Agnostic.com

6 15

I was trying to mow the lawn this morning but the grass was too wet. I was heading back to the house when I heard a voice ask, "Ma'am, could you give me some water?" I turned to see a woman standing on the side of the road holding a water bottle. She had a pack on her back, no teeth, and looked much the worse for wear.

I said, "Yes," and took the bottle, asking her if she would like some ice. Yes, she would. She started to tell me her tale of woe, saying she had not eaten and had run out of water. Her hands were shaking.

I filled the bottle with ice and water, and took a banana out to her. I don't have a lot of "disposable" food in my house, so there wasn't much to offer. She was sitting on the ground in the shade. She took the bottle and the banana and asked if she could sit there while eating/drinking. I replied in the affirmative and said I had some work to do in the house.

I feel totally inadequate in situations such as this. My desire to help is tempered by my "common sense" which tells me not to do TOO much as she might not leave or she might come back. I won't give people money for various reasons--especially in a case such as this where she might return for more.

I graded a discussion and when I looked out the window again, she was gone. I am going into town and if she is walking that way, I will stop and give her a ride.

If I were a Christian, I would say, "there but for the grace of god, go I," but it is through my own perseverance that I am not this woman. However, she does make me realize how "lucky" I am--I was born with intelligence and made use of it. Some people are not so genetically lucky and some were raised and continued to live in situations which were deplorable.

As Vonnegut wrote, "And so it goes."

Gwen_Wanderer 7 July 19
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

6 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

Sometimes even intelligent people end up in dire straits. It might not be for lack of trying that this woman finds herself where she is. I live in one of the poorest cities in my state, but I never see homeless people or beggars around here. We also pay some of the highest property taxes and most of that money goes to the schools and to feed children (all year round) and to provide low income housing. We have a homeless shelter and women's shelter. I think that the community is doing the best they can with what they have. And I think they are more successful than other cities.

I know that some people wind up in dire straits not for lack of trying. I had two friends who (respectively) lived in their cars for a period of time before I knew them. One simply could not find a place to live (it was in a college town as school started back up); the other was shafted in a divorce and her husband has siphoned all of the money out of their bank accounts prior to filing divorce. The latter learned a lesson about not allowing husbands to control the money.

However, one gets a feel for this type of person and people who are in dire straits due to other issues.

Both of my friends pulled out of their situation. The first got her MA and became a prof in Alaska. The other remarried and went on to build a successful design business. Their experiences haunted them "forever" and pushed them to succeed.

Also, it is not just a case of "intelligence." For me, it was because my education is what makes my living. However, I also know people who have different types of intelligence who support themselves. My mechanic has probably never read a book, but he can fix my car.

1

and the really weird thing is that america considers itself to be the richest country.
i hate to think where it'll be when the bottom totally falls out of the financial system & the 35 trillion $ debt has to be reckoned with.

I hate to think of that, too.

When I was a kid, I heard people criticize other countries by saying, "At least we don't have beggars in the streets here." Well, the "beggars" have now been in the streets for decades.

5

You did the right thing. Compassion with a bit of leeriness.

Thanks--it is good to be validated!

5

You did the right thing, food and water and shade.
NEVER give money as it could easily result in death by overdose.... at least 3 times when I have offered a meal and water/coffee to these people I have been told, loudly FU as they are panhandling for drug money Only and could care less about food.

I have heard people say that when we give money to someone, it is not our concern as to how they spend it. If I work hard to make that money, I am not going to give it to someone to buy alcohol or drugs.

Years ago, I was in Branson when a woman approached me in a Walmart parking lot. She said she hurt her arm and needed money to get to the hospital. I told her she could call 911 and they would be required to help her. She curses at me and walked away. A few months later, the SAME woman approached me in a Walmart parking lot in Springfield. Not only did I remember her face, but she had a distinctive voice. Same excuse--she hurt her arm and needed to get to the hospital.

I said, "Sorry, you tried that tactic before and when I turned you down, you cussed me out."

She cussed me out again!

@Gwen_Wanderer Deja vu all over again.....

@annewimsey500 it was a bit amusing--sad, but amusing.

7

People fall down or are beaten down by a multitude of different problems; the "thousand natural shocks that flesh is heir to," as The Bard put it. We can't even begin to solve all the problems of every poor soul that crosses our path. That's why compassionate societies institute social programs to help the poor. By pooling our resources, we can actually provide housing and healthcare to people in dire straits. And we could do even more in this country, but we would need the rich to pay their fair share of taxes. Good luck with that.

Agreed.

Or cut "defense" spending!

@PaddyO Sure, the defense industry is like a bloated tick. But it does serve some important functions. Obviously it's a good thing to be able to defend ourselves. And certain industries (e.g. ship building, aerospace) never left our shores (when so many others did) because their products, by law, had to be made domestically.

Most of the military budget is actually service pay and pensions. (Pensions being the larger part, by far).

The military can and does bring people from many different backgrounds together. It can have a beneficial, unifying effect.

I propose that we do like the Israelis: everyone serve at least two years in the military. That way everyone is a veteran, eligible for veterans benefits including medical. Just combine the VA with Medicare, and expand it to cover 100% of the population. Automatic universal health care! Boom!

We can talk about which overseas bases to close.

We can ferret out waste, fraud, and abuse.

We can make the service more equitable and safe for women, gays, etc.

We can refuse to allow politicians in the pockets of billionaires to use our military to protect the interests of multinational corporations whose products are destroying the natural environment. Yes, I'm talking about the fossil fuel industry.

6

There is a fine balance between a generous heart and self-preservation. It is very easy to cross that line on one side or the other. You managed to keep that balance perfectly and I am very proud of you. 🤗

Betty Level 8 July 20, 2024

I agree that is is fine line. Though I don't usually walk the "middle line," I feel that protecting self is important.

Thank you, my friend!

@Gwen_Wanderer Uncertainty should always err on the side of self-protection.

@Betty always!

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:761636
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.