Pro and cons of homeschool....pour them out if you are able,waiting to read....
I was homeschooled for elementary and middle school ages. It went okay in elementary when my parents were more involved and helped us to stay connected with other people. Actually, I think that was good for me and helped me to learn to take charge of my own learning as a core part of who I am.
Middle school grades sucked because I didn't have hardly any friends, didn't have enough parental guidence, and what friends I had, I lost. And on all three counts, do you want to know why? Simple: a church fucked us over. (long, icky story; I should have realized that that was a fundamental problem with Christian Churches—not just that one—a long time ago.)
Anyway, I think homeschooling can be done fine. But it depends on the kids and the parents, and public school can still be ok. In my opinion, I think it's easier for homeschooling to be incredibly great or an absolute crap-shoot than public/private/charter school.
A few points to consider. Parent and child can learn together. If the parent does not know a particular subject area very well they can study with their child. You can switch off with another parent if they have better skills in an area that you are lacking. Socialization is not an issue since there are so many coops people can join. I am a Montessori teacher with a master's in Sped. I have had all kinds of students. And one thing I know is it is more your approach and attitude to learning than anytning your taught that really matters.
I think tbe parents are crazy to do it, but given a actual curriculum that is actually followed with appropriate social activities homeschooling can be good for kids.
However, that's rarely what happens. Homeschooling is often another way to say "can't be bothered by our kids".
It's really not. Most parents who homeschool love their kids and want to give them the best education possible. It is an incredible commitment. Sending kids off to school is much easier.
@Minta79
In my experience, the poor kids receive no education. The parents just couldn't be bothered either to take the kids to school or pick them up.
When asked about school and progress, they have endless excuses for why the kids aren't doing anything. Just to be clear, I've noticed the same problems with private and charter schools. It's truly a parenting fail.
@Minta79
I worked in schools for 11 years, with at risk kiddos for 14 and have had 3 nieces and nephews who were 'homeschooled' and one niece whose stepmother is actually following a curriculum and teaching.
Like anything else they only get out of homeschooling what they put into it. My niece stays witb me 2-3 weeks a year. She comes with homework and we work 1-2 hours a day on her assignments with 2 days off for a. 'weekend'.
@PhoebeCat so, you don't really have a great sample to draw from. A couple of people you know personally and "at risk" kids that represent an unknown segment of the total homeschool community. I wouldn't dream of making such broad judgements about public schooling based on so little information...
What you describe happens (obviously) but it is the clear minority. Most homeschooling parents have put so much time, thought and effort into schooling their kids that it's become a whole entity of it's own. Most homeschool parents do it out of love and a desire to give their kids a top notch education. What you have experienced is not the norm.
Wow. I didn't expect to see so many responses down on homeschool. So, I actually am a homeschooling parent. One who wants to teach my kid science and history. Obviously, there is no religious motivation. He is an extrovert's extrovert (much like his mama) and would shrivel and die without lots of social interaction, which he gets.
Pros:
Cons:
For me, the pros totally outweigh the cons. We have a great secular co-op, so my son has tons of social opportunities. There are plenty of little art classes available locally and he's involved in sports and cub scouts. I personally have made some of my best friends in the last few years through our homeschool community.
If you have any specific questions, please feel free to contact me.
@nosferatu_cat if they're quite pronounced, and the staff is paying attention learning differences can be diagnosed early. But, on average dyslexia gets diagnosed in mid-elementary. My son would have skated through school, barely able to read, feeling dumb just like his dad and my brother did. Because he's smart and really good at faking it.
I
I'mre your daughter is fantastic at her job and the staff at most schools genuinely care. Homeschool isn't the best fit for everyone, just like brick and mortar school isn't. Dyslexia isn't the reason we homeschool, catching it early'ish is just one of the pros.
Fabulous! These are all amazing reasons to do it and the cons are legit too! Especially the never ending time with your kiddos. You will do a great job! your kiddos is lucky!
It depends on the reasons why you choose to homeschool. I am a teacher and private tutor and have had many homeschooled students. Most were just fine, socialized through activities with other homeschoolers and were learning. A few had some issues, social, learning disabilities etc. If you do it right you can really give your child a fabulous experience. But not everyone can do it
It depends on the reasons why you choose to homeschool. I am a teacher and private tutor and have had many homeschooled students. Most were just fine, socialized through activities with other homeschoolers and were learning. A few had some issues, social, learning disabilities etc. If you do it right you can really give your child a fabulous experience. But not everyone can do it
Home schooled people are generally about as dumb as a box of rocks. All of this home schooling started as a "special needs" thing and then the religious got ahold of it. They can't stand that someone will teach their kids science. The poor child doesn't learn until much too late that they have been fed a bunch of bullshit. Imagine the shock of that.
Wow. What a rude way to state a completely uninformed opinion, with literally no basis in fact.
OK, what is your concept of home schooling? IF they are not special needs children then how would you explain it? My explanation admits that the religious want to use home schooling to protect children from scientific facts. Do this and you are betraying your child.
@DenoPenno I actually homeschool my kid and belong to a secular homeschool co-op. So, I know over 100 homeschooling families who do not homeschool for religious reasons, in a mid-size town in Ohio (just imagine how many secular homeschoolers there are in larger metro areas!). Some do. I don't agree with them, but it is their right and they are shrinking as a percent of total homeschoolers. You can read below to see my reasons and pros and cons list. Which is what the OP asked for. My point is that your opinion is not based on experience or fact.
My evangelical brother and his wife xtian-homeschooled all five kids(1still at home)...for two of the kids, they had huge social adjustment problems in the first months in college. My nephew quit and moved away, is much happier now. My niece is so withdrawn, she never spoke to her roommate in college, and refused to go back for a second semester.
Their goal in homeschooling was to keep out all secular influence and teach the Bible-or their cherry-picked parts of it. I see it as abusive. My nephew actually had PTSD and severe depression. He attempted suicide once; they prayed for him. Second attempt, my parents were present and got him the help he needed.
I’m sure others have different experiences with it, but I view homeschooling as negative.
Prevents them from learning social skills outside of their immediate family.
@PickledRick exactly. In the case of my neice, she barely relates to anyone even inside the family. It’s a social handicap.
It is abusive. Very much so.
Anything can be abusive. Homeschooling in and of itself is not abusive. These people chose a very unhealthy lifestyle for their children and added homeschool to that. You cannot judge all homeschoolers off of the actions of a few religious wackadoos.