Agnostic.com

21 6

Isn't happiness just the absence of grief?

Just like peace is the absence of war!

atheist 8 Mar 27

Post a comment Reply Add Photo

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

21 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

8

I think there's a neutral, contented space, and when we experience loss or other hardship we are into the grief space, and when we have something new or exciting or joyful we enter into the happy space. I think it's a continuum, rather than a binary state of being.

5

This question is getting into the semantics zone. Happiness is an antonym of the word grief according to Thesaurus.com. So if that's what you meant then yes your right. But if you are looking for a psychological or philosophical answer then the normal absence of any emotion like grief or happiness is called apathy.

I told my ex when we were separating that the opposite of love is not hate. Hate indicates there is still some emotion there. The opposite of love is indifference or apathy. I didn't have any feelings for him.

5

You can be grieving and be happy. So no is the answer to your question. I once read that happiness was someone to love, something to do, and something to look forward to. It can also be said it is having meaning in your life. Meaningful for me is not going to be meaningful for others.

I may steel that! πŸ˜‰

@Donna_I You may have it with my permission, my blessing, and my thanks that you like it.

@HippieChick58 thank you kindly!

@Donna_I absolutely my pleasure!

@AMGT I cannot begin to imagine the hell that is losing a child. I appreciate your candor and honesty and willingness to share your life, grief, and trauma. Thank you for sharing your story with us, it gives me a totally new perspective to digest.

@atheist I agree with her. One can be happy AND grieving and I draw from personal experience.

@atheist My mother died when she was 45 years old, I was 14. She never got to meet her grandchildren. When I had my babies I grieved anew for so many reasons, that they would never know my mother or her them, and I would not have her guidance to bring up my girls. I was happy to be a mom and have healthy babies, but at the same time missing and grieving the loss of my mom. Now tell me that I was not happy and grieving at the same time. Emotions can be complicated things.

@AMGT I didn't see your post when I left my first comment. If I had, I would first have acknowledged your loss and shown respect for your comment that with the loss of a child, grieving and happy don't connect. My experiences to date draw from other types of grieving. Again, I am sorry for your loss and thank you for sharing.

4

Is not that which was the source of your happiness that is now the source of your grief?

4

Oh, no. I was once clinically depressed and took anti-depressants. Yhey took away the sadness and depression, but made me emotionally dead. I felt nothing and it was horrible. It was worse than the depression.

One of my kids was the same way, REFUSED to take antidepressants. I knew that was a fight I did not want to have with her, I also knew she was right.

Without an SNRI I have no affect and no happiness. It's different for everyone.

@SACatWalker I know the first one I was ever put on was anathema to me.

And I've had various anti-depressant drugs poop out on me as well.

3

There's really sad, relationship break, loss of parent or pet,etc and then there's joy of first meeting, acing a challenging piece of work. Happiness is in the middle. I wake up a happy person, or I use to til this arthritis shit started 18 months ago but still I wake happy.

For some being anxiety free would equal happiness.

3

Happiness has always appeared to me like a big colorful bubble while grief is that small, hard tangle of emotion that ties us down until the thread runs out.

2

Isn't light just the absence of darkness?

No. Light is an actual force/wave/particle. Darkness may be the absence of light on the other hand.

2

I think it’s the other way around- hate is absence of love because when you don’t love, which is fundamental, the void is filled w fakeness. It feels like a paradox might as well let go cuz everyone loves already depends on how much you decide to go w the flow and let go of that which isn’t. Like squeezing your fists at nothing. β€œClosed hands and open arms hold nothing” might as well be open and accepting. Easier said than done uhcourse

@atheist gotcha same principle tho

2

and neither of those are necessarily true..peace is the absence of struggle not just war...I hate peace...it is stagnation. The absence of grief is more than likely psychopathy to which there is no happiness.

2

Sure, by default, but that doesn't define happiness for me.
On a scale of 0 to 10, grief being 0, happiness being 10,
the absence of either would create a 5 imo or 'neutral', neither sad, nor happy.

1

No, that woudl be closer to contentment.

1

Apples and oranges.

JK666 Level 7 Mar 27, 2018
1

No-life is not either/or. Not polar opposites. There is a middle field.

1

No soldiers have fun and laughter in war

it's not ideal by any stretch

not a lot

1

No! Diametric opposites, or close (actually sadness is, which is subtly different from grief). You can be empty & not be grieving, you wouldn't be happy then. & grief, & even sadness, are necessary components to a fully lived life, just as happiness is. We all, or most of us, wish for more of the happiness, but can't avoid the other.

@atheist How could you not? Children can be happy too an extreme & never have experienced any grief, let alone much disappointment. As an adult we appreciate the depths of emotions more & the nuances between them, & learn from the variety, but happiness can exist independently!

@atheist Ah, but might you be blissful before birth?

1

No. I am truly happy when the reality of my connection with someone or something smacks me up side the head. Even when alone there are so many varied and inescapable connections. Too often we suffer under the delusion of our aloneness. The removal of pain or suffering can be wonderful but maybe that's because pain and suffering cause us to turn inward making it easier to ignore those connections and get lost in our own minds.

@atheist Please re-read my comment.

@atheist Could you show me where I say you can be happy and sad at the same time?

1

.. and heads is the absence of tails! But seriously, this dichotomy only simplifies the condition. The passing of my parent gave me x units of grief. Chocolate ice cream can give me y units of joy. So if I eat enough ice cream, I'll get over the death of a loved one. I don't think anybody agrees with that.

1

Good grief! I hope not. ;0

1

In a nutshell, I think quite possibly, you have nailed it.
I don't think it's nearly as complicated as many make it out to be.

0

No. The two are not mutually exclusive.

Write Comment
You candd include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:44649
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.