Agnostic.com

9 1

Does anyone else feel pressure on this point?
Without a soul, you have no moral compass. What stops you from doing bad things and do good things? God has the monopoly on morality with your soul.
With only faith sacrifice all there is to ever know, for something awkward to fully know. It’s okay to say I don't know than to make excuses in faith I do know.
How do you defend your morality without a soul and not be rude?
I’m learning to bite my tongue and keep my cool when it comes to discussing morality with religion.

flower_nut 7 Oct 25
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

9 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

A few years ago I wrote a "Rebuttal to Pilgrim's Progress," and one of the characters explains why religious people (in this case citizens of the City of Dogma) hate humanity:

"In the City of Dogma, being human is a crime. To that end, you are expected to abandon your humanity to their God, thus circumventing any charges of humanness. This is why citizens of the city can do such egregious acts to others and never be called to account for their bad behavior. They proclaim that their humanness led them to do it, but that their God has forgiven that humanness and they are no longer responsible for any actions done because of it. You, however, have left the city, and subsequently chosen to embrace your humanity—and to take responsibility for it. In their eyes, you have fully embraced this crime; and because you have left of your own accord, you are also considered a traitor."
~ The Rebuttal to Pilgrim's Progress

Later, another character says:

"What makes humanness so meaningful is that you can consciously seek to evolve into a human who values this humanness—and, consequently, the humanness of others. In the City of Dogma, you are taught to condemn this perfection and mistrust your humanity and conform to a very peculiar series of "un-human" dictates. Sin and evil are religious constructs—completely made up by the religion that defines them. They want you to believe you’re not perfect, but that cannot be true for this reason: you are a human being. As human, you can only express yourself perfectly—as HUMAN. Nobody else in the Universe can be you. You can rise to the pinnacle of humanness, or you can sink the lowness of humanness… either way, you’re still a human “being”.

Thank you for that. Being responsible for my own actions is very important. Hard to consider myself as a traitor when it feels so right. I love your words and cannot thank you enough.

1

I used to try to use the more 'educated' knowledge that 'morality' is built in, and then gets upgraded as we become more aware of our humanness. But that doesn't work because it involves actual cognizance, and they're not into that.

So now I just say, The most moral thing I can do as a human being is find a way to teach Christians about Jesus and encourage them to one-day embrace his teachings.

That's very interesting. I'm new and eager to understand how powerful faith can be. “Is faith a reliable path to truth?” from the Atheist Experience, Matt Dillahunty. This phrase changed my life. Simple words for my simple mind. Maybe they can help others, if not, your approach is the next phase.

2

I've always said if you need someone to tell you that murdering and rape and stealing is wrong, maybe you have some issues.

Remi Level 7 Oct 25, 2018

I never thought about that concept until a Christian mentioned it. It stuns me that people use God as the reason to not hurt someone.

2

Since when does god come into this equation. No one needs god for morality, I have a deep personal soul and that is to love nature and humanity. I did this without the big idiot in the sky who apparently can be quite vicious. No, I like my morality over gods and we should all try to teach this so called god, how to act like a god and not some stupid ass judgemental moron.

EMC2 Level 8 Oct 25, 2018

I went down that road and my ego came into question from others. I guess in your context I do have a soul. It's my unique individuality of who I am. Thank you.

@flower_nut yes you do have a soul my friend, We are all atoms that share the big bang in effect. You were never without , born with the ability to go deep within and discover what you are. Enjoy the journey with no guilt

3

Ask them one question: If you knew a man was molesting a child, would you do something about it?

When they say yes; tell them, "Congratulations, you are more moral than the god you worship."

JimG Level 8 Oct 25, 2018

So simple and yet confusing for believers to understand. I like it, Thank you.

6

Does God count as moral? My moral standards were always higher than Gods even when I was religious. I thought the Bible was full of horrible stories.

Myah Level 6 Oct 25, 2018

100% TRUE.

I was more like a coward when it came to God and simply ignored it. Didn't read the bible, but I tried. While defending my position I'm up against others who try to save me or condemn me. According to the bible, I think God is immoral and it's easy for me to understand this, but difficult to convey. People don't understand morality is built in, aren't we proof?
Thank you.

3

My first thought is to question what a "soul" is, then if you can get past that point, then the meaning of morality. Empathy, logic and reason are a good starting point to explain secular morality. Religion does not have the "high ground" on morality, they just think they do. Sam Harris does some good work in this area.

The last step for me is defining my soul. I attribute a “God-loving soul” to the supernatural and not a person's character. I do have a soul it just doesn't include the supernatural. I've seen a bit of Sam Harris and will continue. Thank you.

3

i have had people attack me on this issue. i refuse to bite my tongue. i feel no pressure at all. if i am a good person, and i hope i am, it is because i believe in being a good person. fictional characters from ancient texts have nothing to do with it.

g

I'm still new at this and gaining courage. I hope to get to the point you're at eventually. Thank you.

2

I've had this problem before, and there are a couple ways I've dealt with it. My favorite way to describe how we derive our morality is to bring up our evolutionary tribe mentality. Aron Ra speaks about this pretty well in one of his talks. If you wanted to refute the point of God gives us morality, see what God really says in whatever religion they cite, and contrast that to what they say. Sometimes, it's just easier to stay quiet, however, so I do understand that pressure.

Radon Level 2 Oct 25, 2018

It's frustrating when someone gives you the impression you can't love. This hurts and gives me the creeps. The Bible tells us to love God first and everybody else second. Is there any self-love for me? I was quiet all my life and now I'm learning to deal with it in my own way. Thank you.

@flower_nut I get that, and I hear that kind of rhetoric often, or rather, I don't hear anything from them about my ability to self love. It is frustrating to hear, but in the end, they don't determine my self esteem. Glad to hear you're dealing with it, however you choose.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:208266
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.