Agnostic.com

14 1

Does anyone know why so many evangelicals don't consider Roman Catholics to be Christians?

kozmic 6 Sep 6
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

14 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

Because catholic’s rape children

0

Every church group considers itself to be the true believers. This means there are hundreds of thousands distinct religions on the planet.

1

Because they have sold their minds and integrity to blind devotion to a specific religious dogma which they see as the one and only truth. They are"true believers", not normal thinking and caring people.

1

They are bigots. That's why. Next?

0

Cause it's not their particular brand. ?

0

It goes with the idea ofv only one religion being the "ture" one. I fyou don't belong to theri church then you aren't truly a christian....

1

Different bible, the pope, the holy trinity and much of the dogma associated with Catholicism.
I mean historically, in the bible, Catholics are the only christians that existed at that time. I mean until the 1500's there were really no other clearly organized christian branches to follow but in 1517 Martin Luther's "95 Theses" challenged Catholic dogma. Of course Henry VIII was the first king to defy the catholic church and start his own...probably as much a money/income thing as a divorce thing imo.

Anyway that is partly why christianity is so dubious for me...I mean there is a clear evolution that if you look closely is simply just a further division of wealth. How do you solve a crime...follow the money. How do you explain modern civilization/humanity...follow the money. It is no wonder in a capitalist society the US is responsible for so many versions of the christian religion. 'Merica.

0

I know some Catholics who don't consider themselves christians. The worship of idols, the belief that the Pope is the word of god, wine & crackers being the blood & flesh of christ (yech) blah blah blah

1

Most non-catholics, not just evangelicals, consider the Catholic church being filled with side altars where you can pray to saints, to be "worshipping false idols". Not a recent thing, one of Martin Luther's peeves, in fact.

1

I can't answer the question, but it's so fucked up.

In the beginning there's no Bible just a collection of parables. Then someone puts a selection of these parables together in one place. People start to live by the teachings of this compendium . The compendium is destroyed. A bunch of Roman Catholics re-write the parables supposedly from memory, but form them into a book and say it's the word of God. Now the people that wrote the book that everyone is worshipping aren't Christians.

My head aches and I need a hit...

3

I dabbled with the JWs in my youth and from what I remember it goes like this.
Catholics are idolaters saints and virgin Marys abound. Revelations talks of the whore of Babylon sitting on 7 hills (a reference to Rome). "Tho shalt have no other god than me" Yet the pope is supreme pontiff on earth etc.

My Pentecostal background confirms this as the consistent refrain from that area of the schism.

1

Just like all other religions. Eventually they break into sects. I once saw a show about interviewing Pakistanis on a train. One guy smugly said, if everyone were Moslem there would be no violence. Thing some of the most violent places are between Sunni's and Shiite Moslems. Remember Romney (Rummy)? Evangelicals didn't vote for him because he was a Mormon (now even they are dropping that name). Nature of the beast.

2

I grew up hearing that protestants didn't believe catholics were christians. Guess they think they're the only ones. Another thing they're wrong about. Heheh.

2

Because they don't throw enough hellfire and brimstone into the lies.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:172609
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.