Agnostic.com

38 3

So fellow unbelievers...what do you think about Astrology? Also a load of nonsense?

antman 7 July 22
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

38 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

I think so but a large portion of important women in my life have been Scorpios...

antman Level 7 July 22, 2018

Just coincidence.

@JohnDublin I was just realizing I don’t know. Will have to ask.

@JohnDublin, @Quazi my mom, my wife, and most of my girlfriends....all scorpios...

1

Yes, I believe it to be just nonsense.

1

Ranks right up there with chicken guts and tea leaves.

1

same I think of insect men.

1

My neighbor informed me three years ago that I am a Scorpio. She's weirdly involved with astrology. I was curious about what that meant and read stuff online to find out. My conclusion: meh.

0

Yeah, but it's fun.

1

Not a fan or a believer. If haven't before, check out Numerology or the Jewish Cabala.

t1nick Level 8 July 22, 2018
2

Yes nonsense. Hocus pocus just like horoscopes

Well, it IS horoscopes. They mean the same thing.

1

I have never followed astrology. I don't even know all of the signs of all of my kids.

Lol me too

2

Nonsense. In fact the signs used are based on configuration of the universe 2000+ years ago and have shifted so if you were born in what is called the Gemini sign you were actually born in the Cancer sign. I think I am correct in the shift direction haven't done much research on it.

This is correct, due to precession. The Earth remains tilted to the plain of the solar system the same amount, but actually spins around like wobbling top over time. In the future, the North Start will no longer be the North Star, replaced by whatever star the north pole points to at a given era, if any. I may have the number wrong, but I believe it takes 26,000 year to complete a wobble. So yes, the original constellations backing the Zodiac are all out of sync.

@godef Thank you for the replies. My knowledge has been increased and I like that.

2

Have you ever answered questions about what your thought of this or that? And then told you are this type of person. It is found in some businesses and governments. It is an attempt by management to determine the best mix of people. It can be harmless or devastating. I call this 'pigeon-holing'; and attempt to put round pegs in square holes. Most of the time it will fit, but it never fits everyone. Astrological traits are a similar attempt to attribute qualities to people. Modern astrology is wrong anyway -- it uses fixed dates, rather than the actual constellations and there are 13, not 12 signs.

xyz123 Level 7 July 22, 2018
1

Have you ever answered questions about what your thought of this or that? And then told you are this type of person. It is found in some businesses and governments. It is an attempt by management to determine the best mix of people. It can be harmless or devastating. I call this 'pigeon-holing'; and attempt to put round pegs in square holes. Most of the time it will fit, but it never fits everyone. Astrological traits are a similar attempt to attribute qualities to people. Modern astrology is wrong anyway -- it uses fixed dates, rather than the actual constellations and there are 13, not 12 signs. It has as much value as one wishes to place in it -- though I think flipping a coin is more reasonable.

xyz123 Level 7 July 22, 2018
3

unadulterated bollox along with tarot readings tea leaves and crystals to name but a few

weeman Level 7 July 22, 2018
2

Yes along with alchemy, creationism, hydroplate. Etc.

1

I believe it is a crock of bovine excrement.

0

Yup, absolutely.

godef Level 7 July 22, 2018
1

As an amateur astronomer, knowing the signs of the zodiac, as they pertain to the constellations and the precession of the equinoxes is clearly important, but that is all I pay attention to. Believers in astrology are not too different from religious adherents, or those who believe in fortune telling, healing magnets, conspiracy theories, homeopathic treatments, anti-vaxers and anti-GMO'ers.

1

Yes, nasty nonsense.

However, taking a clean sheet of paper approach, I could entertain the notion that there might be some trends or patterns as to the time of year that you are born and some personal traits. It could be anything from when a person's parents chose to conceive (eg: after a nice Christmas bonus) to whether you had to begin the school year as young or old for your grade, etc. So, this doesn't yield anything as satisfying and granular as "you will have thus-and-such experience today", but it would be interesting to see some reputable study on this.

kmaz Level 7 July 22, 2018
1

If you’re asking about the science, the science is in. There is not a single shred of evidence that human lives are affected or directed by the movement of the stars and constellations. When measured the possibility that they could have any influece at all is laughable. The distances are literally astronomical.

Humans see our environment in patterns. It is one of the things we are best at. We can see pictures and patterns in the pure random static of a TV screen. Structured semi random behaviors like Astrology, Tarot, and I Ching can help us put those random/patterns together and make sense of them. They are useful on the same way the Rorschach Test and the Meyers-Briggs test are useful. But the magic doesn’t come from the stars or the cards or the test. The magic comes from inside. The magic comes from us.

JTony Level 3 July 22, 2018

@KissedbySun I’d still say that there is no evidence that the sun’s position in the sky at the time of birth has any affect or relation to one’s personality or future events. There’s not a lick of evidence that shows that it or any other celestial body is in any way a source for predicting or determining who we are or will become.

@KissedbySun well that I can wholeheartedly agree with. The sun and stars are the source of all things after all. Btw, I really like your name!

2

Load of bollocks.

3

I don't believe in it but we Virgos tend to be skeptical.

This made me laugh!!

@antman Me, too!

1

Yes it is BS.

3

It's entertaining. I am a sensitive Pisces and I do like the water. But sometimes their readings are a little fishy. It;s like I'm running around in an XFiles T-Shirt saying, "I want to believe."

1

Sure! It is so obviously true that the planets all line up in a certain way so that they can tell me how to live my life because of my birthday. ?

1

More nonsense. The planets line up differently from every point of view which is infinite, so which line up is correct, plus the planets rotate and move in orbits, so the positions are always changing.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:137097
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.