Agnostic.com

13 5

How big a factor?

How big a factor is the fear of death in fueling human religiosity? When I hear people say, about a deceased person, things like, "She's with Jesus now." or "She and her beloved Johnny are together again in heaven." I want to wring their f'in necks! I overhead my own cousin tell her dying mother, "Let go, Mom . . . Go be with Dickie (my aunt's deceased son) and Daddy. They're waiting for you." Will most people say and do anything to ease the sting of death?

By RobLawrence7
Actions Follow Post Like

Post a comment Add Source Add Photo

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

13 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

I'm with you. Those statements drive me nuts.

0

Why not? I imagine a very scary time for some. Why not make their last moments pleasurable instead of trying to score atheist brownie points!

Geoffrey51 Level 8 July 24, 2018

What if telling them fairy stories helps their passing and makes it less traumatic. Probably s bit late for s death bed conversion to atheism. Someone dying is about them surely. Not the quirks and foibles of a world They need no longer consider.

1

All of these statements are for the living, the dead cannot hear. In talking to someone who is alive, I would think telling them to go see dog would be useful for them, but what are you doing? Are you doing this for you or for them? The fear of death? Personally I do not fear death, actually I look forward to it as experiencing the process will answer many questions? What I fear is dying? It seems to be painful, expensive, be the source for much dread, be costly for many in ways that have nothing to do with money, and be a total pain in the ass for anyone close to you. When I go I would like to have my body dumped into the local bay, out of site as it will be gross, and let the wildlife use me to feed and replenish nutrients that I no longer need. I would hope for there to be some money in an account that is used for a party where everyone, whether they knew me or not, could have a good time.

If you want an after death party in your honor, be sure to set up an account and designate it as your money for your wake . Be sure to appoint a trustworthy person to see that the party is created and run as you planned .

@Cast1es Thanks for reminding me, I am setting up a trust for the house and the party.

1

The vast majority of humans cannot accept finality of life. It is one of the primary drivers of religion, I believe. They find it hard to accept that they are insignificant and only have a limited time to exist. Even my father, who never stated it was I believe an agnostic, was hedging his bets near the end of his life, and trying to believe in god. As my religious friends like to say, if my non belief is wrong it will be too late when I’m dead to change. If they are wrong in believing, when they die, they won’t know the difference. Doesn’t change my outlook, still don’t believe.

1

That's the major bait in pitching religion - the fear of death, and of hell, and/or the promise of an afterlife in heaven. I think most people would do anything, or even say anything, to comfort a dying loved one. For my parents, I just said thank you for everything, and I love you. (They weren't into bullshit either)

Byrdsfan Level 8 July 16, 2018
1

From the great Jim Jeffries. I don't want to live in existance for ever, It's eternal, you'll get used to it, then you'll be fucking bored.

Oh, and no, I do not fear death.

@JustKip The funny part is , if they actually got 72 virgins , they'd have to remain virgins , because it's against their religion to have sex outside of their marriage .....

2

The oldest and strongest emotion of mankind is fear, and the oldest and strongest kind of fear is fear of the unknown.
This is a key reason why people flock to religion..because it dangles hope in front of a human..and human nature is to survive..even after death... blind faith, hope and terror of this great unknown overides reason, evidence, and that terrible abyss of truth..that we must all face our mortality.

Hitchens Level 8 July 16, 2018

That's probably why they flock to Christianity, not religion.

@Geoffrey51

Why flock to Cristianity and not Religion ? Elborate a little..?

@Hitchens Christianity isn't the only religion. I am not aware that anyone heads to Buddhism or Taoism or Judaism or Islam out of hope for something after life. Christianity seems to fill that gap in he market!

2

Even if it is a big factor, where is the harm? If it is a kind of anodyne to these people and it does not impinge on your mental health - who cares?

Matias Level 8 July 16, 2018
0

Things get a lot weirder when people around believe in reincarnation, just saying.

DSGavde Level 6 July 16, 2018
0

I think it's a pretty big factor for a lot of people.

0

Yep, I agree and it annoys the heck out of me as well. My uncle recently passed. I hadn't known that his mother died in childbirth. People kept saying at the funeral that they know he will be so happy to finally meet his mother. The flipping priest even said it during the sermon!

Marcie1974 Level 8 July 16, 2018
0

It is one of two main factors of most religions. The fear of death and the use of that fear to control the masses in a society.

PDF Level 5 July 16, 2018
1

I think it gives comfort to the dying and those left behind. Raised in an atheist family, I struggled with where my dad was because it was just too hard to imagine that he disappeared altogether. I went to a church to talk to the reverend for an opinion and to explain my dilemma. She immediately started talking about Jesus and there she lost me right away. I told her I don’t do Jesus and thanked her and left.

Sydland Level 7 July 16, 2018

@RobLawrence it was when my dad died

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text 'q:132239'.
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content read full disclaimer.
  • Agnostic.com is a non-profit community for atheists, agnostics, humanists, freethinkers, skeptics and others!