Agnostic.com

5 3

On the PBS Newshour tonight, New York Times columnist David Brooks opined that for Republicans, being anti-gun legislation is not a matter for debate. Rather, like belief in Trump's big lie that the 2020 election was stolen, being against gun control is a Republican talisman, a tribal marker, what T.S Elliot called an "objective correlative."

If Brooks is correct in his analysis, when Republicans say they oppose legislation that would limit access to guns, they are merely signalling their membership in a tribe. And their desire to remain in the tribe, and fear of being ostracized by their tribe, is greater than any desire to be logical, or reasonable, or to protect school children from losers wielding military weapons.

If this is true, then we are truly in a dark place. This is how Nazi ideology swept through Germany in the 1930s.

[pbs.org]

Flyingsaucesir 8 June 4
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

5 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

Now apply your "protect school children from losers wielding military weapons" to USA fomenting trouble & arming insurgents around the world not just with rifles but land & sea mines, rockets, tanks & cruise missiles and you will understand why Russia took action to prevent Russian speaking Ukrainians from fascist genocide in Ukraine.

Tut tut! You're conflating, Russian bear.

@Flyingsaucesir until you acknowledge the fact that they are linked.

@FrayedBear It's really too late to play that card, because Putin already revealed his reason for invading Ukraine, i.e. to reestablish the Russian empire. And Putin justified his actions by denying the existence of a Ukrainian identity, state, or culture. And Russia's overt actions to erase the Ukrainian state and Ukrainian culture constitute genocide. So no surprise that Europe and the USA are helping a European country fend off an illegal invasion by a rogue state. If Putin's Russia doesn't like what's happening in Ukraine, they should get the f**k out. 🙂

@Flyingsaucesir so when you hear your sister\ mother\ other female relative being subjected to disrespect & violence you just walk away?

Putin said he wanted to expand Russia 20 years ago when US governments started plotting to provoke Russia into defending Russian speakers in Ukraine?

Please stop being childish.

@FrayedBear You are trying to defend the indefensible. Even if what you claim were true (there is no evidence that it is) Russia had no right to meddle in the internal affairs of a sovereign nation.

@Flyingsaucesir now you project to protect your fragile brain & ego.

@FrayedBear Better try to sell your psychobabble somewhere else. No one here is buying it.

@Flyingsaucesir do I care?

@FrayedBear 😂

3

On the bright side, David Brooks is almost never right.

1

You see a dark place. I see opportunity.

Opportunity to change many minds from fascistic to democratic?

@Flyingsaucesir Changing the minds of people whose minds can be changed. Ignoring the others.

4

"The Big Lie" is very similar to Hitler's "Stab in the back" myth. A terribly destructive political belief, that may well tear America apart.

Like Putin's "Ukranian Nazis" lie and his "limited military operation" that seems to require massive military resources.

@Petter Limited to less than nucular/nuclear. [grin]

@Petter He didn't invade Ukraine with anywhere near enough troops to conquer it, he's already withdrawn from the large swaths he occupied north of Kyiv, and would be crazy to try and occupy Ukraine. And even if you want to call it propaganda, it's just run of the mill propaganda like that that flows out of Washington in torrents. "Stop the Steal" and "The Stab in the Back" myths are in a much higher league. The only similar one I can recall off hand is Israel's "The Arab governments told the Palestinians to flee" lie.

@yvilletom We hope.

4

And, much more often than not, the shootings serve the GOP purpose of intimidating minorities that lean democrat. Students, Blacks, Hispanics, Jews, and LBGTQ that the GOP would like to disenfranchise, also happen to be the targets of mass shooters. How convenient!!

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:669794
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.