Agnostic.com

6 4

"This is how it is with the universe. We are the Y of which the constants of nature are the X. We exist because the constants are as they are; had they been different, we would not exist. The fact that we exist as a result of what happens to be the universe’s character entails nothing about purpose or design. It is just, depending upon your point of view, a lucky or unlucky outcome of how things happen in fact to be. The universe’s parameters and laws are not fine-tuned on purpose for us to exist. Matters are the other way round: we exist because the laws happen to be as they are".

(A.C. Grayling)

The same kind of (flawed) reasoning could be applied to every person: How many things had to happen exactly as they happened for me to be born as the individual that I am?
Does that mean that I am the "chosen one"? In this way every fly, every louse would be "chosen". Everything (every thing) is the highly improbable end point of a causal chain, but that does not mean that this thing X is the purpose of the causal chain.

Matias 8 Aug 28
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

6 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

There is not a single word, or even hint of a word, about "chosen" in that statement. Happenstance is not choice.

1

I once dealt a poker hand of four ace-high royal flushes. The players thought I was playing a trick and they made me re-deal. The second time every hand was four of a kind, all face cards. The players stalked off in disgust. I did have a reputation as a trickster but in that case both were fair deals, though as dealer I’m the only one who knows that.

Every card is unique, so the odds of any particular hand is the same as any other hand. Yet those high hands are the ones that count most and are highly desired. Statistically such an event should not have happened in the duration since the Big Bang. It is an eerie thing that used to give me shivers.

Finally though it was laid bare and neatly explained by one of my daughters: It was nothing more than the work of a mischievous ghost who happened to be on the premises. There are simple explanations for everything if only we apply logic and critical thinking.

Love your daughter!

0

The universe is way more complicated the A>B>C...X>Y>Z, In reality it isn't a line its more like a river, that is to say you can move forward but not backwards, but you can also move left-forward and right-forward, changing the stream you are in. Modern physics tells us that some events, and especially quantum events truly are random in nature and fundamentally unpredictable, with the macroscopic deterministic effects emanating from those random laws a matter of probabilities at large scale. These effects can have macroscopic effects.

For example, lets say you make a decision based on some quantum experiment. Lets say you make a list of what you want to eat, pick a random number based on that number, then ate lunch. under the many worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics there are other universes that are inaccessible to ours where the you ate something different for lunch. If you did this every day for a year, in some universes you would eat the same thing every day, but in most you would have a variety.

What this means is that you are not the "chosen one" but rather the most typical, most likely you that could exist, but tiny fluctuations could make you the most unique.

0

The Christian bible has god saying "I am that I am." Apply that individually for a moment and you see more about all of us.

2

Each one of us is the product of the 1 in 100,000,000 sperm that was lucky enough to fertilize the egg, so we are all lottery winners, otherwise we would not be here.

BD66 Level 8 Aug 28, 2019
2

I don't think anything has any inherent purpose, other than what we choose to ascribe to it.

Which opens the question what factors are at play to make us make that choice? The decision to act always precedes the action, therefore the events have been set in train before we see their operation or intervention.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:394800
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.