Agnostic.com

23 4

If many Christians believe in transubstantiation, (wine & cracker transform into body & blood of Christ) does that mean they approve of cannibalism? If not, why not?

kozmic 6 July 20

Post a comment Reply Add Photo

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

23 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

Yes. They do.

1

To a certain definition of ritual cannibalism yes.

But you can only eat and drink Jesus.

Anybody else is idol worship, I guess.

Jesus is the flavor of the millenium!

3

I sometimes tell Christians that they are in a cannibalistic death cult. I then explain it to them.

For some reason they are never very happy with me.

1

don't fall for Christianity....the hors d'oeuvres suck....

0

If I'm not mistaken, this was one of the main reasons why the Romans were so disapproving of Christianity. They literally thought that the early Christians were eat the flesh of other human beings and the Romans found that repulsive.

1

How many of those crackers do you need to eat to consume an entire jesus?

GwenC Level 7 July 20, 2018

Brilliant! Love it. You're the best GWEN🙂🙂

0

Certain christian denominations believe in transubstantiation, other vehemently reject that belief & see communuion as a ritual remembrance. There are those who believe in free will & others who believe predestination. 1 blanket cannot cover all the crazy.

1

You have just made me ask myself quite a few questions.... I grew up Mormon an would raid the sacrament cabinet full of crumbled Wunderbread and water after service with friends because we were starving. Sorry everyone! I ate your idol!

I did that too! My friend and I's logic = its still in the bag, hasnt been blessed or cut up yet... So its ok.

@Seph
Yep! We were told that it was still sacred... At least I wasn't going to hell hungry.

0

In cultuarl anthro they called ritual canibalism

1

You should sign up at a christian site and ask that question. It could be the most fun you have that day.

0

IMO, transubstantiation makes the belief in god seem tame. Got to go with Hermann Hesse-just an insanity.

0

Put a little grape jelly on Jesus and he's pretty tasty. Goes well with the grape juice, and both are full antioxidants. Eating and drinking a little Jesus daily could be healthy.

0

When I was a child and my grandparents would take me to church in hopes that I'd actually pay attention and believe, they had all the children go up and "drink the blood of Christ and eat his flesh". For us, they used grape juice. I ate and drank mine, but the kid next in line was scared. Being that I wasn't really able to control the volume of my voice as a kid, I said very loudly "don't worry, it's only grape juice" and half the church laughed and the other half wasn't pleased. It was great cause they asked my grandparents to leave me at home if possible from then on.

1

Come on, now!!
You're expecting logic from those people?
LOLOLOLOL

0

I've always thought that if anybody thinks wine and crackers turn into blood and flesh they're smoking some serious shit!

ipdg77 Level 8 July 20, 2018
0

It still tastes just like matzo and cheap wine even after the "transubstantiation" occurs so if it does change it changes but not really. the church denies that it's cannibalism. When you ask how can it not be cannibalism if transubstantiation is real the answer is the usual answer that you get for such questions. It's a "mystery of faith."

1

What a cop out! If they wanted to keep things real they should just demand a human sacrifice at the end of service to make sure they're all really committed to their religion. Jk... All that is just a weird remnant from the old pagan religions that Christianity plegiarized. I find it weird that none of the followers have questioned that particular ritual.

1

It's an atypical (for Catholics) literal reading of Bible verses describing the sacrament of the Lord's Supper. Sure, technically that makes it cannibalism, but Catholics no more think of it in those terms than evangelicals find being "washed in the blood" of Jesus to be ghastly. They are so used to the notion that it doesn't bother them.

I concur with that that is what many of them think. However, it is still actually cannibalism and they are again having that compartmentalization and cognitive dissonance brain activities going on.

0

When I took communion I’m pretty sure it was a metaphor, but I don’t really know what was in the cracker?

0

They do not understand that they are cannibals. And they would deny they are.

And because someone made up a story about a dude named jesus said he wanted us all to eat of his flesh. TheY do not understand what any of that really means.

Jacar Level 8 July 20, 2018
0

Well, let's face it, ya'll, if you can believe that God turned up in the Bronze Age, impregnated himself into woman, got himself born, was illiterate, worked as a labourer, performed miracles, was happy to be tortured and then killed, and then came back from the dead, then, quite frankly, you'll have no problem believing he's happy to be eaten and drunk by those who consider him as their saviour. Simple really.

0

This very question helped greatly to my becoming persona non gratis, in parochial school. A fine day in my life. It seemed to me no matter how they chopped him up it was unpalatable.

0

What’s the reasoning either way? Why are we eating a guy and drinking his blood? Why? I read the Bible, I don’t remember that one 🙂

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:135620
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.