Agnostic.com

13 1

What's your take on Deja Vu? Have you experienced it? How do you explain the strange occurance? I have my own interesting theories on the subject.

sophiesmomrocks 3 Aug 22
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

13 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

Memory is complex,and with electrical impulses- i am suprised more DOESN'T occur. I have experienced it
and felt its akin to not getting ALL the info because it
seems incomplete. The brain has like a filing system,
as in i think of ice cream-it has a file and that file is connected in various ways. Our memory(of ice cream)has to be updated and yet availible for access. There are triggers that will go to the file OR the whole cabinet ,
this is where i think the issue happens.
Thanks

2

Our mental "continuity" is really just an illusion. The brain develops a narrative that it feels best incorporates all of the sense clues at its' immediate disposal - and it looks for changes from moment to moment to narrate the passage of linear time. But, as others have pointed out here, sometimes that glitches. generally the brain draws from prior memories to develop its' narrative by comparing sense to sense and noting differences. deja vu happens when it calls on the last memory to develop the narrative - which it usually doesn't seem to do. we tend to search for historical patterns of the past vice immediate past. not sure why.

Check out Norman Doidge's canonical work "The Brain that Changes" and pay particular attention to the split brain studies. After the corpus callosum is split between the right and left hemispheres they are left to develop these narratives on their own based on the limited sensory information each has available to it. There is an amazing example that illustrates this effect. When the left side is told to perform an action without knowledge by the right and the right is asked to explain it will make up the most amazing story to include all the sensory input available to it and memories. This is the type of glitch where deva vu occurs.

Well put ,thanks for the refrences.

0

From the Oracle of Delphi to modern game theories we have had nothing but futile attempts to predict the future or evolve a winning strategy.

1

I have experienced it. If it happened all the time, I would go see a neurologist. [sciencedaily.com]

0

I get deja vu feelings all the time, but so far it has never helped me predict the future or avoid danger or bad decisions, unfortunately.
So I really think it's just our mind glitching so that we feel like we are remembering something but really aren't.

0

yep, it's deja vu all over again.

1

Whenever I would get the feeling that I experienced something before I always thought that it was my brain misfiring. I logically knew I wasn't experiencing the same thing again. This is not the same as something feeling familiar. In that case I figure I was being reminded of something.

0

With a lousy sense of direction, I get that feeling often while hiking and driving.

"This trail junction looks familiar," I say.

"Yes, Kathleen, we have been here dozens of times. We passed it this morning."

It's maddening.

1

It’s a vague feeling of familiarity … nothing cosmic. It’s always given me a buzz though. Anymore, I’ve the time to consider ‘why,’ and generally figure it out ~

Varn Level 8 Aug 22, 2019
0

I think we have probably all experienced the feeling of deja vu at some time or another. I have no real knowledge of why it occurs, but understand that there are a lot of things beyond my comprehension and this is probably one of them. The brain is like a giant computer which has stored within it memories of everything we have ever experienced. We dream at night, and although I personally can never remember them, unless I’m awakened directly from one, these dreams are recalled memories jumbled up. Perhaps deja vu is a similar type of brain activity, a response to stimulus in the present which our brains identify with an experience from our past which we mistake for a memory. In fact this could just be a jumbled up recall of some other similar experience...a brain malfunction or false memory if you like.

5

I feel like i read this post before😉

2

it's an interesting phenomenon because so many of us experience it, and because so many believe what they experience actually foretells future occurrences, but in my opinion it's also a load of rubbish because it's impossible. i'd like to hear your interesting theories about it, though.

Jnei Level 8 Aug 22, 2019

I agree. Besides, when someone experiences it, whatever they think they are reliving ends as soon as the feel it. They have no further future knowledge beyond that peculiar feeling, nor did they have any indication that they were currently moving toward that endpoint before feeling the effects. So, in a word, rubbish.

@Kafirah I've experienced it many times myself, though far less often now than when I was younger. That exactly describes it, and also explains why I think it's rubbish.

...i agree -i think it is a trick of memory as it
reconstructs our memory base( or updates our "current data" ) , they know these are linked as chemical connections,
some stronger than others.

5

We talked a bit about it in my neurophysiology lecture. There is an area of the brain responsible for the feeling of familiarity. Deja vu can actually be triggered through trans cranial magnetic stimulation.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:392440
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.