I'm curious.........she didn't know you lacked belief before you started dating? Perhaps , if she did, she mistakenly thought she could change you. Oy vey.

I know your break up was for a difference of spiritual beliefs, but break ups happen for a million reasons. Chock it up to incompatibility and move on...you'll eventually find someone more compatible.

What really made her "uncomfortable" was that your lack of belief was making her question her beliefs. She couldn't handle that. It was easier for her to break up with you than face the fact that she believes in nonsense. Sorry you were hurt by her immaturity and refusal to face her delusions. I think you're better off., but that's just me.

Sorry to hear that but I just pity her judgemental attitude because she's missed out on a good guy.

We're out there! Just keep looking. If I meet someone really religious, that would be a deal breaker for me! Especially if they tried to convert me.

much much better now than later.

I put in my profile on a dating site I am not religious nor am I interested in the very religious. Once trump was nominated I added no trump fans to my profile. The religious may find a non-believer attractive and may think they are okay with it, in the end there is just too much conflict. Sorry you were dumped. I'm sure you'll find someone on this site who may want to come out to play.

Dude you're in Chicago! There's all kinds of interesting women on this site in your area and I'm sure there are also many different non-believer groups on Meetup were you might meet someone more compatible.

You’re probably better off, relationship-wise.

I don't think I could date anyone who is religious. That makes dating in GA really hard.

Some people feel that the only road to a moral compass is religion; sad but true.

Been there. Fucken sucks! The Bible says unequally yoked. That was thrown in my face multiple times.

I've been there. You will be better off. The relationship usually gets very awkward with them because they cannot understand that you deal with facts instead of myths.

your well rid of her if she's that shallow

I'm sorry for your loss.

If that is the case, you really did well to be rid of her. The relationship would have been fraught with conflict.

Walks like a duck quacks like a duck.

Highland Park? I worked in Winnetka for 23 years. Raised in Evanston. Chicago is expansive.

So sorry to hear that but the good news is, there are tons of lovely female Atheists out there, and this is a great place to look for one!

your well rid of her if she's that shallow

If you want her that bad... convert now. Otherwise... move on.

let your heart be sad, yet keep your head the clear & accepting space nature allows it to be - a life is worth nothing under the weight of pretense.

Been there. Been through that.

I am sorry to hear. Though there is a much more wonderful spectacular women out there waiting for you, who believes exactly the same as you.

I think it would be impossible to have a deep meaningful relationship with someone who believes in god. inevitably we would keep running into that wall. good luck in your search.