Agnostic.com

16 1

What are views on nationalism? Do you think it is as dangerous as religion and god?

Srijith 7 Jan 2
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

16 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

On average, humans are selfish, yet value loyalty. That gets a lot of people into a lot of trouble.

1

The hurricane doesn't know the nationality of the people who live on the shore it devastates.

The epidemic doesn't check itself at national borders.

The starving stomach doesn't know where the rice was grown.

The ocean currents don't care where the trash gets deposited.

We are all pink on the inside.

I was over nationalism at age 15.

Great!!! I like the way you think.

1

Anything that splits people into "Us" and "Them" is dangerous because human nature works on the basis that it is OK to treat "Them" in ways that it is totally unacceptable to treat "Us". The measure of a persons morality is how small "Us" is. If everybody is "Us" then you can't feel morally justified in treating people other than as you would be treated yourself. Doesn't mean you won't do it but at least you will be aware that it is pragmatism not the natural order.

Kimba Level 7 Jan 3, 2018

Great. Thanks for the reply

1

Yes it is.

Thank you for the reply

I served this country for 9 years and I don’t buy into the propaganda. I got out when my National Guard drills started feeling like KKK meetings.

1

I think it's just as dangerous if not more dangerous. The world is becoming smaller in a sense.im disgusted with Trump and his America first blather. I always felt the u.s. thinks it's number one and the greatest country in world, but Its far far from it. We can learn much from other countries. In trumps America, we have to lower and bully all others to give trumsters the feeling of superiority they so desperately seek.

3

yes. when I think of nationalism I think of what herr trump is trying to do to the US now. MAGA is like America is the center of the world-no other countries matter anymore-alliance? what's that? His ignorance on international affairs is astounding. Nationalism is trying to make us a white christian country by reinventing immigration laws, visa bans on Muslim countries and building an assanine wall. No nationalism is more dangerous. trump is a piece of shit.

Thanks for the reply.

I cannot like this enough!

2

Yes, it is dangerous because religions and gods are always used in the so called 'nationalism' movements as are racism, sexism and other forms of prejudice.

Exactly. Thank you for your reply.

1

Yes it can be . There are ppl out there who top the scales and can be overboard with belonging to where they were born. Then again there are some who have a right to protect their cultural land of over zealous individuals who think they have a right to destroy or change their environment they are not taking into consideration any cultural values of the ppl of the land. Which really boils down to lack of respect and internal gain.

Thank you for your opinion. Everyone is entitled to their opinion. I am coming from a place where there is a different culture every 100 kms. I wonder if everyone start protecting their cultural land where will our country be. Samuel Johnson said Patriotism is the last refuge of the scoundrel. Your views on that please.

Regardless of how close or far each culture is. Respect of that culture must be held. If everyone was the same the world would have no appeal
only materialism. If you go into territory that is not yours and disrespect their way. Why are you there? What right does a stranger, foreigner have to tell locals how to act behave if they have been living the way they have for decades. Why shouldn't they be able to defend their homeland or cultural beliefs. Ppl can live together if they enter with no hidden agenda.

1

Aggressive nationalism is a scourge of mankind. But, nationalism, in the sense of people identifying with the principles and processes of a nation, can be healthy. This form of nationalism breaks the bonds of tribalism and lessensethnic hatreds.

Thank you for your reply.

1

A concept that can be used constructively and destructively. Can be used to unfairly discriminate against people and more. Therefore a dangerous construct which interestingly can be made seemingly benign through cognitive ease.

Thanks for the reply.

1

I’d say it’s often sparked by ‘religion and god (beliefs).’ Yes, quite dangerous. It’s not that nations shouldn’t have borders, or pride in their achievements, but when they begin walling themselves off from the world, either physically or metaphorically, they create an ‘us against them’ mentality that never ends well… It’s often the rallying cry of a deranged despot ... Gee, any come to mind..?

Varn Level 8 Jan 2, 2018

Thank you for the comment. Can't agree any less.

1

even if in my heart there is only one... In my brain there are two nationalities. I have learned to carry them equal with all pride and pain that may be. I don't wish pain or harm to any. If I have to decide I will make a decision then... the man is his and his circumstances.

True. Thanks for your reply

4

Couple religion and nationalism together, and you get a cocktail ten-times more potent than each individually.

Great. Thank you for the reply.

5

humans are dangerous

No doubt on that. Thanks for the reply.

your welcome

4

My definition of nationalism maps almost directly to selfishness and bigotry/racism follow closely. So yes, I think it is even more dangerous than religion and god.

Absolutely. Thank you for your reply.

2

Yes.

Thank you for the reply.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:12245
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.