Though born Pisces, I'd go with the Wind, fluid, changing.

My western sign connects me with earth. Eastern with earth and metal. I would like it to be water, but I know im not anywhere that mutable. Id still venture to say it though, as I feel so at home physically within the water.
I most definitely identify with some fire traits too, but thats the manifestations of all my traumas and mental illnesses. Regardless, its a huge parr of me so for now I will go with 2/3 earth and 1/3 fire lol.

Half Earth, half Wind, if that's a thing. I'm all the supportive and nurturing Earthy stuff but I'm less stubborn and immovable, more tactful and communicative. I also avoid conflict, which I'm told is a wind thing.

Air. I have a tendency to be aloof and intellectual. I love the ocean though. 22 years as a sailor.

Fire .. Under the sign of Aries.. But i am fire everyone says so lol.. I liked the response where someone said, "all of the above" .. think that sums it up for most people. ( don't use or think anything of astrology by the way) .. just think being told you are something all your life can have subtle effects to.

Definitely earth. Probably way too much so.

Fire

Heart! Wait, that's not an option?
I'd say I'm wind. Sometimes you notice its there, sometimes it helps, sometimes its just annoying. Sometimes you wonder where it's gone, and sometimes you never even notice its there.

Hmmmm... I would say earth. That's where I came from and that's where I will return one day. Also, being a mushroom picker, I relate to the earth more than the other options.

I'd say wind. Because I love to fly.

Water. I am pretty adaptable

Fire.
And lots of it.

Earth

A little bit of this and a little bit of that. I can't say, it depends on the circumstances.

Definitely water.

Fire, the source of life and creation.

What about mud? Lol

Is this a astrological thing...... Hmmmmm.

Not too many of us 'Earthy' people here but I guess I am one of them. I have several gardens and like to grow things.

Has anyone heard of the trilogy, Earth, Fire and Water? They are gut wrenching Indian films. And we think things are bad here. They are must see films but they will hurt and make you mad!!

Water is a 2005 Canadian film written and directed by Deepa Mehta, with screenplay by Anurag Kashyap.[citation needed] It is set in 1938 and explores the lives of widows at an ashram in Varanasi, India. The film is also the third and final instalment of Mehta's Elements trilogy. It was preceded by Fire (1996) and Earth (1998).

Too limiting and superficial. We are all those things.

Since you placed the restriction to only one, I can think of a clover way to pick all four and still comply (I am not a lawyer ? ).... Any of the four elements have unique properties I can relate to somehow.... There you go. Cheers !!!

Fire .. Under the sign of Aries.. But i am fire everyone says so lol.. I liked the response where someone said, "all of the above" .. think that sums it up for most people.

Earth

Earth

Well, wind certainly describes what I "do," but I think water... moreover turbulent water fits me the best.