Agnostic.com

5 5

I am a bit of a calling-out-bad-research geek (in nutrition), and that combined with my early career work has given me some knowledge of and appreciation for research, and especially, data-driven decision making. That said, I highly recommend this article, published yesterday, discussing Covid. The oldest axiom in management is that if you can't measure it, you can't manage it. Right now, the Covid measures are lousy.

[statnews.com]

Mitch07102 8 Mar 18
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

5 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

2

Lousy, and expected to be lousy until the wave is past. A pandemic is a slow motion car accident in which the whole world is involved, we are all passengers and will not be able to determine how serious the wreck was until after the fact, if we wake up in the wreckage.

Everything we do in real time now, is like steering, or braking, it might be effective in the crash and it might not. We won't know until after.

That is when we get the good numbers, to learn from. All we have are poor numbers in a Viral Bloom, and we are oft forced to use poor numbers because we have nothing else. It is very very hit or miss.

1

I don't believe we really know much about this virus. My ideas of it is that it can travel through the air without being coughed or sneezed. others would have you believe it is simply alive somewhere for 3 days and you have to touch it in order to move it around. If this was true it would die out quickly, therefore I conclude that it actually can travel in the air as well. Now we can apply "what goes around comes around" and see that we need a vaccine.

It does appear to travel through the air. This is likely why so many health care providers are getting sick: the ventilators push a cloud of virus-laden air into the area around the patient.

itis both airbourne and via droplets, however it is not fully areosol, like measles. Measels will stick to micro dust particles and float around breathable for days.
All evidence thus far shows this does not do this, but when you breathe, and speak, and sneeze, and cough, and sweat, you produce virus which exudes from you. It does not seem to stay long as an areosol, but that is why we need n95 masks, those are for areosols. So if your in the face of an infected, you can breathe it in.
Hence "social distanceing"

This is a misunderstanding of droplets.
" it is simply alive somewhere for 3 days and you have to touch it in order to move it around"
When science says droplets, it means from the wet droplets which are visible in a sneeze, to the micro droplets which are not visible, but rather the humidity of your breath. Those do not travel far, a 3 ft avg, 6 to be safe, and by gravity fall down.

This means, and remains unsaid, that if you go puiblic, your clothing might be covered in microdroplets when you come home, invisible but transferable.

0

I don't think we (as a nation or as a group of nations) have the real life ability to access that data. All we can do now is take it as it comes. An antibody test may be incredibly useful later though.

1

I want to know why healthcare workers and the general public cannot be tested for covid as of 3/18/20 unless they have traveled out of the country.

Because we don't have enough test kits to test the adequately.

1

Good article!! We need data and we need a government can implement what needs to be done to get the data. There's the rub. At this point I do not know that due to politics either side is looking good for this challenge.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:472102
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.