Agnostic.com

13 5

What do you think about the idea that the "god experience" is within you, is part of being and accessible via meditation?

Hello fellow agnostics, I am appealing to your open minded curiosity to help me explore an idea about the mind's capability for being in grace.

I am coming to believe that there is a great misrepresentation of the higher self as some kind of "external god" . What I mean by the higher self is that part of our mind that is able to rest in the present moment with a sense of grace, and which can observe our sensations , emotions, thoughts with a sense of calm wisdom.... usually accessible via meditation or moments of peace and perhaps in flow. ( By "in flow" I mean when you are completely into something- like playing music, or painting, or whatever it is you absolutely adore to do).

As a person who meditates daily, I am familiar with the experience of exquisite grace... and as an atheist, I have come to understand that this is a beautiful part of me accessible when I am able to quieten the chatter of my mind.

I can see how this experience is incredibly difficult to explain - i know I am doing a pretty unsophisticated job of it... and I can see how those who have tried to explain it have often been misrepresented. I also propose that some ( the highly charismatic and eloquent among us) have had misguided and rigid religions spring from their attempts to share their experience.

I can also see that this experience ( deep meditation - oneness - grace... ) would be interpreted by whatever belief system you brought to it... after all that's all we have in our wordy conscious mind- boxes for ideas and words for the clumsy expression of these ideas.

So, I am hoping there are some fellow meditators who are also atheists for open minded sharing . I am keen to explore.

SueZ 5 May 5
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

13 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

That is certainly one way go SueZ. I do feel like that occasionally

1

The words experience, grace, external are very much in tune to a interpretation of mystical experiences, that tend to be alterations of consciousness which can be derived from meditation, but also flow states, music, dancing, drugs. Besides the flow, there are near death experiences, lucid dreams, psychedelic experiences, all alterations of consciousness similar to mystical experiences described in religious texts. The alterations of levels consciousness (ALC) include many states of consciousness described by meditation masters, including higher levels described in Yoga, Buddhism, but in scientific terms these would be just ALC induced by meditation, but the interpretation differ depending in the school of meditation, which are thousands of them. But I agreed more with the Taoism interpretation and the zen tradition that one needs to experience this states rather than theorizing about them. I am very open minded being atheist and meditation practioner and having experienced alterations in consciousness with meditation without drugs, having seen light, having felt peace, compassion, is now difficult for me reduce consciousness to the brain without exploring more the meaning, and the experience, that is the phenomenology.

1

Your Answer:
in brief I think that this is what some experience as god. I happy with that, as long as my experience and perception respected, too, if I’m asked. It’s wonderful, and a rising tide lifts all boats, praying is a type of meditation for some. The ones who try to make that peace or grace into a diety that can be handled or cashed in on sicken me, & so I don’t trust or appreciate religious organizations. good questions.

0

I'm reading a little about Kabbalah lately in a desperate attempt to get some meaning from Finnegans Wake. Your post made me think of Adam Cadmon, who I think might be called the archetype of the perfect human. He has the divine attributes of the Kabbalist god. I must say I don't believe in an external god. I'm convinced that god is a name tag for the best of our human aspirations. I don't agree with your use of the word 'grace', coming from the tradition Christian understanding, but I know what you are communicating. I think this 'grace' is the net value of your own good thoughts, an idea already brought up by one of the other posters.

0

In my opinion only: when you meditate the traditional way of trying to cleanse your mind from the external connections it establishes from the outside world what manifests is the internal data in your mind which you let out in the absence of external data. However, these are not random data created because you are already instructing the thought patterns you want to produce and your brain manifests the thoughts/awakenings/manifestations available. The so-called 'higher plane/conciousness' is just your internal data overpowering your external data. That is why some claim to experience a god because that is exactly what they want their brain to produce. It is like there is a mass murder and a baby survived. A person would look at it and see a miracle happened because a baby survived because in his mind something made this possible which could be a 'god' when clearly there should not have been a mass murder if a miracle god was true. In short for me, when you 'meditate' your brain gives you the desired result you want. There is a man in Europe who cannot function without listening to heavy metal music. His brain is 'wired' to it. I myself meditate while doing a lot of things like eating, working, looking at anything and if I concentrate on whatever it is I'm thinking of inspite of my activities the whole world seems to open to me. To finish, the god experience is manifested to people who have thoughts of a god and for other people what manifests is what they want to manifest like a demon, angel, fairy, etc. Have you tried knowing all the details of a particular subject so much that your brain literally opens up possibilities you haven't thought about?

2

there is n doubt that the god metaphor refers to the inner god, the one we wear on our faces.
meditations goal is to be able to permanently stop our inner chatter and enable us to control the brain/emotional flow.

mzee Level 7 May 6, 2018
4

I personally don’t like the word “grace”, it has a negative religious assosiation for me, but I love the ideas you describe and I am an atheist. I have tried recently to meditate with an app but my state of mind at the moment seems to be too anxious and distracted for it to work. I desperately want to relax!...does anyone have any advice as to how I can get into meditation?

I often use an app called Insight Timer, aside from the timer you have a plethora of guided meditations. I use them when I feel as you describe. Sometimes I can sit in silence more readily than others. The key however is to never have judgement or expectations. It is impossible to meditate badly or incorrectly, it is what it is. I would find guided meditations that appeal to you, gradually add time on your own without the app... it’s also helpful to find a local group, a synergy happens when you meditate with others. I went to a guru for this for more than a year, the teachings were as important as the meditations themselves. When the guru said, if science finds Buddhism to be wrong it is Buddhism that must change... in that sentance I found exploring the inner self to be grounded in reality, I envoke no Mumbo-jumbo🙂 most important thing is simply don’t judge, never judge... if you find yourself judging don’t judge it, let it go... you never stop being human and nobody can actually clear their mind, nor is that the desire. Just be present, follow the breath, it grounds you in the present as it is what your body is always doing, notice it, be curious about it and be kind to yourself☯️ I’m adding as an edit: every time your mind wanders to, I’m hungry, what time is it? Gotta get the bills paid... whatever? that is the opportunity, what you are doing is noticing that your mind has wandered and gently bringing it back to breath or the focus of your meditation... it’s normal and expected. If your mind did not wander you would have no need to meditate and no tools with which to do it.

There's so good free stuff on youtube, if all places for that. 8 hour sleep/meditation music & guided meditation as well. Enjoy.

@ScienceBiker 10 hrs... I like it, may keep it handy. I’m not so hardcore into meditation that I can do the 10 hrs in one sitting🙂 one great thing about the modern interpretations of meditation is we can find small blocks of time so it fits our busy lives. However, I like the saying, if you have time to meditate do it for an hour, if you haven’t got an hour to meditate do it for two hours?☯️

I personally don’t think you can really force your mind to quieten and meditate. If there is noise, anxiety or restlessness or absence of grounding, then I feel one needs to bottom out and expulse the frantic energy. At some point our mind learns to align to our spirit and it reaches a tipping point after which there is sudden and obvious clarity. Don’t suppress your nervous energy, let it flow through you. Also don’t be ashamed of it

5

I meditate and I’m an atheist, no conflict of terms or interest. I’m also a musician and find a similarity. I did not recognize the meditative quality of music before starting a meditation practice and looking at through that lens. I think of meditation as the removal of filters but it sometimes becomes the filter in its own way, it’s my time without judgment or concern for past or future. My meditation is very active in its focus on the present, it’s not a clearing of the mind, it’s the repeated letting go of what comes, what you push away comes at you faster. My desire is to be fully in the present. Without the minds distractions we would have no tools to strengthen our attention. I have not found a point in meditation that makes me believe anything is happening that I did not create but should I feel that way I would attribute it to something created by the mind.

6

I meditate for relaxation. The rest, nope.

3

I got nothing for you..... You carry on

1

It sounds like you're describing the natural "high" of endorphins and corticotropin. Increases in their levels can be self-triggered by an experienced meditator, they can even reach similar levels as they would in a long distance runner during the "second wind".

Although cortisol isn't related to the feeling of a higher state, both practices also trigger it's release. It's stress hormone and steroid. It's easy to see why stress hormones would be released during excercise but much more interesting that it is released during meditation.

@SueZ on cortisol: [healthdirect.gov.au]

On hormone release during meditation: [sciencedirect.com]

Unfortunately only a summary of the second article is available unless you have access through work, or are willing to pay. The great problem with peer reviewed science, it's often only available to scientists!

3

And that, folks, is how you get stinkeye_a to follow you.

Mention meditation, "god experience", open minded curiosity, exploration, and higher self all in the same post--and cross reference it against misguided and rigid religions, interpretation, and belief systems, and you become stinkeye_a's new favorite member. 😀

2

I enjoy clearing my mind daily as well, I call it a nap.

Emme Level 7 May 6, 2018
Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:74598
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.