8 1

What is your opinion of Nicola Sturgeon’s call of yesterday, to Scottish MSPs , for Indyref2 by time of the Holyrood elections in 2021. This, she says, is to preserve devolution and to protect Scotland’s place in Europe.

Posted in @Macnostics too.

Marionville 10 Apr 25
You must be a member of this group before commenting. Join Group

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account


Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.


I met Alec Salmond in the CO OP last night stocking up with cakes... anyway.
As for wee Nicki - Referendums are a reserved matter for Westminster. What is missing in the Nationalist argument are social effects of separation from a union that began to happen when King James VI of Scotland became King James I of Britain, then the act of Union 1707. The FUBAR of trying to separate from the EU has in three years shown how just four decades of union is proving painful. Thus attempting to disengage over four centuries of integration is going to be far harder. History has shown in recent years the nationalistic conflicts that have arisen in places like the Balkans and ex-Soviet Union are a potential outcome.
Recent polls indicate a lack of appetite for more political conflicts. But the SNP cannot leave it alone. There may well be a fear in Nationalists that if they don't win a referendum soon, they could suddenly sink back to last century levels support wise.
With the current Conservative government, there is a real potential for them to overturn the Sewell convention permanently as they have done with the EU withdrawl bill. Theresa May is psychologically unable to 'listen' to the opinions of others and her probable replacements don't seem to understand 'England' doesn't have an Empire anymore.
As for myself, I would fully support a Federal Scotland (and Northern Ireland, Wales, England and London), but not Scotland as an independent nation state.

Sofabeast Level 7 Apr 26, 2019

Last time round I had no skin in the game. I know from a few people in the oil industry north of the border that some of the Independence propaganda totally misrepresented the future of North Sea oil but beyond that I didn't really take much interest. I chuckled when the Independence campaign were attacked on the basis that Scotland might lose their place in the EU through independence and the reply came back that they might lose it by staying if the Brexit vote went the wrong way. No one I knew at the time took that counter argument seriously. However since the initial argument was a significant campaigning point and has now been reversed I see a strong argument to revisit the question. In the new context they might also have to consider if they have room for 48% of the rest of the UK.

MattHardy Level 7 Apr 26, 2019

Surgeon? I thought her name was far fishier, like her politics.
Seriously, if the UK remainers get a second referendum, then fair play, precedent, and logic all dictate Scotland shoild get a second independence referendum.

Petter Level 9 Apr 25, 2019

Misspelling...should have read Sturgeon. Apologies for that! As they called out in Braveheart....”Freedom”!

@Marionville I see it is now corrected! The grammar and spelling police may chalk up another victory!!! 😀


I don't have strong feelings about Scottish independence except that I am in favour of any group which sees themselves as a nation being independent if a majority want to be. I thought her biggest problem at the moment was that there isn't a majority for independence. If she calls indyref 2 and loses, what then? That's how I fel about a second brexit referendum, too. If remainers manage to call a second vote and leave wins again, what are they going to do - call a third? When i was in politics, the leader of my group frequently reminded us that you don't ask a question in public unless you know what the answer is going to be!

CeliaVL Level 7 Apr 25, 2019

I think she’s a very shrewd politician, whatever she is doing it will be well thought through.

@Marionville I think that is right. She is not going to make a stupid error!

@CeliaVL let’s hope So.

The only reason indy failed was because we were told the only way to stay in the EU was to remain in UK. So, many were voting to stay in the EU, not the UK, that was just the price. of staying. Well now the prize might be lost so why would we still be paying the price. If we want the EU we have to ditch the UK and there will be no lies accepted.

@CeliaVL Oh she's a very canny lass.

@Savage Exactly! The Tory party renaged on the very thing that kept the Scots from voting to leave. I'll be sad to see you go but good luck!

@Paul_Clamberer I actually live in england, for my sins but if brexit happens I will be heading north. Then once Scotland rejoins the EU I'll be moving to France, following my young son, dragged off by his french mother over brexit.


Sounds reasonable. Scotland wants to stay in Europe and independence from the fools in Westminster would be their best chance.

Red_Cat Level 7 Apr 25, 2019

Just putting Pressure on Mrs May. She does need it. Destroying the Union would be a big step

Mcflewster Level 8 Apr 25, 2019

I don’t think you can lay that at Scotland’s door. I’d say Brexit lies fair and square as the catalyst for any break up.


Absolutely brilliant. If the UK brexits I'm immediatly aiming to move north and wait for my Scottish EU passport. After that I'm moving to France where my EX ran off with my young son due to brexit. Too late for us as she has a new fella but I will be close to my son, he will know his Dad.

Savage Level 7 Apr 25, 2019

Yes...I think it’s looking like the beginning of the end for the UK as we know it. Farage and Widdicombe are standing for election in this new Brexit party...the lunatics are back, and will soon be running the asylum....let me out!!


Hmmm... bit of a constitutional dilemma, as Westminster has to approve any referendum. As a bit of a soft southern leftie, I dread the thought of Scotland leaving and increasing the strength of the Tory gerrymander in England.

Screw their approval, Scotland will not take no as an answer. The only thing that kept Scotland in the UK was being told it was the only way to stay in the EU. So, we will not take no for an answer.

@Savage How dare they try to stop us! The Scots need to have the courage to leave this time, instead of wimping out like the last time. The idea that we need this bunch of cretins In Westminster to show us how to run our own county is unbelievable nonsense. We largely ran the British Empire and were the ones who pioneered and founded cities and territories through the world in the name of the British Crown.

@Marionville They need to keep in mind, 80% of the SAS are Glaswegian. 😉

@Savage you also host Trident, the North Sea refineries and two nuclear power stations. That might also make things interesting.

@MrBeelzeebubbles True...the Scots want trident removed from the Holy Loch.

@MrBeelzeebubbles I know only two well about Trident. My old protest Bus is at Faslane camp and when you put your head out the sun roof you can see straight across the Loch to the subs. Scotland will be very glad to see the back of them. And the nuke power stations I'm very aware of. My father was electrical foreman when some twat wired a pump the wrong way round and started pumping radioactive waste into the sea instead of pumping seawater in. For 6 months, FFS before anyone noticed. The north coast by Dounrey is still radioactive over 50 years later.

@Savage the company I work for does the safety testing for the AGR's at Tourness and Hunterston. Also got some of the contracts for decommissioning Dounrey. It's going to take a long, careful, systematic and thorough process to clean up that site. And we ain't cheap.

@Savage Which should prevent SAS interfering!

@MrBeelzeebubbles Yeah, I know how bad Dounrey is, a dark stain on my family through my shit father. Stay safe and do a good job. And if no one else does, I'll appreciate it.

Write Comment

Recent Visitors 25

Photos 58 More

Posted by MoravianTory Corruption ?

Posted by MoravianA Tory Christmas carol

Posted by MoravianAny takers

Posted by MattHardyA Boris promise is just a lie that hasn't happened yet. Whatever Sue Grey says, no way is Boris going to admit he lied and resign.

Posted by MoravianJacob Rees Mogg is one of my least favourite people in the world.

Posted by MoravianBoris certainly has his finger on the pulse

Posted by webspider555No trump to take the spotlight off him now

Posted by MannanWhat do you think.....?hahaha

Posted by McflewsterEVERY BORIS SPEECH []

Posted by MoravianPolitics in the UK

Posted by webspider555All set to go well with the vaccination roll out

Posted by webspider555Vaccine already in production

Posted by webspider555If Boris is mentioned then I cannot rule out it being true

Posted by HawkeyeNew to this group, thanks for having me :) Thought I would share something that has had my poor wee atheist brain turning for a few days (the article is a few days old).

Posted by McflewsterWhere Religion ,Monarchy and Private Education meet. Taken from the Book "BOY" by Roald Dahl "Tales of Childhood" []

Posted by webspider555I’m beginning to wonder whether our government is just incompetent or are all these things happening just to get us in a rage arguing amongst ourselves.

  • Top tags#video #world #hope #government #religious #god #religion #church #DonaldTrump #Atheist #BBC #vote #atheism #reason #friends #death #politics #money #children #laws #agnostic #fear #community #book #minister #Christian #media #belief #society #rights #parents #dogs #faith #cats #beliefs #hello #Jesus #politicians #truth #Australia #weather #movies #Christmas #wife #conservative #Wisdom #Song #kids #USA #Europe ...

    Members 383Top