Agnostic.com

4 4
MichaelSpinler 8 Jan 12
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

4 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

2

Half of four year olds have an imaginary friend because quite frankly, not many at that age really have friends to speak of. They are trying to fit in and maybe have noticed that you have more friends than they do. Also, the imaginary friend gets them some needed attention.

3

Ok I slogged through it. Some great points and somewhat convincing overall. Most of it works. However, there is a whole lot of causation from correlation going on in there and that makes me suspicious of some of the assertions.

For example, the notion that because half of all 4 year olds have an imaginary friend, it means that they have a belief in a form of life outside the body...and that this is the default setting of the human brain.

That's quite a leap, particularly when most science points to children developing the "theory of mind" at around 3 or 4 and seem to use an imaginary friend as a means to cope with it. That is not at all the same thing as a belief in a form of life outside the body. That's just a child longing for a special friend, for a myriad of possible reasons, and pretending one exists. "Pretending" is a normal part of childhood development. We even love to do it as adults.

Also to note: not all cultures have children that do this, or do it to the same degree as American or other western children as accounted for in these tests.

Furthermore, when children are raised in a household and community where no deity is ever discussed, they obviously do not automatically believe in one. It has to be taught. It's the same for any other supernatural myth, such as ghosts and demons and boogey-men. You have to plant such a notion in their heads. And of course their impressionable minds believe what authority figures tell them, particularly if there is ambiguity on the part of the parent as to whether something like that could exist. In this way we teach kids to believe in implausible or supernatural entities. Enter Santa Claus.

Rocket science it ain't.

@MichaelSpinler The video dates to 2009, so I'm not ready to agree with the assertion that it's the most recent.

Whatever the case, I agree with you that we don't need to search the cosmos for earth-made mystical concepts and creatures. Santa Claus again comes to mind.

Very well thought out. I did a study on this a few years ago. I found similar problems with the arguments being made. He is definately on the right track. I expect more conversations on this in the future.

1

I watched this recently. Very good. It seems religious belief is becoming recognized as a psychological disorder within the field of psychology. About time. His last sentence, as I remember, is one to note.

0

Looking forward to watching this. Thanks!!

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:448716
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.