Agnostic.com

13 10

When will someone just be done with it and create an official Progressive party that has no ties whatsoever with the Democratic party much less the Republican party.
It's inevitable that one of these fossils will die. I was hoping it would be the Republicans but honestly right now I really don't care if they both fall apart.
What's the point of staying with a party when it refuses to represent millions of its citizens.

Novelty 8 Mar 4
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

13 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

Don't confuse being able to vote with democracy. Corporate power and the rich own both parties. If threatened, voting will end. We may see it if trumpster loses the next election.

@Novelty I hope she succeeds. Given the history of this country and the world, I am realistic and therefore not optimistic. Chomsky said the revolution would come here first, in the most advance market economy. That doesn't mean that it will lead to an outcome we like.

1

I've been crowing for a third party for a long time, but no one listens to me because I'm an older white male.

And a bit of a dick.

1of5 Level 8 Mar 4, 2020

There are lots of political parties in addition to the two we're familiar with. The trick, you will find, is to make the votes for a third party add up to 51%.

@BitFlipper no, actually, the trick is to siphon off enough votes so they have to listen/deal with you. 51% applies to electors, not the pop vote. You don't actually have to win it all to be heard - thats just the general consensus.

But a party isn't any good without members in the House/Senate to vote your will and enforce deals you make with other parties. He has people that believe in his ideals. They would turn out to vote for his candidates and for him if there were even 1 more person on the ballot they agreed with.

That's the problem I have with Bernie, he's one of the rare people who could have pulled it off but didn't. He's an ideologue that could have really altered the dynamics of our political system for the better.

Anyways, rant mode off before I look up and it's 1AM.

3rd party? Why do you think that there is more than 1? Corporations and the rich own them both, they are different flavors of the same thing.

@Mitch07102 3rd viable party.

Yes, so tell my why Bernie wants to be the dem nominee instead of create his own party free of those influences? Itd be the best thing he could do, imo.

@1of5 Educate yourself about the difficulty of doing that. The system is rigged in more ways than one.

@Mitch07102 dude, I grew up in politics. I interened in the state house of reps. I was at fundraisers when I was 8. I've campaigned, canvassed, and voted in more elections than I care to remember. My families actually help elected offices before, so I think my political education is pretty good, thankyouverymuch.

Politics isn't easy, and rigged systems can be unrigged with effort, timing, money and support. Bernie had those and blew it.

Voting Bernie as the dem nominee would change all this rigging, how, excately? Details, please.

0

I've been closely involved with the Democratic Party for decades, and I've watched it slowly corrupt. And do you know why?

All these years when I asked people to become involved, they said:
"politics is dirty"
"I'm not interested in politics"
"all I need to do is vote"
"I already have too many meetings"
"I don't donate to political candidates"
"I don't want anyone to know I'm a Democrat"
"I'm not going to walk in that part of the city.

I've stayed with it because I know which side I'm on. And now there's work to be done. There's tremendous infrastructure and generations of loyalty to the Democratic party, but too many people don't want to get their hands soiled. They would rather throw the baby out with the bathwater and start new.

The corporate world came up with a solution like that about 30 years ago. It was called Outsourcing. "We can't fix our organization, so we will Outsource it to another company." And you can see what happened with all of that.

@maturin1919 and after it's been burned to the ground, how will you put gas in your tank?

0

“Someone” is us—you, me, all of us. There is no savior. Join the Workers Party, the Democratic Socialists of America. Or any of the hundreds of other small groups dedicated to a progressive change like CELDF, Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women, The Poor People’s Campaign, Real Justice...

I donate and volunteer to Bernie’s campaign. He’s a consistent and tireless and honest man dedicated to overhauling the system. Do it!

0

. . . we buy them books, we send them to school . . .

[en.wikipedia.org]

. . . now get off my lawn 😛

2

Declaring one is silly. Make one. Pay the dues. Serve in local and state government. Become viable. Funny how this comes.up only in a presidential election year, as if you can expect to just jump in and grab the presidency, especially from the monster and his enablers. This is not a board game!

g

1

There is the Green Party, whose platform aligns perfectly with my views. Unfortuneatly they are a long way from turning out a candidate that can win any high office.

BDair Level 8 Mar 4, 2020

The green party, despite good stated goals, has no actual viability, nor should it, since its main function appears to be accepting republican money to run spoilers at state levels to divide the liberal vote. Maybe it used to be honest. Maybe it will be honest one day. It is not honest now.

g

@genessa and their Not Recognized by the E.U Greens...

I used to support the green party locally. But then I started watching them perform in debates. It was embarrassing. They only know how to speak to each other. They have no talent for persuading other people to join their cause. You can't win, no matter how good your ideas are, if you can't get people to vote for you.

@BitFlipper The reason for that is that they don't have the chops and are not interested in governance. They just want to jump from being a political organization loosely based on slogans, without doing the work first, right into the white house. Remind you of anyone?

g

4

I wish that would happen too, but right now I hope the Dem party finally blows up after they lose, again, in November, which will happen not because Bernie supporters stay home or vote Trump, but because working class voters who have given up on the Dems will stay home when they see there is no real difference for them between Biden and Trump. But we all know the centrist Dems will still end up blaming the Bernie supporters or maybe the Russians again (falsely) for their loss in the general rather than themselves.. I call bullshit on that and will not accept it when it happens from them.

I'm very disappointed to see you speaking this way. Do you really see no difference between Biden and Trump? Or are you just pissed off?

@BitFlipper Little difference. Both are very corrupt. Both lie, Biden less often than Trump, but still too often for my tastes. Biden is already mildly senile or demented, while Trump is simply nuts. I could go on, but I think you get my point... Biden might be better for foreign relations and climate change and maybe less likely to get involved in new wars. Not much for a working class person to get excited about as far as helping their day to day lives...

4

When we are young we want things NOW. That is not how it works. How long did it take for women to get the right to vote? Well over one hundred years. The gay rights movement started in the 70's. We still haven't overcome racism in our institutions even though civil rights legislation happened in the 60's. Sometimes an entire generation or more has to pass on for big changes. That is the way of a democracy which we are in danger of losing if we don't vote trump and a bunch of republican Senators out.

@Novelty I am one of those old people and I am in no hurry to leave, thank you very much. You will become more patient as you get older or you will just become angry. Most folks, and I am not one of them as my life style was nothing but radical changes, don't like change. It is just human nature for most folks everywhere.

@Novelty It feels like it sometimes. 🙂

@Bierbasstard Most people really don't like change. The majority of Americans were vehemently opposed to Obama Care. They were pissed until they realized it was good for them and their families. I never overestimate the intelligence or courage of people when it comes to big changes.

I've been waiting my whole adult life for M4A, among other things. I am sick of feeling like none of it will happen before I die. It's also depressing to keep getting older and realize that America has only continued to get worse and more unfair since the early 1970s. It's a very hard reality to accept and experience as one's body and mortality are only continuing to decline.

@TomMcGiverin Black people have been waiting for more than 400 years to be treated as equals in this country. We aren't worse since the early 70s. Women, black people, and gay people all have more rights as individuals. It is not there yet but it is better. The health care system will have to be a gradual change as it is incredibly complicated. Bernie wouldn't be able to change it. He wouldn't even get enough Democrats to vote for M4A.

1

Part of the problem, I think, is that all humans have common ground when it comes to basic needs like survival, but different needs when it comes to the various mythologies which have developed over the years. So guaranteed income or universal healthcare get obscured by abortion or capitalistic instincts. The Libertarian Party tries to address the conflict by espousing personal responsibility and a government that does not interfere with human freedom, but the majority are afraid to espouse the unkown, because of laziness, greed, and other undesirable traits. Another aspect of the problem is that in order to actually implement a new order with desirable outcome would require a sort of dictatorship to enforce this new way of being, and the aforementioned undesirable adherents would rebel. In my worldview each of us who wish to live life on our own terms must live in, but apart from society, doing things that are sensible to us, and letting the others exist as they wish as long as they don't interfere with us. I'm not naive, but treasure my innocence...it sustains one in impossible circumstance.

@Novelty I just now read this article, which might address your concerns a bit ... I agree the Libertarians are mostly conservatives hiding behind avoiding the 'moral' issues. I just think it's an example of an attempt to make things different. read this and you' see a clearer picture of my beliefs, which speak to yours as well?
[medium.com]

@Novelty Libertarians are a party for people who don't think Americans are greedy enough.

0

After we get rid of trump

2

Democracy is not flavour of the month right now, if it ever was. I don’t know how the US system works but on the outside looking in it seems very flawed.

3

Unfortunately after Shirley Chisholm's surprisingly strong showing in the 72 election, the Dems/GOP rewrote the rules to the effect of effectively disenfranchising any third party. And since then the establishment has consolidated its hold on power even more. Maybe someone with widespread appeal and world class political acumen could pull it off, but baring a national catastrophe that cripples both parties, seems unlikely to me. 😟

[en.wikipedia.org]

Help me understand this. The Democratic party wrote rules, which only covers themselves, but somehow prevent the existence of a third political party. Am I understanding you?

@BitFlipper The Democrats and Republicans work together to create and maintain a system where third parties face huge obstacles, not a fair playing field on par with the two established parties. One of the classic ways, is if one does get elected, they spike all legislation they propose. Then come re-election, look, a do-nothing legislator! Dirty politics rules in Washington, and the DNC is as deeply entrenched in this swamp as anyone.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:466722
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.