Agnostic.com
11 3

I've an ethical question . A few years back , my backyard neighbor , came to me , and demanded I cut down my mature trees , along our shared fence ( Oleanders ) . I told her I like the shade and privacy they provided and love to see the flowers . They were planted more than thirty five years ago , long before I bought this place , and are a part of the reason I found it so attractive . I told her no , I wasn't cutting down my trees . She complained they were tired of raking up the leaves from ny trees . The mowing service they hire attaches a bag to the side of their mower , that vacuums up the grass cuttings and leaves . They've never raked their yard . Three days later , I saw through the fence , that they had put new plants in . We had an exceptionally cold winter that year . I lost several oleanders that had been growing along the fence , exactly where she wanted me to cut mine down . The plants they had put in , were a pomegranet tree , a peach tree , and a grapefruit tree . They cut down their pomegranet tree because they had planted it so close to the fence that it was trying to push it over . One of the oleanders that died , had a small sprout at its' root , that was healthy , so I removed the dead oleander and fed and watered the sprout , which is now doing well . The fig tree growing next to it , on their side of the fence , is exsatic about the extra fertilizer and water and is now happily producing heavily , where it had been producing very little previously . They never harvested it , but the squirrels usually did . When it's dry , my sprinklers are watering both my plants and theirs , and I routinely fertilize my red tips and crepe myrtles along the fence . In the past couple of years they planted some kind of vine that grew up both their trees and mine , producing some kind of melon , which dropped off and rotted in my yard , so I began tossing them gently over the fence into their yard . This year not only are the melons in my yard but they've also planted a vine that crossed over the fence and is producing an abundant crop of some kind of long pod on my side of the fence . So the question is , do I let their crops rot in my yard , gently toss it across into their yard , or simply harvest it ?

Cast1es 9 July 17
Share
You must be a member of this group before commenting. Join Group

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

11 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

Harvest it of course, you can also prune anything that crosses onto your property, however I suggest that you do this only conservatively as you don't want to start a war.

0

I would harvest it.

Arshi Level 5 July 18, 2018
2

In most places it is usually legal to harvest or cut back anything that is growing into your property. I would harvest anything I wanted and throw back what I didn't.

CeliaVL Level 7 July 18, 2018
4

Possession is 9/10 of the law, although you could always offer to sell her a few melons to be neighbourly.

Surfpirate Level 9 July 17, 2018
4

I am not sure about your local laws. Where I live, it is legal to harvest and prune anything that comes over the property line.

Thank you !

That actually comes from British Common Law and is pretty well the case in all English speaking nations and jurisdictions.

4

If it is on your side of the fence harvest it. If is growing in your tree harvest it.

Donto101 Level 7 July 17, 2018

There were quite a few responses to my question , but yours is the first I've seen to answer the question that I asked . Thank you !

1

can't put in my two-penworth as I have never seen an oleander tree or a peach pomegranate or grpaefruit tree.

jacpod Level 8 July 17, 2018
2

Sorry guys . Having computer misbehaven' problems . It cut me off , in mid post , then did something even weirder when I tried to edit it , then poshe completed message as if I were answering someone elses' post . Still trying to get it all together .

Cast1es Level 9 July 17, 2018
2

I think in most places they're allowed to cut back the trees right up to the property line.

cmadler Level 7 July 17, 2018
0

What's your question? Do you think she killed your trees? Or do you think winter killed them and want to replant?

Honestly , I have no way of knowing if the trees were killed either by her hand or by the weather . This is not the first or only time , she has decided though , that I was the root of whatever she felt was wrong in her life , and I needed to fix her problem , immediately .

1

This post seems to be lacking the "question" you meant to ask.

Sorry , was having computer temper tantrum problem . It cut me off and planted my post somewhere else altogether . I'm trying to mend it , still .

Write Comment