Agnostic.com

22 4

Do you think this quote is accurate..??

vmedel 6 July 12
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

22 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

4

All I can say is that I personally love smart women. I grew up in family of them, married one, and my daughter is one.

3

Not really. I tend to think all people pay more attention to wealth and status. Intelligence is somewhere down the list.

Definitely not all people!

@girlwithsmiles I agree. I wish intelligence was more valuable, but that might undermine myself. πŸ™‚

2

I have seen this go both ways, in all honesty.

2

I don't think a man has or ever will turn down a beautiful woman only because she wasn't smart enough ?

Speak for yourself buddy. If she can't hold a conversation it's a no go!

@chris26plus If only I was smart enough to find the super duper like button here...

2

Mot completely accurate.

2

Only a dumb man who thinks he is smart.

2

I'll pretty much believe anything she tells me

1

I think it's an incomplete premise. Some people are intimidated by intelligence, I honestly believe that some men find it unbearable to even think that women even have the ability to be as intelligent as they are... It permeates much of society mostly do to ancient ideas and outdated religions/dogma patriarchal attitudes etc.
I'd like to think that intelligent people seek out other intelligent people in order to be challenged and to have intelligent conversation... If you can't have an intelligent discussion about a topic, you should either want to be more educated about the topic, or you're not interested/unwilling to change your opinion on it... No-one is so smart that they can't benefit from more information.

1

I love Natalie Portman! Not sure about the quote. Probably. There are a lot of smart people that don't want to be proven wrong so I they like hanging with people that are less smarty than them. Not sure about the gender bias part. Ok, I don't know enough about the topic so I'll just stop rambling.

JeffB Level 6 July 12, 2018
1

I think it's true.

1

I think there are definitely men who are intimidated by smart women. I generally refer to them as boys.

ejbman Level 7 July 12, 2018

aka misunderstood machismo

@DUCHESSA How do you mean?

@ejbman WHAT do I mean? Some men think "machismo" is to be tough, know-it-all, to be always right...and they can't handle when another person -specially a woman- reigns over them.

@DUCHESSA Ah yes. Agreed.

1

not accurate because of the Dunning–Kruger effect.

Lukian Level 8 July 12, 2018

When both parties are intelligent the above effect is irrelevant; it's main point is about an illusory effect in those less skilled in perspective to those more skilled. If both people are of the same level this effect is irrelevant I would have thought? They equally consider those less skilled to be at their level.

@girlwithsmiles valid but assuming the D-K effect is predominant in men. The statement implies smart men don't like smart women as much. If you apply the effect on the man he will think he's smarter than the woman even if they are equal.

@Lukian why would I presume it's predominant in men?

@girlwithsmiles you don't but it works the other way around as well. What I'm saying is to self evaluate our intelligence is a D-K trap. So the statement above is really hard to assess. I know I went far off left field but the OPs question is not a simple Y-N answer.

@Lukian Now this is the kind of fun debate smart people have. Why would any of us discount that opportunity is beyond me. I need to get some popcorn for this one.

@Sucellus too late, I can't go much further with this. I'm also not claiming intellect superiority. I was just going to hard rationally rather then gut feeling...

@Lukian I stand by my previous statement. As the D-K effect has no gender bias it is not applicable to this statement. This statement has a gender bias that may or may not be true, but as the D-K effect seems to affect both genders equally it is not relevant to Ms. Portman's alleged statement πŸ˜‰

@girlwithsmiles noted. I get your point. It’s probably true.

1

Not strictly accurate, no. How could it be. I'd take it as her opinion based on her life experience.

1

I'd say not across the board, but there is probably some truth to it..........

0

Yeah. I’m not sure if that’s a good or bad thing though.

0

Yes. In our society I think that is possible. I know a lot of men that have hangups about being in-charge and the leader in everything. I say bring on the intellect, I like a fun debate.

0

All to often

0

I don’t think it is accurate.

0

Yessssssss

0

Yes, sadly...

0

I don't know but what I will say is that you never find many girls that hold intelligent conversations at the club,bar, or party. Not saying that it couldn't happen. People today are first attracted to a person's looks more often than their intellect. I'm personally not very smart but I love an intelligent woman. She can teach me everything she knows.

0

How will I know? I am a Man.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:129226
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.