Absolutely reasonable. They are all part of your life. I would question your date's judgement rather than your own.

I was married 25 years. I couldn’t throw away my lifetime.

I have pictures. It was part of my life. To me I prefer someone who has pictures, then someone still having animosity about their significant other. That is a game stopper for me.

I wouldn't display our wedding pictures on the walls but I have kept all pictures from my past.

I was married for 37 years, and we were together for 5+ years before we married. I have three children from that marriage. I might abhor the man, but he is part of my history, and we had many wonderful years together.... Of COURSE I have photos of my ex. Nothing displayed, but he was a major part of my life. To "trash" so much of your life is wrong, and for anyone to be unhappy about any part of your past would suggest that that person has some un-resolved issues of his/her own. Yes, unreasonable...

I have pics and I am absolutely fine that my partner has pics of his. His relationships helped him become the person he is. My ex-hubby is the father of my children and in the end, we were happy together for many years. You are not a clean slate and anyone wanting to be with you needs to understand that. I like my partner's stories about his ex's...they make me feel so superior

I have pictures of my late wife and of our marriage license,27 years together(26 good ones),yes, a new relationship will be my focus,but I cannot forget the past.....

I have diaries and pictures, concert stubs, leaflets, pebbles, bits of metal, etc from every year of my life all kept in a trunk and every piece has a special meaning to me - but little consequence to others

I have pictures of ex girlfriends and wives. They are a part of my history, some of them a very important part.

I kept pics of all of my ex-loves...they are in a box for my eyes only...you can't ever wipe out your past by throwing away the trimmings of life: mementos, pictures, etc. As long as you don't linger in the past, your current loves should appreciate that your past made you who you are today and keeping such things are of no consequence to them.

I would be a bit wary of anyone who has an issue with this...I think your view is quite a healthy one for you to move on happily the rest of your life.

You are right. Its an important part of your history. Perhaps you might consider how you display them so that perspective dates are not intimidated by their presence.

It all varies person by person. I have none- a hard 28 year abusive mess. My SO, now, after a 10 year hiatus, still, on occasion does a few things for her ex who recently had a stroke. I am not threatened in anyway, and she does minor things like any old friend would do. Having kids, I actually sort of envy that she can even talk with him (my ex and don't communicate at all).
So, you are fine, and a date who is offended is, in my humble opinion, someone who you don't need to see again, unless they can make changes.
Best wishes.

I think you are a good person for keeping these things. I have photos and gifts from my (failed) marriage and I will always keep them even though at the time the divorce was 'messy'. These things are a part of who I am. If anyone doesn't like that then tough.

No

Kept one wedding photo with my first, sexually abusive husband.
I had years of therapy to recover from being abused by the man I loved.
Tim died of a massive heart attack in 2008.

There should be a hideous Hell for men who abuse women and children.
Hieronymus Bosch springs to mind.

You are not unreasonable; your date was. I would think it far stranger if you had felt the need to purge everything and every last photo or trinket from your life.