Agnostic.com

7 11

Allow children to choose religion and form world-views after growing up.

St-Sinner 9 Sep 10
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

7 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

I agree with the principle. Unfortunately, most people, while raising a child, start teaching religion and other things which don't really allow that choice to be made. Some kids grow out of it, some don't. That doesn't mean that kids aren't taught values, which is the most important.

0

Impossible to totally eliminate!

All cultures must of necessity enculturate their young. The real question is how to do so.

Some comments below shows a poor understanding of sociology, anthropology, social psychology, and developmental psychology.

Critiques have to be based on facts, not wishful thinking that is contradicted by factual necessities.

As you say. "All cultures must of necessity enculturate their young." That's what the post says, it does not say that you can or must do without it, only that it is a fact.

@Fernapple You are right. I was more responding to some of the comments supporting the elimination of all the post describes.
Thanks. I'll edit my comment.

@Krish55 That's ok. You are welcome.

1

It's a vicious cycle. My mom didn't get into religion until I was in my teens. I went with her for a time out of respect. I'm glad my eyes were opened about 25 years ago and saw it all as farce.

1

I fell for religion because I knew that all of the adults had to be right. After all, look at how long religion has been here. Now I loathe religions because I know that nobody is right. Raise a child with certain order and discipline but without imaginary and invisible beings.

2

18 is too late.

What is the right age?

@St-Sinner As early as possible children should be protected in their reaching out to this new world, instead of being poisoned with fantastic nonsense that is antithetical to what reality is.

1

Where did these researchers come from? Loompaland?

Changed

1

If that were the law, few would choose religion.

And, I would be ok with that. Indoctrination is all they know and how they control

@Focus1 Was going to make an ironic comment, but thanks for your pre-emptive idiocy.

@OldMetalHead That dude sure is fixated on “commies.” 😉

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:686059
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.