Agnostic.com

33 6

I've had a couple of people ask me if I've read "Men Are from Mars Women Are from Venus". Today I went out and bought the book. Has anyone else read this book and if so what did you think about it?

SonderOpia 8 May 16
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

33 comments (26 - 33)

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

2

Read it with gf about 20 years ago. Was great fun discussing. Today remember little.

7

This book contains too many generalizations about men and women. I stopped reading it.

I don't like it when people stereotype others, for example, "Mexicans are lazy" or "women are emotional."

3

If I remember correctly, there's a chapter about "how to avoid arguments." I thought it was wrong information to put out for the most part. Here's my take on arguments. They are GOOD! Any relationship that lasts will have MANY arguments...so I don't agree that they should be "avoided". There is a right way and a right way to DO it, but airing your thoughts to your partner, even if it's arguing and gets loud, is healthy. Where you cross the line of course, is if you begin throwing out verbal abusive slants toward the other person, or becoming physical.

My wife and I regularly argue and I'm not ashamed to admit it. It's what I feel has kept us strong for going on 20 years. Afterward, we always "kiss and make up" and we tend to speak TO each other eventually about the topic instead of AT each other, which does happen frequently when each person is upset or feels they really need to get their point across to the other person.

Arguments are healthy, as long as boundaries are respected.

4

Read it, and have discussed its concepts many times. I found it interesting, and fundamentally, theoretically sound. Men and women do have different ways of looking and responding to their world; but there are also many similarities and commonalities. Like any self-help book, I saw this one as being an opportunity for some people to become more mindful and emotionally competent. No one size fits all and i know many who found it useful. Did you?

I haven't started it yet. I plan on starting to read it today. I still want to read it just to see what it's all about. Plus I enjoy reading and hope to get a little something out of it. Even if it doesn't have much to offer it'll make me stop and think.

@SonderOpia I just bought Transitions by William Bridges for 3 of my contacts who are going though major changes in their lives. It is another worthwhile read. I also know that many people read such books like they do mysteries and fiction. But self-help books are different if one wants to get maximum benefit from them. When reading a self-help book, as we come across suggestions and options which might help we need to first personalize how the suggested fixes could work for us. I've always suggested to clients that they journal in a separate notebook as one reads through any book which one chose as a helper. I hope i haven't been presumptuous with my suggestion.

@josephr that's a great idea to write in a notebook while you're reading a book. Taking notes is very helpful. Thanks for the advice.

@SonderOpia my pleasure. Enjoy

5

It's a long winded way of saying men's minds and womens minds work differently. at the time it was written it might have been relevant but society as a whole has moved on now there is no longer that much of a split between the sexes some men act really effeminate if I asked my dad what moisturiser he used he'd look at me like I'm taking the piss but I regularly hear guys in their 20 discussing what products they use while at work and I have met a lot of women who act extremely masculine compared to gender stereotypes from the 80/90s. Honestly no book can tell you how a mans mind works I'm one and I don't even know how mine works. We do dumb shit for no reason at all and it doesn't matter how smart the man.

Well considering I'm almost 50 years old the men I'll be dating aren't millennials so maybe they'll fit the book better?

2

I get the feeling I should. I'm off work for summer break and maybe the library has it??

3

I did read it and I felt like it fed right into a lot of the stereotypes people believe about each of the sexes...I didn't take anything from it that helped my relationship at all, but it was a decent read.

1

I really can't wait to start reading it. It sounds like it should be good.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:82412
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.