Agnostic.com

5 0

Deconstructing SIN.

There are a more than a few words in our common vocabulary that need careful examination and critique. We have been taught their meaning, accepted their jargon and used them without thinking. But as intelligent, responsible, free-thinkers, this is not the way to conduct business.

Technically, many of the words handed down to us by religious authorities are in reality totally meaningless. Take the word “SIN” for example.

The Collins COBUILD Dictionary for instance, defines the primary usuage of the word as:

    1. variable noun
      Sin or a sin is an action or type of behaviour which is believed to break the laws of God.
      The Vatican's teaching on abortion is clear: it is a sin.
      Was it the sin of pride to have believed too much in themselves?

Though precise, the definition is a little obfuscating, though perhaps on the part of the lexicographer not deliberately so.

The concept of “God’s Law” is not enough in itself to carry the word's portent, to have enough weight it requires the additional concept of God’s Absolute Moral Integrity and Virtue. Right has to be RIGHT!

Theodicy, a term coined by Leibnitz but a problem recognised as early as Tertullian, is that the GOODNESS of God has to be assumed, it cannot be demonstrated or proven. In fact all the evidence we have would argue against the wishful thinking of your neighbourly theist.

So what does this mean? When demythologised the concept of “SIN” dissolves in the wash before our eyes. As humans, imperfect we most certainly are, and we may well often err against our better judgment, and as a result deeply regret many of our actions. But this does not make us sinners, or make us wrecks in need saving….

rcandlish 7 Dec 5
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

5 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

There’s no such thing as sin. Sin is a superficial human concept with no real meaning. Even our president gets it:

Trump said he was "not sure" whether he ever asked God for forgiveness, stating "If I do something wrong, I just try and make it right. I don't bring God into that picture." (Wikipedia)

1

This comes from a book I like:

Apollo: What makes humanness so meaningful is that you can consciously seek to evolve into a human who values this humanness—and, consequently, the humanness of others. In the City of Dogma, you are taught to condemn this perfection and mistrust your humanity and conform to a very peculiar series of "un-human" dictates. Sin and evil are religious constructs—completely made up by the religion that defines them. They want you to believe you’re not perfect, but that cannot be true for this reason: you are a human being. As human, you can only express yourself perfectly—as HUMAN. Nobody else in the Universe can be you. You can rise to the pinnacle of humanness, or you can sink the lowness of humanness… either way, you’re still a human “being”.
~ Pilgrim's Progression: The Rebuttal to Pilgrim's Progress

0

There are definitely some fairly universal laws that any dereliction from could be said to be rather dreadful, like killing people, raping, harming the vulnerable, children or defenseless animals. I think sin is the very human idea that they will get their comeupance in the next life. Reality is that many trully despicable creatures do very well out of their 'sin'.

2

I don't believe in sin. Just like I don't believe in gods.

1

Paul defined "sin" as "missing the mark" when he compared it to archery practice when you are shooting an arrow at the bullseye of the target. I assume the bullseye is "the mark" that you are shooting for. I won't get into this any more than that because I'm not teaching Sunday School.

Who set the mark? And by what authority does it become the mark?

@rcandlish I think you missed the whole thing. "The mark" is wording that came out of Greek language for what we would call a bullseye. Paul used the example of target practice and how the goal is to hit that bullseye. Sometimes, try as we may, that does not happen. "Sin" is missing the mark. It has nothing to do with abortion, drinking, smoking, or any individual thing a person might do. To sin is to not follow god's law even though we might be trying to. Like the bullseye we are trying to hit, we just keep trying.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:237600
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.