Should prostitution be legal?
Sure it should be legal. What bussiness is it of the government’s about what goes on between 2 consenting adults. During the golden age of the Roman Empire there were 40 brothels in Pompei, Italy a town of about 7,000. Here where I live the nearest town is about that size. When I was young there were 2 brothels and 17 bars there. Now there are no brothels and 1 bar but about 25 churches. I think I like Pompei a lot better.
The brothels in Pompei and all of the Roman Empire were manned by slaves, I say manned because male and female prostitutes were on offer in often squalid conditions. Even today prostitution often involves sex slavery, not always but often there is coercion involved in the sex trade so this is not something to advocate for no matter how laissez faire your political views.
@Surfpirate Yes I’m aware of that. During those days it was common to enslave the conquered. I’m not advocating slavery but I have a problem with the government arresting 2 consenting adults.
@Trajan61 Consenting and not coerced, if you know much about the sex trade then you know that a lot of the sex workers are in fact coerced, either to work off a debt for illegal immigrants or for people who become property of organized crime. Brothels like the Mustang Ranch or the Dovetail are the exception and not the rule, both are licensed by the government which helps to keep them the exception.
@Surfpirate If prostitution was legal we wouldn’t have the problem with being coerced would we? That’s what I’m advocating. So what’s your point?
@Trajan61 My point is that you are willfully naive to believe that the world's oldest profession is generally entered into of a person's own free will. Even in those few areas of the world where it is legal it tends to prey upon the disadvantaged and the vulnerable.
What colour is the sky in your world any way?
I think so. Sometimes it is the only way for people to survive.
For both parties. One has a physical need, another has a monitairy need.
Excellent point. We have to free ourselves from the restrictive Christian morality that has burdened society. @TheGreatShadow
@nicknotes Yes, and if it was legal all over, you'd go to a place like the Bunny Ranch that has security. Prostitutes CAN be raped. I'm not talking about paying the bill. I'm saying that there are certian things people just won't do. Also it would cut down on CTD's. I've heard that if you go to one of these establishents, you have to have an STD check. Also you wouldn't have to worry about the prostitute skiking your drink, stealing your money, and end up with a missing kidney. Also street pimps treat their hoes like shit.
Yes. A well regulated system would 1) help protect those who choose to participate and drastically reduce sex trafficking 2) reduce the prevalence of STD's.
And of course 3) piss off hypocritical evangelicals.
Totally agree....
Looking at Trump it seems to inspire Evangelicals.
Some European countries have legal prostitution. The woman are regularly tested for sexually transmitted diseases. If a woman doesn't mind it and a guys willing to pay, it should be legal
The same with parts of Asia (not usually as well done as Europe) However, Thailand received an UN recognition for keeping AIDS under control, in large part to the testing of prostitutes. Thailand is far from perfect, as it is still a favored haunt of pedophiles.
Yes. It could be regulated for safety. it would allow women to report abuse. The underground violence related to this area of the sex industry would mostly disappear... goodbye pimps. And for women who enjoy sex and would like to make a living from it have that option. And for some women who have no other way of making money... they have another option if they would choose it.
There would be requirements like regular testing, being of age, licensing, and emergency hotline to report abuse or suspicious activity. The government could tax it. And for some people who may never get to experience sex (such as handicapped of some sort) this could give them the opportunity to experience one of the most basic, natural, fundamental enjoyable human experiences that make us human.
No women would be forced into prostitution, no one would walk the streets (they could be required to work at a brothel), no one would be underage. Sex trafficking would barely exist. Those who force women to break these rules would be prosecuted to the highest extent. Johns (and Janes) who go to a street prostitute would be prosecuted as well. People would choose legal brothels because they're legal, safe, and clean.
Could you imagine the union? What if they had a strike...We want a pay raise or no one gets laid!
Chi-Raq in real time!
Yes, Would be a lot safer for workers and their john's.
I am a believer that what consenting adults do is their business and not anybody else’s.
That being said prostitution should have some regulation to protect the sex worker.
George Carlin made the most logical argument for legalizing prostitution anyone could make when he asked: "How can it be illegal to sell something that's perfectly legal to give away for free!?"
God, I miss him.
In Japan, in the early sixties, I was told the concept was that favors were being exchanged. Not a question of legality...I really have a hard time finding fault .
Maybe. A straight yes is far too simplistic.
First and foremost the safety and mental and physical health should be the first priority for any sex workers.
I am also not sure that the provision of sexual services should be done through brothels. Given that greed appears to be an intrinsic part of human nature, trusting the health of workers to pimps is probably not the best idea. There will always those that are prepared to exploit to provide "extras" and "special" services.
I have no problems with prostitution per se, but do have problems with pimps.
Regulation and unions can only protect so far, but I do agree that it should not be illegal to charge for sexual services and sex workers should be protected by the law and not criminlised.
yes. just like abortion and porn, women need to have control over their own bodies. prostitution should be safely regulated the way pornography is.
I think it should be legal and regulated. I think the workers should be required to get regular health check ups, and their earnings should be taxed.
Our senators and congressmen get away with it. They're just glorified whores.