Agnostic.com

49 4

Here is a question for men: how do you react to a woman crying? Not because she saw something sappy on tv, but because things hurt her.

RapidCityKelly 6 June 1
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

49 comments (26 - 49)

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

2

Offer assistance in any way I could.

1

I feel compelled to comfort them. Its immediate and urgent.

1

I put the kettle on and make a nice cup of tea.

1

Depends on the context. If appropriate and wanted: consolation and possibly assistance. If she doesn't want my attention I try to mind my own business. There's been a few times a woman has done something horrible, started crying when she got called out on her behavior expecting consoling and I walked away because that was appropriate and even necessary. In fact I should've done that last one a few more times than I did.

1

Depends, genuine emotional and empathetic sorrow I will comfort, crying because she is hurt because she did not get her own way and is trying to elicit sympathy and her own way after all, will be ignored.

@DianaGinger
I use the word she here in a generic form of address to indict any or all individuals being considered within the context of the given discussion.
It is not meant to indicate any specific individual, rather emotional type or types.
As to your specific inquiry the persons in question are being referred to in terms of their emotion maturity rather than biological age, and their motivation for genuine or faux emotional reaction.
In this context, it is perfectly possible for anyone, of any gender to behave with the the emotional maturity of a person of any age for nefarious reasons of their own especially for the emotional manipulation of the the gullible.

This is so typical. Sad. You must think women are world class cry on demand creatures. smh

@Qualia
No not all women, but some can and do, so do some men and most children can.
People emotionally manipulate other people, it is a fact that has given rise to some of the world's greatest literature.

You not liking a fact does not make it untrue

@LenHazell53 Same to you Len.... I'm not a "crier on demand" so this is a judgment call to me. I NEVER cried at ANYTHING much before motherhood. It's all hormones and a larger "library" of emotions I've had since. I am cellophane and have trouble having a "poker face" as it is. HOLDING IN A CRY, is a HERCULEAN EFFORT for me.
I've never known or met a "fake crier", but I've met my share of people who think it's fake. I don't keep relationships with those types of people if I can help it. Period.

@Qualia
I'm sorry if you feel attacked or judged, I don't know you and made no call about you personally whatsoever, I was speaking generally and from experience.
I have been married twice and my first wife could turn on the tears as easily as turning on a tap to get her own way with her father, it did not work with her mother or sister who would simply tell her to belt up, and she did, it was remarkable to see.
I've known other people capable of doing this before and since, as a trained actor I can do it myself, but have never used it off stage and never would lie like that to another person.
My point was simply yes I am empathic to another person's distress and will assist any way I can, but given good reason to believe it is not genuine, I will ignore it, I do not like emotional games from anyone as it does a disservice to them and to people's feelings generally.

@LenHazell53 I think the "disbelief" based on comments from men in particular on here is very telling.
Here's one scenario I experienced: After months of fighting a serious issue with one of my dogs was referred to a "double certified veterinary dermatological specialist", one of only two in the country. After 5 months of being at my wit's end broke into tears in the exam room.
This no soul motherfucker was so cold to me as I was bawling my head off, and I paid $800 for the "privilege" of his prescribing a dangerous antibiotic AND his disgusting reaction to my emotional exhaustion. Which I won't go into here but suffice it to say I hope he dies a horrible miserable death and I will NEVER set foot in his office again nor recommend him to anyone.
So yes, it's very common, this heartless POV when people crack to the point of tears.

I'm a shitty actress. Couldn't act my way out of a paper bag. I'd have to play myself if I was in anything. ...

@Qualia strikes me as asperergers

1

All to often it is the very man that you may be looking for emotional support can very well be the cause and some men are impervious but to their own emotional handicap such as sociopaths and psychopaths who are impervious to therapy let alone a simple hug for your sadness and tears

1

That's the time to really put words to a good use

1

I typically ask what’s wrong? Is there something I can do to help you?

1

share it

1

I'm hard-wired as male, so of course I try to help her. Men who don't yield to their women partners doom the relationship.

"John Gottman, a well known marriage researcher, and his colleagues followed 130 newlywed couples for six years to find what marriages succeeded and why. Turns out, happy, stable marriages had one thing in common: The husband was willing to accept his wife's influence.

In contrast, when husbands responded to their wives' complaints by stonewalling or belittling them, the marriage was almost sure to fail: More than four-fifths of those relationships — 81 percent — fell apart."

Gottman, John M., and Nan Silver. (1999). “Principle 4: Let Your Partner Influence You,” in The Seven Principles for Making Marriages Work (Chapter Six,

1

If she’s a friend of mine, I ask her what’s wrong and try to comfort her.

1
  1. Recognise that tears validate everything she says
  2. Accept blame if possible
  3. If you are not to blame, offer to beat up the offender
  4. Try to turn the situation into an opportunity for sex
1

With sympathy and empathy.....if I think it's legit.

1

A big hug and some thoughtful words are the best. Understanding the problem is the key. Having raised all girls allows me to spot drama a mile away. ?

Be there for them, let them get it out, and keep loving them.

@Holysocks always.

@Mikeb56
Most important, keep our stupid mouths shut! 🙂

@Holysocks we as men tend to open our mouths only to change feet when it comes to these matters. ?

@Mikeb56
Hahahaha! Very well typed sir!

1

Really it depends. I feel a great deal of empathy for anyone who is hurting/sad/frustrated,but..... My Ex suffered from Borderline Personality Disorder and would cry at the drop of a hat, often over the most benign events. Other times she would use it to manipulate me, if she didn't get the response she wanted she would cry more hysterically or rage that I wasn't responding.

@CrazyQuilter I know all about Cluster B personality disorders and emotional Black Holes (vampires)

1

Ask’er what’s wrong. If I’m the one who hurt her, apologize and try to make amends. Otherwise just listen. She’s smart enough to figure out a course of action.

0

Communication is key along with compassion and affection.

0

Inquire as to why she’s crying and if she wants to discuss it.

0

This question is too general to answer. I have way too many clarifying questions of my own. Something physical is easy. First stop what is hurting her, apply appropriate first aid. Emotional pain is another thing. All I can do is similar to above. Appropriate first aid depends on the person and relationship...and the history.

0

I'm the father of 2 adult girls so my first reflex is to hold, console and listen.
However, as a manager, I received an incredible lesson from a woman 12-15 years ago. She came into my office and we were talking and she suddenly broke into to tears, I was in my late 20s and quite confused (she was at least 10 years older). She explained to me that not everyone reacts the same way and that her default reaction was to cry whether the information she received was bad or good. It was simply her way of exteriorising he feelings and that I shouldn't feel bad for it.
I never got a chance to really thank her (I went on leave for burn-out not long afterwards) but I wish I did. She gave me a perspective that has served me ever since that moment. That woman helped make me who I am (not as much as my ex-wife but that is another story).
TL😀R It depends, look at the circumstances and be empathetic.

EricJ Level 4 June 3, 2018
0

I no longer know female tears are real? However I would like to think that should a lady friend be truthfully tearful I could be of assistance to her on an emotional level.

Good lord it's everywhere.

0

I may think about the reason why she's crying, but I'm not likely to do much more. I don't assume that I am helping a good person because I may have some urge to help them, that is foolish.

I hope I never become so jaded I will not help anyone. Sure I have helped the "bad" people at times but are they less worthy than "good" people? I have also fallen for the fake 'I have no money and have a baby' scenario, Myself I will rather lose a few bucks helping the fake ones to make sure I can help the true ones. But that's just me.

@MacTavish

Yeah they're less worthy than the good people haha being jaded is awesome

@DZhukovin No one person is worth more than another.

@MacTavish That isn't true

0

very good question!
If she is young my brain immediately give signals to fall in love with her and comfort her.
If she is old enough then my heart starts beating for my mother.

IAS1 Level 5 June 1, 2018
0

Sometimes she cries because she been drinking like I witnessed last weekend and now she can't recall what it was as she told me today.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:96671
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.