Agnostic.com

11 1

got into a strange discussion the other day regarding leaving a butter dish out on the table or counter. one person was appalled by the idea. how long is too long to leave butter out?

michaelj 7 May 23
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

11 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

2 weeks

bobwjr Level 10 May 24, 2019
2

I never refrigerate butter...it is left on the counter by the stove to be used for spreading and cooking...according to the food safety guidelines, two weeks...I use a stick a week easily...

1

A covered butter dish sits beside my bread bin ... the butter is often too hard to spread, but 10 seconds in the microwave gives enough soft butter for a sandwich

2

Butter will not spread straight from fridge. I cut a small bit off the block of butter and keep it out on the counter, keeping the rest in the fridge until I need to replenish the dish.

1

My butter sits on the counter. It probably takes half a year to go through a stick.

Yikes

2

I live in Oklahoma where it is not cool and I leave my butter out all year round. My summertime thermostat always goes to 80 when I'm not home thanks to a Smart Nest Thermostat. Butter always tastes good and spreads easily at my house

When I was in Hungary my roommate and I constantly had this discussion. She wanted eggs on the counter and butter in the fridge. I wanted butter on the counter and eggs in the fridge. Eggs are probably fine on the counter but the counter space was very limited there and butter doesn't take up much space.

Oh my gawd, I'd be so nervous about eggs at room temperature or warmer.....not willing to chance it personally! But recipes do ask for room temp eggs all the time...which is a pain when it comes to spontaneous urges to bake something.

@mojo5501

"In the Bahamas and Virgin Islands, I was surprised to see that people did not refrigerate eggs," my mother said.

@LiterateHiker @mojo5501. Eggs do not need to be kept in a fridge...I keep a few out on the counter for ready use, and some in the fridge....when I use the ones on the counter I replace them with ones from the fridge. Room temperature is recommended for egg use....the shell protects it from going off quickly.

@Marionville Actually, they do...your eggs are not processed chemically like ours...

[businessinsider.com]

@thinktwice thank you for that information,....had no idea of that difference.between our countries,

@Marionville When I was in Europe, I noticed this and was curious...I buy eggs from the Amish farms...they are not processed and can be left out just as they are in the hens nest until you are ready to use them...

5

I always have a stick of butter on the counter until it’s nearly gone. I then take another outta the fridge. I never really measured the days. A friend of mine who studied at a hoity toity culinary institute in France sanctioned this approach 🙂

4

Except for a stint living in Albuquerque I've always had butter on the counter in a covered dish.

1of5 Level 8 May 23, 2019
4

Depends on the room temperature.

I leave butter in a cool cupboard, in a covered dish.

It's impossible to spread hard butter on bread.

mmmm and you make bread...mmmmm

@thinktwice

Think I'll make bread tomorrow.

@LiterateHiker You tease! ha ha ha

3

I live in "The Dairy State", Wisconsin and I have always kept my butter out on the counter in a covered butter dish without any ill effects. As my mother and grandmother did before me. If I lived in a southern state, things may be a bit different since it would probably spoil/melt/both faster. As a single person, I only set out 1/2 a stick at a time and it takes a while for me to get through it these days. Here in Wisconsin we have reached that wonderful time in spring when we can spread butter on a slice of bread without wrecking the bread because it's so damn cold....a time to celebrate! ha ha

3

We always have a stick out. Granted it doesn't last forever but it hangs around for at least a couple of days with no issues. I keep my house at 74 though

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:351200
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.