Agnostic.com

5 7

A good history lesson about the terms "capitalism" and "socialism," and criticism of the changes of the concepts underlying these terms. . . . Sir Roger Scruton | Full Address and Q&A | Oxford Union . .

JacarC 8 Jan 14
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

5 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

I only watched part of this lecture, and stopped when he characterized conservatives as diffident, “muddling along,” and uncertain. Maybe that’s true of the British Conservative Party, but it’s untrue about American conservatives. In fact, a defining trait of conservatives is their absolute belief in their own infallibility, to the point of needing no research, facts, or consideration of opposing points of view. Racism—an idiotic set of beliefs wholly contradicted by biology—is one example. Another illustration: McConnell’s assertion that no evidence will be allowed in the impeachmrnt hearing: he’s already made up his mind and facts are literally of no interest to him. He’s even willing to commit the felony of false swearing, taking an oath to be impartial after repeatedly announcing that he has no intent to honor that oath. Indeed, to conservatives, the “weakness” of progressives is that they acknowledge that they don’t know it all.

0

He failed to recognise that Russia was one of the "liberators" of Europe during WW2. And a very rose-tinted view of grammar schools, which varied enormously in quality of curriculum. He falsely claimed the capacity to learn lessons from the past as a "conservative" quality. In real life, when identifying a problem it is not always possible to instantaneously think of a solution. Thus it is perfectly valid to complain about injustice or shortcomings before you have the solutions to them. In my vie this character is playing the victim at the same time as stating (he thinks) conservatives do not want change. Lazy argument IMHO.

3

I'm in favor of Democratic Socialism. Every nation that's still doing well is Socialistic.

I favor Democratic Socialism as well. America has it in very limited form and the GOP is trying to get rid of those programs. Who will take care of grandma in the nursing home? Those in power do not care.

Every nation that is doing well is egalitarian Capitalist, with vigorous social programs. None of the nations which are doing well have Socialist governments.

@PBuck0145 No, but it's interesting to see governments who manage a large part of society not run it into the ground. It's rare to meet someone on the right who won't give a long speech about how everything the government does is either evil or incompetent or both. "If we expand social programs we will all be poor." Well, no developed country with the kind of reforms the furthest leftie running for president wants to put into practice, is poor.
In the wake of Roosevelt, America was not poor.
I hope people will remember that in the upcoming election.

2

Kudos to @Jacar for posting this video on this site.

@OwlInASack Considering how badly this site is infested with regressive leftists, his post took considerable courage.

@OwlInASack Not "hard right". Classical (non-leftist) liberal.

1

Capitalist Pyramid, turn of last century
DOH!
Begining of the twentith Century.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:449196
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.