Agnostic.com

15 4

the number 40 apparently appears in scripture 146 times

why is God so obsessed with that specific number?

is it simply a lazy thing? using symbolic numbers instead of actual ones

doesnt it prove that the bible is historical fiction?

HeAdAkE 6 Feb 15
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

15 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

not sure "historical fiction" is a genre, but imo you're on the right track, yeh
theres about five diff genres used in the Bible, can't find the list now but its in here somewhere
[biblicalhistoricalcontext.com]
prolly other places too

1

Two possible explanations:

  1. they actually wanted 36, but that was taken by the Muslims

  2. in the Jewish language, 40=bullshit

0

Generally two people can count that on all of their fingers and toes.

0

It's fiction

bobwjr Level 10 Feb 16, 2021
1

The whole concept of god is a fiction of man’s, the bible is a human construct, therefore everything in it is also manufactured by man. Whether or not 40 is overused in the bible is completely immaterial and may or may not be construed as laziness, but only those who believe that the bible is god’s word need to worry about that, not those of us who don’t. We needn’t give it a second thought.

0

I don't understand the concept of God being obsessed with a number (except for 42, or course). The Jewish numerology tradition, known as gematria, puts a great value on certain numbers, so if you look, you can find them anywhere. 40 indicates transformation or purification. Raining for 40 days and 40 nights, fasting for 40 days.

0

I thought the magic number was 45 and that’s how evangelists wiggled trump into their theology?

Mvtt Level 7 Feb 15, 2021
0

They hadn't invented umpteen.

3

Because OBVIOUSLY the Xtian God can't count to 42 which is the answer to life, the universe and everything else.

do u know where our mother is?

hes father right

wheres our mum?

0

If you want to believe it.

1

LOL, possibly by the time Imaginary, Invisible Sky Daddy got around to getting some weak minded human to write the Buybull for him he had already developed Dementia hence when counting using the ONLY things available to him/her/it, the fingers and toes, Sky Daddy just repeated counting them twice until an Imaginary Sky Angel stopped him. LOL

3

All religious text are made up by humans to control humans.

3

It is a formula style of writing and the number 40 can simply mean "a long time." Some people put significance to all of the "magic numbers" of the bible but you have to understand that the stories were past down to others and nobody actually knew how long Jesus was in the desert, etc.

Is the bible historical fiction? No. There is nothing historical about it.

2

It is a pun
ארבעים is hebrew for 40 and is pronounced Albi'im
The phrase על באים pronounced Al' byim
is Hebrew for on coming, in the sense of "that which is will be" the on coming storm etc
Therefore 40 days and 40 nights is the inevitable future, the time of inevitable change.

3

Who knows?
Who cares?

It doesn't rise to the level of "historical fiction".

thank u for the words

very interesting stuff

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:576529
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.