap themselves in the flag and become uber nationalists (eg. Lee Greenwood or other recent country artists). I am very patriotic, but do not have difficulty either supporting what I agree with or criticizing what I do not. To criticize is not to be less patriotic. I have done a lot of criticism of Trump the last few days due to his performance in Helsinki. I truly feel he let the country down and did not defend the values and Constitution of our country. His actions were less than patriotic in my opinion.

t1nick Level 8 July 19, 2018
1

I think so. They people who pound their chests and yell either about patriotism, politics, or religion, are usually trying to cover up or distract people from the kind of person they really are... and their own less admirable traits.

0

Absolutely! I wonder how many of the people who rage about football players taking a knee actually show the flag the proper respect. I've seen tattered versions of it used as spare tire covers on jeeps or bikini pieces. And BTW, when it's past its prime it's SUPPOSED to be burned, not thrown in the trash. A lot of businesses seem to think they're showing patriotism by flying a giant flag outside, but they put it up and leave it up, and when it's showing clear signs of deterioration, they keep it up. That's neglect, not patriotism.

0

There are times that I would like to see no patriotism at all. We humans tend to get carried away with the concept, and it seems to be at the root of our difficulties accepting those outside our particular way of thinking.
And of course now, with the orange empty headed one in charge, he is reaping and encouraging the discord of such extremes.

Otherwise , I feel that patriotism is similar to religion. If one is solid in their beliefs, there's no need to carry on to others , and wave your crucifix - or your flag.

0

No cos that's all part of the mind control stuff

Simon1 Level 7 July 19, 2018
1

Absolutely.

Dew25 Level 7 July 19, 2018
1

Not if you're a right winger.

1

Sounds like just another day in Canada. lol

0

Yes of course. You don’t need to wave a flag or even say that you are a patriot to be one. You must be able to see when your country is not taking the correct course as well as taking pride in it when it is. I like to think that my pride in being Scottish is more to do with how Scots throughout history have been trailblazers and pioneers and we have a common humanity with others throughout the world. Mine is a quiet patriotism, no chest thumping, but a lump in the chest sometimes when a compatriot achieves something notable.

4

I have to make a comment so I'll say I hate flag flying patriotism. You don't want to be blinkered to your country's faults.

3

Not a chest pumper, but I served in uniform, swearing an oath to protect and defend the Constitution against all enemies, foreign and domestic. Our Constitution's preamble begins boldly with "We the People," and was the first official state document that denied the existence of any God's divine right over the governed. But 'We the People' sometimes forget our responsibilities in ensuring the continued viability of the rights conferred therein. In my opinion, it is our patriotic duty as citizens to ensure that the rights extended in our Constitution apply to all, and are not impinged.

Does that bit about all enemies, foreign and domestic still apply when you get out of the service? Specifically the domestic part. Would you take up arms against domestic politicians that are clearly enemies of our country or do you think no politician is an enemy to our country? Can you think of any politicians that broke that same oath and if so what do you think should be done about them? Seems like a bunch of nonsense that on one hand you and I have been asked (ordered to) go overseas and literally blow the fucking heads off of people that never did anything against us personally or to our country but once back here all we are allowed to do to literal proven enemies of our country (our politicians) is to wait years and hope our vote counts.
What's an oath worth? Does it have a use by date? Does it only apply to foreigners that threaten corporate profits? Is it worth the paper it's printed on?

@Rideauxb My closest friends, colleagues and family are about the only folks who are aware of my service. I don't have bumperstickers, and don't view my days in uniform as making me inherently 'more patriotic' or, for that matter, a 'better' citizen. I was humbled by the experience. I didn't fully appreciate the meaning of the oath I swore at that time, coming to appreciate its ramifications only later. And I can only intuit, based on the character of the men and women with whom I served, that in the case of a true Constitutional crisis, the vast majority of the leadership, as well as the rank and file, could be counted on to do the right thing.

4

The chest thumping morons actually are.... sort of appalling.

Of course this is "my country, right or wrong," but that doesn't mean it has a license to go around doing wrong. When my country does wrong, it's my patriotic duty to point that shit out and put a stop to it! I love my country, and want it to do right! Just like loving my child, or my friends... I love them, and I want them to be the best they can be! I hope they tell me if I do something wrong, so I can change my ways!

And because I love my country, I have to point it out when we are fucking up! That's what a patriot does.

3

The pump your chest, yelling ones often aren't as patriotic as the quiet, working towards betterment ones.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:134512
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.