Does religion appeal primarily to broken people? Could the argument be made that religion, and by extension, God, be an answer for all the scared, ignorant, lonely, insecure, depressed people who feel helpless in a universe that doesn't give a shit about them?
It makes me wonder because most people are messed up in one way or another. Hell, I'm as broken as the next guy but I'm not willing to buy a plainly false narrative just so I can fool myself into feeling better.
Wealth and success doesn't seem to be the deciding factor; many rich, powerful people are still religious. Nor is higher education given that a fair number of doctors, engineers, and scientists also practice their faith in God. Is it that these rich, successful, highly educated people are also scared, ignorant, lonely, insecure, and depressed?
So if we're all broken to some degree then what makes the difference between those who need a God to pray to and those who don't?
You are probably going to get better information if you ask believers instead of nonbelievers.
That'd be great. I'm one of the few users on this site who thinks we'd have more opportunities for stimulating conversation if we had more theists among us.Without contrary opinions to stir things up you just get an echo chamber. Most users seem to disagree with this however.
@Sgt_Spanky I welcome anyone that is polite.
@Sgt_Spanky I am tired of struggles between believers and non-believers, right and left, men and women. We are all one and we are fucking everything up. There you go.
I would say that those who go extreme religious are generally poor people. People who are rich and religious are more inclined to be Sunday believers. It doesn't mean they don't genuinely believe in God but they seem to pull off hypocrisy better than others.
I think the more science minded and logical based your reasoning becomes - the less you are apt to believe in religion.
However I also know some folks who are very artsy who are atheists! There will always be exceptions to every rule and subsets to every group.
I just want to know how we make MORE of us? lol
Interesting. What are the criteria for being ‘broken’ ’being messed up’ or not messed up?
@Ms_McSteven Ok. Thanks
I think fear plays a big part. That and plain old ignorance.
I think rich people see God as the spiritual dimension of Maslow's self-actualisation. I'm told it came in with Protestantism and is now most obvious in the prosperity gospel. They must mean he brought it into relatively recent Western thinking because there must have been people like that since forever.