Agnostic.com

9 0

After being a member of Agnostic for the better part of a year, I'm just now beginning to realize that the demographic of this place skews decidedly middle-class. Not a problem not a complaint, simply an observation; feel free to correct me if I'm wrong...
This is to say that as a working class and particularly working poor individual (as I myself identify), I often feel that we are invisible to the broader society. As much as I feel at home here (Agnostic), I sometimes feel that sense of unseen-ness here to.
Thoughts? Does anyone else here feel this way too? Out in the world or here on the site? I would love some feedback.

ghettophilosopher 7 Jan 24
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

9 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

Thanks for this post. I'm upper middle class, and it hasn't really occurred to me that those who identify as working class might be under represented here. But in my opinion having people from every class, not just the middle class, makes for a much better online community.
Working class friends I have can smell anything fake or pretentious a mile away.
So, for what it may be worth, I"m really glad you're a member on this site @ghettophilosopher

0

Full time work should pay a living wage. Period.

0

And I thought the USA was supposed to be classless ?. The class system is alive and well in the UK but I refuse to recognise it. Before I retired I rubbed shoulders with landed gentry,wealthy businessmen, management types and labourers and to me they were all the same. As we say in Scotland "we are all Jock Tamson's bairns"

0

I think that you are right when you talk about it being middle class, however there are people here from working class background too. I somehow don't think that there any rich people here.

0

Well shucks! I had to look up what middle income was. Pew says over $40,000. If that's true I'm not anywhere close. Lower income here. Before you asked I thought I was pretty well off. 🙂

gearl Level 8 Jan 25, 2019

Imagine earning that with no family to support

@Treehugger Well, I do have a wife and we're putting a daughter through college but she has a scholarship and grants or it would be hard. It helps when about everything is paid off.

1

I concur! It's also very white & American!

This is not an inaccurate statement...

0

I would say you're right about it being mostly middle class on this site, at least from what I've seen. Personally, I kind of straddle the line. I went to work in a factory right out of high school, and then had a lot of other physical labor jobs over the next 4 or 5 years. I went to night school for electronics, and left for California after a couple of years of that, and lucked into a job in the computer industry. Since then I'm decidedly middle class.

1

Yes i agree with you. You can tell when someone is middle class by the vacations they take cost more then a used truck.

@Bendog @treehugger agreed on both counts. I just saw a post about world travel and I wanted to comment on how, as lovely as the notion is, for some of us it's just so far beyond the scope of possibility. I changed my mind about commenting when I saw that all the other comments were from people who were also well traveled. It made me feel out of place and honestly, a bit isolated.

@Bendog P.S. Vacation is that thing where, once a year, assuming you've been at the same job for more than a year, you get two week's pay for one week's work and your bosses pat themselves on the back for it.

0

well, no, since i am poor and living on social security disability, food stamps and medicaid, no, o don't see this skewing at all.

g

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:273109
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.