Agnostic.com

42 7

How does the atheist community react or respond to the following for example:

This is Lent right now. A time where we give up something until Easter. I don't feel like its a coincidence that this virus is here during this time of year making us give up so much. Its Gods way of making us go without.

I so often want to say to them that if there was really a god, why has there been no cure yet? Why is "God" letting all these people die? Why is he keeping loved ones apart? There are so many questions and no answers from up above. Really ticks me off.

Meaniebabyinga 5 Mar 25
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

42 comments (26 - 42)

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

Challenge those people!

1

I do not believe in any Gods.
I do not practice Lent.

Your feeling looks to me like simple confirmation Bias.
"I don't feel like its a coincidence" because it lines up with things you already believe, so it is psychologically easier for you to think that than the simple reality.

A virus evolved to live in and eat us. Now we are living with a new microscopic predator which kills us. Welcome to the new reality, at least its not aerosolized Ebola.

1

Why can we not say "I am giving up viruses for Lent" i.e TAKE BACK CONTROL ! HUMAN CONTROL that is.

1

Mysterious ways, duh. 😝

1

Growing up Catholic we followed the rules of Lent but it was no big deal. Later, I realized these 'exercises' may actually be useful. A lot of who we are and what we are able to do start during our childhood. Not giving into temptations in early life can give us (some) a stronger resolve in later life.
Remember the famous experiment where a bunch of children are given a marshmallow and told if they don't eat it while the adult leaves they will get 2 when he returns. Some are able to hold on and some are not. Studies have shown those that are able to wait often do better later in life.

1

Well this is how I react..Why are you in this group? It's for Atheists and Agnostics..I've yet to go to one of your fairy in the sky groups and shove my beliefs down your throats. And organized religion is responsible for more hate, more deaths, more judgements than any group of people I've ever seen outside of your kkks, nazi's and white supremacists. And sometimes there's only a fine line between them and sometimes not even that.

1

god gave us free will, so he wouldn't do that (using their own words).

1

Well i come from a very catholic italian family so we went to church from time to time and practiced those traditions. now i take that kind of stuff lightly when it comes to being with my family. but out of the closet i never go to church. i will never pray or say grace before i eat. i will never say god bless you ever. it pisses me off that i have to keep my athiesm to myself or i would get confronted more. lmao

I know right! Christians just ASSUME your one of
them! Not once when I've been around them in a social setting like a meal and they all want everyone to hold hands and pray have any of them asked me if I was a different religion or even a Christian FFS! So I just quietly..angrily go along offended AF but not wanting to create a scene or be judged or snubbed for not being "one of them". And I didnt want to be grilled about why I wasn't "one of them" either.

@AngelaBaker246 from my experience it has been individuals who are aware of the different faiths so instead of my god or your god. they phrase GOD in general as in everybody worships god meaning they don't think god exist they KNOW he exists and there minds will never change. i have been confronted and lost friendships as soon as i say stuff like im not into praying! im not religious! i see no point in saying grace, fasting from food and regulating myself from different kinds of food. i have to eat to be healthy.

1

Yep, 25,000+ children die from starvation alone on earth. Supporters try and make an excuse with "free will" -- but thats bullsh-t. We are born with our genes, into our environment. Babies born with bone cancer didn't have free will about the situation. A truly good and all powerful god wouldn't let suffering happen, and wouldn't need to be flattered & worshiped!

@TheMiddleWay Those are good points I think that's true that a god might need to be flattered and allow evil . . . that doesn't mean it doesn't exist. But that means it's not a good being. Now if you are talking about some new-age cosmic definition of "God" - thats certainly an idea with millions of interpretations. But I live in America - which is 80% Christian, and they believe in an all powerful being which created us, created our environment, created a place of torture, and demands praise.

@TheMiddleWay Philosophically absolutely such pigeonholing misses a lot. But, what impacts my life here in the McUSA is the Abrahamic religions - Islam, Judaism and of course overwhelmingly Christianity. Hence my more practical challenge as an issue I have to deal with.

The founders of America were of course more of deists, with a bit more of the clockmaker idea. A god creating everything and then stepping back and letting it run itself, not being a puppeteer and interfering with it at all. Still ultimately pretty silly, but easier to swallow than the Bible & Quran.

@TheMiddleWay I love what your little cartoon god said..lol..wish I could share it.

0

It's Lent? Loan me 2$ until the end of the week.

0

How about, "If god thinks that's a good way to teach people a lesson, he's not someone I'd worship."
And of course "there is no god".

0

Im not giving up shit for lent! lol thier is so many more things on my mind to even think about lent.

0

ha well there is a cure, it works great, and it is called "having healthy immunity," which is why 80% are asymptomatic, see, and 90% of the rest will not die.

The family separation and all is on you of course, as is the entire rest of how you choose to experience it, yeh? Be mad at "God" if you like, but wait, arent you an atheist?

ps, "Lent" is some made-up pagan bullshit anyway wadr, not in the Bible anywhere, strictly a pagan-fascist Roman Catholic thing ok. It is not Lent right now for Christians, only for Catholics

0

If god had any power over his precious creation, he wouldn't have sent a deadly virus to make them suffer, unless he's a sorry piece of shit. Come to think of it, that's happened several times since humans have been keeping record. So as far as Lent goes, i don't think the priests had giving the one thing up, being life, what they had in mind... Maybe tp or lysol, but not life. But then again what do I know, I'm not Catholic after all.

@TheMiddleWay if you're saying god sent this virus so we can suffer, so it will teach us or keep us from more suffering later. That's interesting. Comparing parents and kids to god to humans is kinda silly I think, but I'll entertain it for a moment. Let's say that your correct. That would mean a parent, before they conceive, knows that their kids going to have a car wreck at a specific time. Then they still have them, raise them like they don't know, don't tell him. Then when it happens, the parents say, this suffering now will keep you from suffering more later. If god knew all this suffering was gonna happen ahead of time, still let's it happen, and still created them, what does that say about him? It means he's a kid with an ant farm, and he loves to watch suffering, he gets off on it. Believe it or not, i know how god's story goes, i read his autobiography. Thanks for your comment though.

@TheMiddleWay I'm not a parent, but if I was, i wouldn't let my child do things like touching a hot stove, for example. I would simply teach them not to touch it. Teaching and helping doesn't necessarily mean they have to suffer not have pain. I wouldn't let my child play with a gun, then when he shots himself or someone else tell him guns are dangerous and they will hurt you.

I was referring to the book Christians claim god wrote, being his autobiography. I meant god wrote it about as much as the Spider-Man comics books are a historic record of the amazing Spider-Man.

@Meaniebabyinga exactly. You don't have to make an example out of them.

@TheMiddleWay when you have a discussion with a christian about the bible, they claim it's god breathed. That's why I say that. You've said afew times about ghost writers, it doesn't matter. There's alot more different books of the bible originally than is in the bible. The Canaan picked the books for today's bible. Do you think I think Moses wrote about his own death or after his death? Nobody really knows the authors of the books of the bible. All they have are the books to go by. Just that's cool.

If all else fails, experience is all that's left.

If someone asks me if god exists, I'd answer there's not enough for me to believe there's a god. If someone asks me if I believe in god, I'd answer no for the same reason. If they believed and have questions, that's great. I encourage that for sure. But one thing I wouldn't do is not talk or answer them, and tell them to find out for themselves. "Letting them touch the hot stove under my supervision." If that's the way they wanted to learn, that's fine, but it wouldn't be because I wouldn't talk to them. That's with an adult. With a child of my own, i wouldn't let a church indoctrinate them. Once they got older, if they wanted to, sure. As long as they understand that it's make believe.

@TheMiddleWay I was scheduled in Phoenix this year, but they cancelled it. But next year it'll be in Phoenix. I figured philosophy for sure.. lol.

I would never teach the child about other religions, for sure. But i wouldn't let the religious indoctrinate them, like they love to do. They call it, get them while they're young. That's what happens to alot of kids, but it wouldn't to mine for sure.

0

Did your God also cause you to leave out the hyphen in his name? his is an example of bull shit reasoning, or unreasoning. Connection in time does not automatically mean causation.
Also, why does god have to step in and make people do what they should, or would, if they are serious about their adherence to the fairy tale?

0

Well, this god is sure expecting a lot of extra people to go without living during this time, and die a painful, lonely death. And, they don't get to get resurrected a day and a half later.

If you're talking about Lazarus, i thought it was four days, right?

@godlessinal Supposedly it was 3 days; but, per the bible, he died Friday evening and arose the following Sunday. That's roughly a day and a half.

@Joanne oh ok, my bad. I know it says his body had already started to rot by the time he got to him. Cheers🍹

@godlessinal : Well, the bible is full of contradictory stories. That's how we can know it isn't the inspired word of any perfect god with a plan.

@Joanne exactly.

0

Yeah right. 🙄

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:475377
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.