Agnostic.com

13 7

Is anyone here the daughter or son of a minister? My father was a protestant minister, as was his father. I was raised in a "Christian" home. I had what I'd call a very nice, normal childhood, but was raised to believe the New Testament- the Old Testament not so much.

I always questioned everything, like if God loved his son so much why did he have to die on a cross? It made God seem like a vengeful bully but whenever I questioned my father the answers were never convincing. I always doubted.

In my early 20"s I started working with a spiritualist and began reading comparative religious works. I saw Bill Mahar's "Religiosity" which I found compelling and made a lot of sense.

Over the years I came to believe that a personal God was not realistic. Maybe there is a god-like "force"- or maybe I just want there to be for nostalgia. So now I'm agnostic. All religions were made by men, not God, if there is a god. I have three siblings- one is agnostic like me, the other two Christian with one being very over the top Jesus freak.

RikiTikiTavi 4 Apr 15
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

13 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

I find it to be very interesting to see the perspective of people who were very close to their highly religious family members or even in your case those who had family apart of the structure in religious institutions who have lose their faith. Excellent read.

1

As a species we long for safety & security. The world & cosmos is a mysterious place. Our creative ingenuity invents 'comfort blankets' called religion. Who likes being unwrapped from the swaddlings only to discover that all is not what it seems?
We are gods, in charge of our destiny, take the resposnsibility.

1

My father is a retired Anglican (same as C of E or Episcopalian in other countries) minister/priest, as was his father, and his sister's husband. My mother is from a Methodist/Congregationalist background.
I still hold fairly strongly to the ethical side of what I grew up with (do unto others etc), just none of the supernatural stuff any more. Interested in what a secular version of the confession-penance-forgiveness system would look like, and if it would work.

3

Yes, my dad is a pastor. He doesn't care as far as I know they treat me the same. My mother is the only one that tries to give me the jesus scare but she is just a little sad and shocked. I have never been a real Christian so it wasn't a surprise. They know that I don't care about others opinion of me so I've been that black sheep for the longest. I remember they wore young and used to go out and we used to go out dancing, I remember their past alcoholism and all. Nothing has really changed. I don't announce it tho because their followers will probably be more asses then my actual parents.

1

There are no gods as they are all imaginary. I would also avoid spiritualism as I would any other sources of woo.

0

Wow, your parents must have been so disappointed in you.

They were actually very proud because I never discussed my doubts with them. My mom died when I was 26 and my father was so devastated he left the church, which to me showed he never fully believed in any of it either.

3

Was Christian for many years. I remember laughing at Islam for thinking that Mohammed flew to Heaven on a horse but then it hit me that bible says Enoch flew to heaven on a chariot and there was a talking mule. I then realize that my religion was just as crazy as theirs

0

My dad did a stump thing whenever the feeling took him, but he was an atheist. Does that count?

0

some vv i doubt your father ever mentioned, for reflection;
you and your sons will be here with me
No son of man may die for another's sins;
No one has ever gone up to heaven
There is only One Immortal
He who seeks to save his soul will lose it

also, the desire for a God that would require a human Sacrifice is covered in the Esau story, but of course your father would not have wanted to contemplate himself as Esau, and so the story was lost on him, wadr, however, Give me some of that red stew, for I am famished unto death! see

1

The 'final shoe' dropped for me after years of independent study of history and human (particularly destructive) behaviors. With a former attitude that 'religions were the 'keystone at the center of mass and individual mental sickness and destructiveness, something rather simple, almost comical happened to slightly adjust that perspective to my present one.

I noticed two things clearly on display at the top of all the (modern/'civilization) world religions; which I prefer calling theologies. 1. The top several strata of theological hierarchies are all comprised of males, usually elder, with a penchant for aggrandizing themselves with ostentatious attire and absurd heas gear. 2. In kind of a 'back to 1', they being male, propagate a shared idea that at the top of their deities a male god is in charge.

Before about 4500 or so BCE archaeological evidence shows human societies to have been much less warlike. Before agriculture, more like 10,000 years or so ago, we were even more peaceful and even greater evidence shows female parity in social structure and roles. Surviving hunter-gatherer societies in remote areas bear this out, for the most part.

So, for me it isn't religions as the root cause of violence and human suffering, but males being in exclusive 'charge', as we can still see clearly in places like North Africa, Middle East and central Asia.

Exactly. Most religions are based on fear and control- especially control of women.

3

I am the brother of a Presbyterian minister who concluded well into his ministry that he could no longer believe what he was expected to preach and retired as a non-believer.

1

Very close to my own story.

0

Nope. Not me.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:485001
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.