Agnostic.com

19 1

So my wife and I almost got divorced over the summer. I had an emotional affair as my needs weren't being met and there seemed to be no fixing it. We're now trying to work it out, but I'm worried. Hell, I'm not even welcome in our bed; I sleep in the living room on an air mattress.

We have two kids who are my world, but I can't help feel like it's doomed. Advice?

Reason1984 3 Sep 2
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

19 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

Focus on the kids and stop thinking with your dick. Look at how you feel towards your wife and how she feels about you. If you or her decide you aren't good together move on with your relationships and stay a father to your children. If you try to "stay together for the kids" it will just make things worse in the long run....

0

You had an affair. What do you want me to say?

1

My concerns were always dismissed. Sex was withheld for over a year. I tried to get us into counseling about 4 years ago. It worked...for about 3 weeks. I bonded with a co-worker who was going through similar stuff and we began an emotional affair that we both came to regret. I told her that we needed to go back to our spouses and really work on things; we are both doing that now.

Our first counseling session this go round (with a much better counselor) went AMAZINGLY well. We're already 10x better.

Thanks to those here who didn't belittle and kept an open mind. Your support here is very appreciated.

0

Ok so, this summer you basically cheated in a manner that is worse than if you hired a hooker one time. It’s fall and you think you should be allowed to be back in the bed? Why aren’t you thinking about your wife’s feelings? If my husband did what you did, he would be contritely eating shit for the next 6 months and it would take years to regain that trust. You really got your just desserts. Sleep on that air bed and deal with it, and instead of focusing on what you are feeling, try to find out why she wasn’t “meeting your needs”? Perhaps you were doing something or not doing something that made her withdraw.
I stopped having sex and conversation with my husband when he continued not to do housework equally and when he would go off drinking with his buddies spending MY money as he earned less than me and let me carry the bills. All women have their reasons for withdrawing from her partner.

Livia Level 6 Sep 3, 2018
3

I had an emotional affair near the end of my marriage. I wasn't looking for it, but when it became available to me, I found it impossible to say no. I had been neglected in every conceivable way for years. And I did everything in my power to try to connect with him. After marriage therapy morphed into divorce therapy morphed into individual therapy, my therapist was shocked that I didn't have an affair years ago.

I'm not telling you this because I have advice for you, you've already said you're starting counseling. I just thought if you knew you weren't alone, you might feel a little better. And if people want to shame you without walking in your shoes, feel free to tell them to fuck right off. We all have a path to travel. I wish you luck on yours. I hope you find a way to get your needs met, whether that's with or without your wife.

I have to admit I found a couple of people's responses here very harsh and unempathetic it's very easy to judge others when it's just words on a page we might want to keep in mind that we're all just human beings here and that when people write here they're still real human beings behind the words and without having a full and complete story there's no reason to tear somebody a new a** just because you have this better-than-thou attitude

1

Not enough data to give a detailed opinion. An emotional affair was not the way to handle it. You probably ought to explore why you couldn't simply discuss it. "My needs aren't being met, this isn't working for me, we need to talk it out." If you were simply afraid to confront it that's arguably one thing, if you didn't want to, then that's a bit of a red flag.

If you're not given to polecatting then maybe you just drifted into something inappropriate by slow degrees without really consciously planning it; on the other hand, following the path of least resistance was not a good idea, as you already have noticed.

Hopefully your wife will, after cooling down, own her own role in this (she has one, even if it's arguably the smaller one) and will talk with you. You might need a referee of some kind (marriage counselor perhaps).

Good luck. It might end up being a good thing and a positive turning point for the relationship; it might be the end. Depends on a lot of things, some of which aren't under your control.

3

Be Dad regardless. Sometimes parents function better separately.

0

I just have to ask,everyone keeps using that phrase,what exactly is an emotional affair. Does that mean you were just like hanging out with the other person for like emotional support or did you actually do the naughty

It is emotional intimacy short of sexual intimacy but involving the kind of deep sharing and all-night discussions and flirtatious admiration that are normally confined to marriage or if not will provoke jealousy in most partners.

It is also known as "mental cheating" as in feeding a cheating fantasy even if you don't act on it. Some people consider it as disloyal as actual sex; I tend to be one of those. I think if my wife were spending half her nights away having intimate conversations with a guy I'd feel about as betrayed as if they were having full on gorilla trampoline sex. It's the principle of the thing. Either love me or leave me, as the old song goes.

@mordant thanks for the response had never heard that term before i was just curious about exactly what it meant I wish you the best though and I hope everything turns out okay

@Drsmash253 I'm a commenter, not the original poster. But that's okay ... I wish him the best too.

@mordant oops

@Drsmash253 Gorilla trampoline sex sounds great! Hahah, made me chuckle!

@Livia I have to admit that paints quite the picture in my mind's eye

0

Every story is different. There are things you both will have to figure out yourselves. I hope things will work out, there are plenty of possibilities. Regardless the outcome, you both will ALWAYS be the parents and that's the most important piece of the puzzle you need to focus on. What can be done to help them go through tough times and what not to do to hurt them. Hope it helps

1

You both as a couple and individually need to go to counseling to deal with this. BTW...be prepared to get treated like shit, cuz you're a man. Now if tables were turned, it would still be your fault for not being sensitive to her needs and emotions. Such a double standard misandric society we live in.

Sounds like you didn't physically cheat, and was seeking someone to connect with emotionally? So her answer to the problem is kick you out of your bed and be more emotionally distant? What steps is she taking to work on her failures as a wife that made you feel you had to seek closeness to someone outside of your marriage? BTW...if the the affair was with a he, would you call it an emotional affair, or just a good friendship you were close too and trusted?

To many unknown variables for anyone here to really have any legitimate input, IMO.

0

I'm no expert... but I think the question is, do you honestly want to continue to have a relationship/marriage with this person or not? If you feel like you would rather move on and turn a new page, then I'd work on respectfully getting a divorce, dealing with this change with yourself, kids, and wife... and end with hopefully, peace, love, and respect for each other.

0

Leave. You are prolonging your misery. In my 63-year life I've never seen a patched marriage that was more than convenience, an occasional fuck, devoid of lovemaking, love, tenderness, trust.

0

Awwww, your poor widdle personal needs not being met justified your total betrayal of the relationship? Too bad so sad, maybe you can get some counseling on how to be a Man?

If it was a woman who did this, it would be considered the guys fault for not being sensitive to his wife's problems. He has just as much of a right to have emotional support from his wife as she does from him. Sounds like they both need some counseling, individually and as a couple. But without specific details on the couple's personalities and relationship dynamics, and a definition of what an "emotional affair" entailed in this case, we can only speculate and project our own ideas into the discussion.

@Crimson67 I WAS the cheated-on wife! And I was there for him in every way, while he made up excuses to screw every thing moving. I was Very lucky to not catch something, according to our mutual doctor (who could not of course say much, but Strongly recommended I get tested......)
It is not just simple, nowadays...and promise-breakers, such as cheaters, never change, because it is Always about them!

@jondspen, @Crimson67 well...thanks, I guess. ?

@jondspen "if it was a woman who did this..." sorry, cheating/lying/withholding is gender-neutral!

There's a difference between a physical affair and an emotional one. You were repeatedly cheated on. That sucks, I'm sorry that happened to you. But your projecting is ugly, unhelpful, and unnecessary.

Personally, a man who can recognize his emotional needs is more of a man than one who fucks whatever he can. Maybe you should spend a little more time reflecting on what your emotional needs might be, instead of tearing down other people who are looking for help. I mean, aren't you the one who told me to stop wasting my time being angry about the past?

@Nottheonlyone What exactly does a marriage consist of, if not mental connection...just ask anyone who perhaps the physical side has faded due to age, infirmity, but the mental bond remains strong. He has removed himself from his partner in a way that is Devastating! A one-night stand, while pathetic, is in no way the major betrayal taking your emotions "on the road " is.....and of course his partner wasn't feeling abandoned, alone, bereft.......oh, nooooooooo......if he could " recognize his emotional needs", and had any respect whatsoever for his Partner, he would have worked on things With her.
The thing that really tops it all off is his expecting our support for his selfish, self-centered actions, and whining about it!

@AnneWimsey There's no evidence here that he didn't work on things with her. Clearly, you felt abandoned, alone, bereft... And you're projecting your feelings onto his wife. He said there seemed to be no fixing it, implying that he did try. You have zero context, but your judgmental tendencies are on fire. I hope someday you find happiness of your own.

@Nottheonlyone i do appreciate the good wishes, in actuality I am living a wonderful life, with boyfriend, money enough, president of a social club, 4th term , etc. All of which was made possible by the cheater, and I have written him a heartfelt letter of gratitude, several years ago.
But right is still right, and wrong will Always be wrong, and whining about how "poor you" was cmisunderstood will Always, ever, make my blood boil, so please stop projecting on my behalf!
I worked in a shipyard amongst 20,000 men for 13 years, the way it is Always about the cheater never ceased to amaze!

1

It will take time and patience, you have betrayed her trust. The fact that she has allowed you even sleep in the same house is positive. If you felt your emotional needs weren’t being met did you not try talking about it with your wife. I have been around a long time and have heard all the stories I ever wish to hear from about who are not having their needs met. I bet you told the other woman that your wife didn’t understand you! Is there a text book that you guys read? My advice is...talk to each other, most marriages get stale at some point after children come along, women are programmed to concentrate on child rearing for a few years, it sometimes makes their partner feel neglected but discussing how both of you feel and supporting each other gets you through this. Going off and having an affair is definitely not the answer. Now you will have to put up with a gradual journey back into your wife ‘s good grace again, and learn from this mistake.

0

Keep everyone happy by deception. Secretly go back to having an affair without your wife knowing. That's what I would do

Don’t be a complete ass.

@Spudnut I'm not married and I don't believe in marriage or the concept. But if I were married I'd probably not be here having this conversation or be thinking the way I do now.

0

Do you want the marriage, or are you just staying for the kids? If you just want to stay for the kids, then go ahead and get a divorce. If you could cheat so easily on your wife, it's not a certainty she'll ever trust you again.

Married men are always coming to me with their "problems" with their wives, but I just laugh at them, knowing they are just angling to get some action on the side. I would never date such a man.

2

Counseling is a good idea, and I’m sure you’ll be asked about what changed, and when. The kids are your world? Then where does your wife fit in? And does their being your world mean you do as much daily parenting as she does, including housekeeping and monitoring social calendars and school projects? She likely has needs, too.

UUNJ Level 8 Sep 2, 2018

She probably does and like all parents is exhausted

5

We start counseling tomorrow. ?

Glad to read it . I started going to counseling , and eventualy was told to bring my husband . He said no . Nothing changed . I did.

Own what you did. It is fine to say there are things you need that she was not providing but own the fact that instead of having a true conversation with her, to find out why you made the huge, but common mistake of withdrawing and filling it somewhere else.

2

I second counseling. My ex had a few emotional affairs ... always found a way to weasel himself out of counseling.

@JustKip that is correct! Among other reasons...

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:170275
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.