Agnostic.com

37 8

Is an atheist kinder than a believer?
What is your experience?

Wildgreens 8 Oct 29
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

37 comments (26 - 37)

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

I've had the experience of knowing a lot of Scientist's and Engineers most of whom are secular because of where I work, and also Christians because where I live (and work).

I honestly can say most (over 99%) are nice, but i live in an area where greater 80% have technical or business college degrees so its not a random selection. Business people arent so nice though....lol!

Scientists typically 99.999...% nice by my experience. They go out of way to avoid conflict. Though there are wild exceptions.

I have met a more hostile Christians tbh, but they are usually conservative, and some are so horrible sometimes I don't even think of them as Christian, just someone who thinks they are.

I'd have to say that percentage of nice scientists is ridiculously high. Personally I think the real difference is a scientist or atheist isn't going to be unkind and then excise it by blaming their fictitious sky fairy.

My guess is there are more sociopaths masquerading as religious but that is only one or two percent of the population. Even if they were all pretending to be religious (I doubt it) that's not enough to move the needle on atheists being perceived as kinder.

But sociopathy and lack of empathy is a sliding scale IMO. There's a more common certain kind of person who by and large lacks empathy and they definitely gravitate to the god squad. They are a much greater percentage and not having them on "our team" probably changes our perception of ourselves. But the god squad are probably always going to label us as wretched souls definitely not in the "kinder" bucket.

Can you find an objective measure of "kinder"? Probably. How do we rank Vs theists based on those measures? I really don't know.

@MakeItGood I appreciate your observation.

1

My experience is that it makes no difference whatsoever.

Orbit Level 7 Oct 29, 2020
1

I am an atheist, and I know some very religious people who are kinder than I am. At least that is my impression.

1

I have lived amongst Christians my whole life. Some are the nicest people you ever met. Some are assholes. I've only knowingly been around atheists about a decade and a half, and some of them are very nice and I've met a couple of Atheist assholes.
One thing I can't stand about most of the Christians I know is that they will believe anything you tell them, if it fits into their worldview. They will then spread it around their church and beyond. True or not. It makes me crazy that they don't care at all if it's true.

1

Well, speaking personally as one only truly can, Atheists, for the majority part, are somewhat kinder and more caring than the believers possibly because,
A) we are that way simply because we KNOW and understand that it IS the right, correct and decent way to be,
B) we do it because we can and we KNOW that there IS no Sky Daddy watching and taking notes,
C) we know that there are NO rewards awaiting us in some mythical, non-existent After-life, and best of all,
D) IF you're anything like me, you get a kind of warm feeling when you do something for someone in need of help, etc, EVEN if they don't actually thank you for it in so many words.

1

Non believers are definitely more generous than religious people, and also we are smarter. Studies prove both facts. [nydailynews.com]
[independent.co.uk]

1

I'm trying to answer this and cannot really. It's because I do not know. To me some atheists are stupid. These are the ones who cannot believe in gods but yet do believe in spirits and people on other planets, also thinking spacemen were our early "gods." The reason I call this stupid is because suddenly there are several things all at once to not have evidence for. This type of reasoning is why Scientology caught on with so many. You know, the religion started by an alcoholic science fiction writer.

Back to your original question. I'm not so sure I can answer it. I do believe that the kinder people are those who are not always making stuff up.

I think there is a nuance that religion tends to undermine. Many religions have a good deal of black/white thinking. A person is either good or bad, on the right path or on the wrong one, etc. Without these belief systems, we are free (or freer) to dislike some things about them and appreciate other qualities they have.

1

Being an atheist/agnostic does not make you better or worse than anyone else. So much is based on the individual and the circumstances.

0

I agree with what Ramona said about kindness not really being a reflection of ur religious views. But I find atheist to generally be as or more judgemental and condescending. And just for reference scroll through some posts here and see how many times u see fairy tales, stupid, close minded, simple minded, brainwashed, and indoctrinated mentioned to describe Christian's. And being offended by some that says bless your heart or merry christmas. And while I agree with some of those sentiments, I don't feel the need to go around constantly voicing said opinions. IMO if the phrase in god we trust, or merry christmas offend you, ur just as closed minded as Christian's ur judging. I know that's kinda different discussion, but feel they r closely related

0

Not necessarily but I can tell you some of meanest and coldest people I’ve ever met were in church and some of nicest in bars. It seems to me that non-Christians aren’t nearly as nosy and judgementsl

0

My experience is that many believers are more polite and respectful than the non believers I know by far.

with yourself being the exception 😉

@Varn oh no. I can be an absolute dick bag.
I’ll admit it.

0

Which one?

skado Level 9 Oct 29, 2020
Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:547885
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.