55 8

POLL Pie or Cake?

Put candles in a cake and it's a party, put candles in a pie and someone's drunk in the kitchen....... but what do YOU think?

View Results Add Comment
Please or register to see comments



Drunk, sober? Who cares! It's fucking pie!

SaucyCheryl Level 5 May 11, 2018

You are saucy!

@gater I'm a true GRITS.


You're evil for having us choose πŸ˜‹

omalita Level 5 May 11, 2018

Now this is the sort of poll I can really sink my teeth into!


Oh screw it, 3.14 πŸ˜‚

Emme Level 7 May 11, 2018

Really? Does no one get it?
It's Pi...πŸ˜‘


@Emme The way the site seems to be set up, it takes time for replies/posts to be seen by others

It might be so.πŸ‘


Can we choose pie AND cake???

annedoneal Level 5 May 11, 2018

Nope, you cannot have your cake and eat it too....only I can because well...I take the cakesmile009.gif


I can have my cake and eat pie too😜

Emme Level 7 May 11, 2018

Depends on what type of pie vs what type of cake

Proto Level 6 May 11, 2018

Related question: What category does cheese cake fall under?


Both, please

Gripster31 Level 5 May 11, 2018


Secretguy Level 5 May 11, 2018

can’t make up my mind..
I like certain types of both, but now I’m really craving strawberry rhubarb pie, thanks.

AMGT Level 8 May 11, 2018

Oh strawberry rhubarb is the BEST!!!

Rhubarb sucks! 🀒

I’ve never had it, but cherry pie πŸ–€


Either, as long as it's served with good coffee.


Pie. But only because I've never heard of a pizza cake.

WTSharpe Level 5 May 11, 2018

Sure you have
"How was the exam, hard?"
"No it was a pizza cake"
....I'll get my coat




Just wait until someone (else) adds coconut to your mashed potatoes. It did really tasted different and the person who made thought it was really good. Yuk.

Marine Level 8 May 11, 2018


billybass Level 3 May 11, 2018

Not a big fan of frosting, and with most store bought cakes, the frosting is the best part. At least with pie you usually get a flaky buttery crust and sometimes fruit. Not as easy to write on though...

Kafir Level 6 May 11, 2018

I love a good fresh baked fruit pie ! None of those cream creations for me ! Oh no ! Fruit please, and yes, candles for a birthday on pie is just as good as in a cake !πŸ€ͺ

SinderSue Level 2 May 11, 2018

I agree. My daughter doesn't like cake, so we often did pie, brownies, etc.


I like both but prefer my cake without frosting. I just think frosting is too sweet and can't eat it.

jonds56 Level 6 May 11, 2018

If you will marry me, you can have all my cake if I can have all your frosting!

@SallyMc Too funny!! I'm the guy in the corner at a wedding dinner scraping my frosting into the garbage.


Here in the U.K. if you say pie we generally think savoury, so pie then cake, and if you say you meant fruit pie then I'm gonna plead ignorance and try a bit of that as well

What do you call sweet pies that don't have fruit?

@cmadler I'm trying to think of a sweet pie that is not made with fruit...... Hmmmm.....help? Oh, chocolate!!

@BlueWave Pecan pie, chess pie, Derby pie, pumpkin pie, and sweet potato pie are the first that come to mind. I'm sure I could name others if I think about it a bit.

We don't really have those, but a pie is still a pie, I love apple pie and cherry pie, but if somebody says pie I'm thinking Steak pie or chicken pie

@cmadler Touche! πŸ‘πŸ˜Š


I love to bake cakes, so that's definitely my preference

Have you made Whole Foods' Fruit Chantilly cake? OMG. There is a copycat recipe online. So delicious!

@BlueWave I haven't! I'll check it out.


Pie for sure


My husband said he married me for my apple pie. I hope that was not the only reason.

Lorajay Level 5 May 13, 2018

yes .... and butter tarts too.

MissaDixon Level 5 May 13, 2018

Actually, if I could only ever have one thing, it would be donuts.

Secretguy Level 5 May 11, 2018

Nuts of the D'oh!☺

Write Comment
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content read full disclaimer
  • Agnostic.com is a non-profit community for atheists, agnostics, humanists, freethinkers, skeptics and others happy without religion!