Agnostic.com

58 8

I’m a Buddhist. Do you regard Buddhism as a religion? Or philosophy?

DavidFalshaw 4 Nov 22
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

58 comments (26 - 50)

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

Buddhism was and is a social movement in India.

when something control people to behave in a manner and kills others not like them it is a religion

1

All three. I'm not Buddhist but I enjoy reading what they preach. They don't flaunt their religions like Christians do in this country

Trod Level 5 Nov 22, 2019
1

Of course Buddhist is a religion, however if you are comfortable being one than it is okay. Just enjoy it.

1

More a religion in the far east; more a philosophy in the west.

1

It is purely philosophical

1

Both

bobwjr Level 10 Nov 22, 2019
1

Some do some don't, my wife is a Buddhist, what she does seems like a religion to me.

1

You are probably more qualified than I am to answer that question, since you have first-hand experience with it.

I just wanted to pose the question 😊

1

Why the notion of "or"?

1

You are the Buddhist, why don't you tell us?

1
1

Does buddhism help widows and orphans in need?

Word Level 8 Nov 22, 2019

Yes. I just returned from Thailand after teaching there since 2010, and they not only helped the poor and people having a flooding emergency, they have universal health care and help stray dogs, as well as people. Also, they don't care what gender presentation someone uses.

@birdingnut That's nice and helpful for you as a person but as to the teachings or information pertaining to buddhism is my focus of question. Does buddhism teach such, promote stuff to cause you to be helpful as such, or are you just doing helpfulness on your own with out the information from buddhism?

@blahblah In the case of the Buddhist Thai, their beliefs include reincarnation and karma.. so good deeds will either be rewarded in this life or in the next reincarnation. Extensive research and verification of past memory details by several teams of researchers of two to six-year-old children from all over the world who remember a past life, indicates that Karma does NOT exist.

People in one life don't get punished or rewarded according to their behavior in the next life, but seem to choose birth parents for reincarnation according to past family relations and proximity of the child to the location of their last death. For instance, researchers kept finding children with the memories of Japanese fighter pilots in countries where Japanese zeros had been shot down during the war.

Puzzled European and British parents would sometimes find that their toddlers had detailed knowledge of fighter plane cockpits and could draw them in great detail, describe shooting down other planes in battle, remembered details about their past personas. The past memories would fade away by the time the children were six years old. .

@birdingnut sounds like it has a connotation to biblical text that is not so well understood. I would have to think on how to explain the connection and find the biblical references. Vaguely it's like Jesus character cast out demons from people that were previous souls interfering with a current living person. But, it's like biblical text gives a 1000 year repeat pattern of souls reigning 1000 years then like a new group of harvested souls are released to reign the next 1000 years.

I had several dreams in my early 20s that didn't seem connected and did seem to be foretelling future events. In my late 20s the dreams come to pass like an orchestrated plan. From one dream I had seen a man walking and when he left my dream it woke me up and I had the thought that it felt like as spirit left my body. When the dreams come to pass i met this man and he called himself by 4 titles,: alpha and omega, grim reaper, son of Lucifer and nameless-faceless one.

@birdingnut the man I met that I had seen in dream tried telling me I was a medium, like spiritual medium. I no longer consider myself Christian.

0

Religion because they believe in reincarnation

0

Many of the Buddhist sects are religious. They have a dogma and rituals, therefore religions.
You can practice the Buddhist way of life on your own, then it become more philosophical.
Buddha didn't want people to idolize him, but to chose the "middle way" in life.... be reasonable in your choices.
And no idols, that why he died in the forest with just the man who was helping him.... somewhat alone. He wasn't interested in the cult of personality, but in teaching in living with acknowledgement of suffering. Life is a painful process, try to make it easier on yourself.... no religiosity in this...

0

I know that Buddah is sort of a title for a person that has reached Nirvana (peace and happiness, even perfection) and is free from suffering. Although there is no God or superior Being creator of everything, there is belief, a set of teachings, worshipping, and FAITH, which make a case for religion. I'm not against statues and symbols, but people tend to treat such objects with a degree of adoration and, worse, attach fortune to them.

frvl Level 4 Nov 23, 2019
0

Just like Chritianity. Buddhism has both a philosophical and a purely religious sides. Christianity has religious scholars and sects ( e.g. Jesuits). Buddhism has its scholarly practioners ( do not know what they call themselves).

To look at the historical texts in an scholarly fashion in order to ascertain intended meanings, or review changes in doctrine in order to understand trends and the evolution of thought to understand the present as an academic pursuit exists in all religions.

Religion is perhaps better described as the everyday practice as understood by the general practitioners. Phiilosophy on the other hand is a more academic, scholarly look at the foundations and histories of the religion.

Regardless, they are all misguided and often taint their work by embracing and employing preconceived biases.

0

I'm told that some sects embrace a divine aspect to Buddha. That divinity puts it into the realm of religion. I've also heard that other sects are secular in nature. That's philosophy.

0

What matters is how you became a Buddhist.....did you pick up a book and start chanting all by yourself ????? Are you following family traditions ????? What are your thoughts when you might light up some incense sticks and offer some fruit to a Jade Buddha???????? I respect your honest question to Atheists here.....seeking nirvana and rethinking events and feelings in your life can be both a religious cult and a philosophy more resembling detached ethics.....or a ritual that merely relaxes your mind ....you are welcome here friend....I do know some Buddhists who believe there are ghosts demons and magic.....if you want to scare anybody into Buddhism that won't fly here....candid discussions here are good for our community

0

all religion if following the true practices are good basically its men that radicalize and fight wars to make others convert

following those rules is good don't kill don't lie don't steal respect mom and dad all good but you don't have to be religious to be a decent person and have morals

0

do you believe in a higher that control the universe? that is a god! a real atheist does not worship anything

You studying sociology?

In modern society and sociology, some writers have commented on the ways that people no longer simply worship recognised deities, but also (or instead) worship consumer brands,[15] sports teams, and other people (celebrities).[16] Sociology therefore extends this argument to suggest outside of a religion worship is a process whereby society worships itself, as a form of self-valorization and self-preservation.[17] wikipedia

0

I've run into this before that Buddhism is more of a philosophy than a religion. By decrying 'we're not a religion' is simply a means to separate one religion from all other religions (I sometimes refer to it as 'looking down one's nose'😉. Many other ideologies try to do this every once in a while. People within these religions who actually study the religion (not just mumble words at each other), there comes a point when they start seeing 'religion' and 'cult' as the same. Try defining one without the other. Cult implies something bad to most people. Once that occurs the person no longer wants the two words to be associated and they look for ways to distance their religion from the others.

A cult is a group or subculture reacting to society, a sect is a response to its mainstream religion.

@Geoffrey51 Yes, I've read the definition. Extend it...Is a subset separate or part or all of the whole.

0

Neither. Just useless.

1of5 Level 8 Nov 22, 2019

Not to millions of people it isn’t.

@DavidFalshaw so? I was asked for my view of it. Xtianity and Islam work for billions, so should I change my views of those?

0

Both, I suppose. There can be a fine line.

Deb57 Level 8 Nov 22, 2019
0

It depends on what the person believes. I personally look at it as a philosophy and guide to live life without conflicts. However, some people add in a lot of supernatural stories surrounding the origins of the Buddha, which were basically drawn from early religious belief systems and added to the story. If you believe in the supernatural nonsense, then it is a religion, not just a philosophical way in which to live your life.

I think probably a lot of messiah stories started off with a real person whose qualities and life were exaggerated and then supernatural aspects were added in because they thought people needed to be afraid in order to behave well. Also, if the messiah overcomes supernatural forces, it makes them appear more admirable ... at least to the gullible.

0

Its religion if you believe in God.

gater Level 7 Nov 22, 2019
Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:429707
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.