Agnostic.com

14 3

Why did God hate Esue? I never got that story.

And I thought God couldn’t hate. It even says when a person hates someone, that is just as bad as murder so what is the deal with him hating? God willingly allowed Jacob to steal Esue’s Blessing. That story always pissed me off, plus it was very hypocritical of God to hate something he created, considering Christians say God can’t hate or lie or destroy anything he created.

By EmeraldJewel7
Actions Follow Post Like

Post a comment Add Source Add Photo

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

14 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

I've never read it so forgive me. Don't worry about it. I forgive myself. Reminds me of a piece of pseudo philosophy from a film, 'I don't hold grudges. I'm too good for that'.

tellyrus Level 5 Dec 25, 2017
1

Do Christians really say that there are things God can't do?

Coffeo Level 7 Dec 21, 2017
1

The winner always write the story in his favor, whether it is a country after war or a person. It is a fairy tale written by someone who wanted Jacob to look good thus putting the blame on God in order to make it just,

noworry28 Level 7 Dec 20, 2017
0

Erm - same reason god hates non-believers and homosexuals? Because he's an obnoxious, judgemental, bigotted cunt?

ToakReon Level 7 Dec 20, 2017

I agree! Coulnt stand that guy!!!

1

The whole bible contradicts itself.

Yes. And it is insane how people like John Lennox defends it.

Yep.

1

Jesus said that if you don't hate your brother your not loving jesus enough (luke 14:26). I get a lot of contradictions from this book.

1

I think from an anthropological view, as how humanity developed, it symbolizes the conflict of the hunter gatherer and the later evolving farmers. Esau was the hunter, Jacob the younger, only by minutes as they were really twins, was the farmer. Esau was pushed to the side as the firstborn ... as to God's role in this, as another here commented, God does change throughout the bible, reflecting what relationship people had with this God.
[biblegateway.com]

ZebZaman Level 6 Dec 20, 2017
1

This question reminds of Greek tragedy story stuff. The Bible never even has to justify "God's attitude about anything. God is portrayed as beyond reproach. We mere humans are not to question God. I always took this story as more of a question of the human father Isaac's attitude toward his sons. Of course, he loved Essau but was tricked by Jacob's mother and by Jacob into receiving Isaac's blessing. Poor ol' God had no choice but to follow Isaac's lead and go ahead and shower blessings on Jacob --ooh, that wascally wabbit! This is, of course, absurb fiction.

Another point: culturally, children weren't actual individuals in their own right; they were merely the property of their fathers, at least while their fathers lived and they were a part of the father's household. "God" would naturally reward or punish Jacob and Essau roughly in accordance with how their father, Isaac, set the stage for that. God, in a sense, gets reduced to a Genie in a bottle or a parlor trick. Aw, sad; and here we thought "he" was the almighty creator and ruler of the universe! LOL

2

God can't hate because the stories are made up and the god of the stories does not exist.

Betty Level 7 Dec 19, 2017

Ha ha ha!

1

They play with the definition of hate to try to justify the phrase...
Saying it means loves less... ????

Buddha Level 7 Dec 19, 2017
1

This is a fabulous and instructive question. I am writing exclusively as literary criticism and without respect to any God or deity. Notice that Esau, a "wild ass of a man" was an impetuous youth. Today he probably would have been given Ritalin.

But when they became adults, the situations were reversed. Esau became the gentleman's gentleman, forgiving his estranged brother unconditionally. While Jacob and his brother-in-law spend their time trying to pick each other's pockets. Jacob was favored by Rebecca, his mother, over Esau, because he could be counted on to not marry a Canaanite woman. This was the point of the story; the journey to escape idol worship, human sacrifice, temple prostitution, stuff like that.

andygee Level 7 Dec 19, 2017
1

The inconsistencies of the bible. Some will say it is hyperbole, you can't take everything in the bible literally, after all god is love. And other preachers will say that the translation is wrong, that it really means Jacob was more highly favored than Esau. But again, what did Esau do to deserve that. The god is capricious.

1

I don't remember this one. Are you sure you have the name right?

I think she means Esau, the elder brother of Jacob. If I recall, he was in line for his father Isaac's blessing on his deathbed, but Esau's mother and Jacob conspired against him so Jacob would receive the blessing (but the story of how they did so is incredibly stupid).

Oh right.. They literally pulled the wool over the father's eyes.

Yes! That’s the name I was meaning. I always messed up spelling that name.

@EmeraldJewel, no worries, I had to look it up to be sure, too. smile001.gif

1

Awww shucks... I don't know!

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text 'q:9246'.
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content read full disclaimer.
  • Agnostic.com is a non-profit community for atheists, agnostics, humanists, freethinkers, skeptics and others!