Agnostic.com

12 1

Is nationalism a way for a group of people to strive towards a common goal, or mearly glorifying geographic lines so that some will benefit from lucky births while not having to share resources and opportunity with the greater populace?

Let's talk people.

View Results
Lifestone 5 July 4

Post a comment Reply Add Photo

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

12 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

Nationalism is a false pride.

3

Borders are imaginary lines that allow people to group together with a commonality. They can be both good and bad, just like individuals. Taking pride in yourself does not mean you need to belittle others, nations are no different. You can do well for yourself and lift others up at the same time.

There are two ways to have the tallest building in town...

In my mind I don't do borders. Unfortunately I have to have a passport from a particular country etc but I consider myself a citizen of earth and I'd like to think I'd be at home anywhere on it. Just leave me to my delusions I don't hurt anybody ?

2

Irish nationalism has been anti imperialist and left wing. It is not anti-migrant or supremicist. During the euphemistically named troubles, some nationalists up North took a strong and valid grievance against an apartheid state way too far. There were bombs that killed civilians including children. The unionist population could be considered British nationalists. Many supported an apartheid state. The British government, in addition to commiting war crimes directly (google Bloody Sunday) colluded with vicious unionist paramilitaries.I guess my point is that all nationalisms are not the same. High minded opposition to us and them mentalities is more difficult if you are one of the opressed in category "them'" I say this as a reluctant nationalist who likes the principle of there being no us and them and who harbours no hatred for any nationality.

Fantastic post. As you say, there are different Nationalisms. Ireland a very good example, compared to England or Palestine compared to Australia.

1
1

Nationalism, like religion and two sides of the same coin, is basically an us vs. them mentality.

2

Moderate nationalism (pride in being a citizen of a country and in the principles undergirding the country is a plus. But, extreme nationalism -- ethnocentrism, racism, denigration of other, seeking dominance over others or exploiting them, and expansionism at the expense of others countries -- is destructive and repulsive. Trump's "America first" (placing international relations in a win lose" context) is an obnoxious form of aggressive nationalism.

1

The wave of nationalism sweeping the UK is dragging us out of Europe for entirely the wrong reasons. I don't have a definite side to take on all that, neither do most people here, the real benefits or problems with it don't get a mention in the press for those of us who aren't practised economists. All I hear about is immigration, which is a non issue. Just like the US we're sliding backwards at the moment.

Salo Level 7 July 4, 2018

I have been in Australia for 11 years now and feel quite sad with regard to what I still regard as my Homeland. It looks a steady decline into lawlessness and anarchy from a distance. I content myself with Midsomer Murders and Father Brown as that is the England I relate too. Pollyanna I know, but it soothes this Bear of Little Brain.

@Geoffrey51 It looks like.it might get worse. Who knows what sort of deal/No deal well end up with. If the hardliners get their way I'm led to believe were going to very quickly.find ourselves screwed. But otherwise we may find we have a brexit thays just a name with all manner of ties and regulatiins still in place. This could lead to dissent from the remnants of the massive (51%?) majority who'll feel cheated out of their voting rights. Or worse still from their perspective would be a 2nd referendum that failed. Though it's probably too late for that. Either way it's going to get uglier.

3

Nationalism is sticking your tongue out at your neighbours and shouting "we're better than you!".

I agree with Einstein. Nationalism is an infantile disease.

1

Short answer? It's both.

2

Nationalism is the fervor of the fanatic

2

Gets the racists to vote

3

I have no use for nationalism or patriotism.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:122415
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.