Agnostic.com

7 5

(Edited)Proof that God doesn't exist?

(see note below)
Maybe not, but it's either proof that gods do not get involved with the affairs of humanity.

The children of atheists don't get sexuality abused by the clergy. It is only the children of the devout. The children of atheists are not denied life saving medical treatment, or vaccinations.

It just seems to me that the fact that atheists' children are more likely to reach adulthood, and less likely to be sexuality or emotionally abused says a lot about the existence (or at least "blessings" ) of good gosh almighty.

*Edit; since 2 of the first 4 responses seemed to have missed key points, I'll clarify. The whole intent of my post was to point out that those who are prayed for the most tend to face additional challenges that the rest of us don't have to deal with. Not less. I did Not say we do not face challenges outside of religion. I did Not say that all clergy are pedophiles.
The children of the devout face all of the same challenges in life that the rest of us do, AND more from their own religion. The idea that prayer offers any kind of protection is very clearly false

JustKip 7 July 24
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

7 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

Quick google search doesn't come up with athiests abusing children but extensive reports and studies on religious abuse mental and sexual ....that should tell you all what you need to know !!

Simon1 Level 7 July 25, 2018
0

Human shittiness is hardly proof of the existence of God or not. I have no idea how this is a logical argument. Assuming "gods" representatives on earth are beyond human fallacies is a mistake and a flaw in the argument.
Atheists can still be abused and that is the problem not who the abuse comes from.

Most sexual abuse isn't from "church" or religion it is from family and people close to you. That is the problem, people are poor at controlling impulses

@JustKip There are numbers backing that up? I find that very difficult to believe as so little is reported to begin with.

I was an athlete in my younger days on some pretty serious team (not Pro) and you wouldn't believe the authority coaches have over kids. It happens anywhere trusted adults (and older kids tbh) prove untrustworthy.

Guess which kids especially young males are unlikely to report things like that?

So maybe I missed the point but it seems like trying to create a narrative which I have never seen any proof for

@JustKip Yeah so I am NOT missing the point. I am refusing to accept your narrative no matter how strong your assertion. I still have not seen where the clergy % of deviants is so much greater than coaches, or teachers, or friends and family, or bus drivers, or even with older kids that significantly or at all, alters the risk that the devout are taking with regard children's welfare than an atheist. You can draw as many Venn diagrams as you want intersecting the possible exposure to sexual abuse, the assertion is no more true until you have actual statistics to back it up

Statements/comments like this is why I became an atheist in the first place. It is hypocritical and attacking a specific group of people for absolutely no gain other than to point out another reason you think they are wrong. We are better than you because we don't have a group socialization aspect associated with our belief? They are wrong to believe in god because crappy people can found everywhere including religious organizations...shocking. Makes anyone with kids seem like a bad person simply for bringing children into a world we are destroying on top of exposing them to crappy people. Parents do not subject their children to risk intentionally no matter what they believe...well some maybe but crappy parents aren't the point. Your point are the crappy ones that believe in God, follow a religion and force their children into situations they may be with adults unsupervised, more than atheist parents.

Sexual abuse of children is deviant criminal behavior and no "organization" supports it or allows it so they definitely do not want to admit it when they find it. It happens in every facet of life where a trusted adult is capable of being alone with children...the end. To assert religious parents are worse for exposing their children to yet another potential situation for sexual abuse is just....awful.

Not sure exactly how everyone's deviant-meter works but this is NOT a reason to be an atheist imo...more of a reason not to have children. I would say the childless have 0 risk of their children being abused but what is the point of that? Are all atheists that have kids crappier parents than me...more irresponsible/worse atheists for exposing their children to known risks I did not want to? I mean the world we live in contributed to my deciding not having children was OK with me. Just a flat out terrible unproven assertion attacking imo.

0

The great thing about being atheist is that you don't have to prove anything. You don't have to believe anything. We got no songs. 🙂

1

You can't prove the non-existence of God. God is possible. Highly unlikely, almost completely impossible, and yet still possible.

0

A good proof that god doesn't exist is all those poor young children dying of cancer. If I'm wrong then why do believers fail to give a good reason for this? Well, nobody knows the mind of god.

The fact that you dislike the workings of nature has no bearing on the question.

@WilliamFleming I see him addressing a god question, NOT a nature question.

@WilliamFleming Exactly. Evangelicals think god heals cancer. I find no proof of this.

3

I agree that a heavily religious upbringing is a disadvantage, but for other reasons. A belief in the efficacy of prayer, guilt caused by religion, bad attitudes towards sex, fear of hell, there’s a whole range of psychological wounds that Christianity inflicts. I feel it’s far better to stick with science.

Denker Level 7 July 24, 2018
3

no they don't but can still get abused by others

weeman Level 7 July 24, 2018
Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:138444
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.